New QB Ratings should be in NCAA 2010

[DougAlvarez]

I understand that Madden is the bigger seller, but NCAA is the better game, why is EA unable to give NCAA the fair treatment every year? I just don't understand sometimes...

[Gossennator]

Probably because the Madden team came up with the great idea and they dont want the NCAA team to get credit for it.

[BSherrod]

Nope, OMT said time was spent on other features. Though they are competitors I'm sure the dev teams arean't petty like that.

[jdrhammer]

I listened to the podcast from NCAA Utopia and I think they mentioned the most likely reason was because they couldn't rate 500-600 QB's in NCAA where it's a much smaller number in Madden. I think Rhombic was on there but I can't remember.

[Boucher]

Quote: Originally Posted by BSherrod

Nope, OMT said time was spent on other features. Though they are competitors I'm sure the dev teams arean't petty like that.

Ding Ding

[the onizzle]

Quote: Originally Posted by boucher

Ding Ding

It's pretty funny when Adam says "this is why not", but still people speculate otherwise. No crack at any one individual, but when Adam says "we included a different feature instead", then they chose to do that over the one they left out. It's OK if the games are a little bit different! So far NCAA has been promised to have probably 80-90% of the 'goodies' we've heard about Madden.

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by jdrhammer

I listened to the podcast from NCAA Utopia and I think they mentioned the most likely reason was because they couldn't rate 500-600 QB's in NCAA where it's a much smaller number in Madden. I think Rhombic was on there but I can't remember.

Nope OMT said that had nothing to do with there decision to do something else.

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by the onizzle

It's pretty funny when Adam says "this is why not", but still people speculate otherwise. No crack at any one individual, but when Adam says "we included a different feature instead", then they chose to do that over the one they left out. It's OK if the games are a little bit different! So far NCAA has been promised to have probably 80-90% of the 'goodies' we've heard about Madden.

Im just wondering about importing draft classes. I disagree with there choice I thought they should have been uniformal about there approach to get more sim.