Pick one Gamekiller

[rudyjuly2]

If you had to pick one game killing thing that would cause you to not buy NCAA '10 or trade it in, what would that be?

For me it would be CPU QB AI. After seeing little to improve it last year other than to reduce the pass rush so we don't see how bad it is, I think this is the one game killing issue for me. I really can't believe it has taken this long to fix it since it was so much better on last gen but it's key for '10.

1) Will the cpu QB finally start making good decisions and avoid costly INTs?

2) Will the cpu QB finally start throwing the ball down the field? Not going deep making the cpu passing game a dink and dunk fest all the time is not college football or football period.

I will most likely buy the new game warts and all. But if I hear from the community leaders or guys who get the game early that the cpu QB doesn't go deep and still throws a ton of INTs, I will honestly pass on this game.

Ineffective sliders is a close 2nd because I've often been able to fix many issues offline with sliders. But last year's cpu rushing attack was so neutered that it was pretty much impossible to fix properly.

I have allowed for multiple choice. I apologize if things like in game saves (personal pet peeve of mine but we already know it's not in for '10) or other defensive issues like pursuit angles are not broken out in more detail. But I don't want to list too many options.

Please try to vote for only the things that would keep you from buying or causing you to move on quickly. Try to keep in mind that we are also comparing it to '09. Consider these game killing issues to you if they are not improved from that.

[da ThRONe]

Come on RudyJuly there are way to many things wrong with this game to try and pick just one! But I went with Bad play calling or player doing thing that they would never do in the real game. I think you should have had an option for Placebo ratings. You know the ones that are just cosmetic that would have been my top choice but I didnt see it. I think a lot of problem with "bad defenses" or "robo-QB" wouldnt have been as bad if the ratings meant something. I think it continues to be a huge buzz kill watching Sam Bradford run the speard option. Just giving the game away!

[acts238shaun]

I've noticed when the QB is pressured he is less accurate and makes more mistakes, so I have to chose the OL/DL interaction. I've tweaked my sliders to "deprogram" Robo QB, still cant get sacks without blitzing.

[Boucher]

Ya there's multiple choices that I'd like pick so I really can't answer. There pretty much all game busters


If the NCAA team used their time wisely then there's NO reason they couldn't have fixed all if these problems for NCAA 10

[Squeezee12]

Im keeping with tradition and buying it no matter what. I had a lot of fun with 09. Still do. First one since last gen that I have played it this long.

[rudyjuly2]

How was the cpu QB AI in Madden last year? I heard it was bad but not as bad as NCAA.

[rhombic21]

This is pointless. Several of those things are potential gamekillers.

[countryboy]

nothing like a positive thread....

LOL