Madden 10 draft classes and dynasty progression in NCAA.

[UnderRatedCoast]

I had the problem in last year's Madden where 99 OVR guys on NCAA like Tebow and Mays would come in as rookies at 93 or sometimes 97 OVR. That was incredibly stupid, especially considering that the one thing I enjoy most about these two EA games is the ability to DL the draft classes instead of using the extremely jacked up computer generated ones (WR with 99 SPD and 75 ACC, LMAO). My concern this season with the dynasty progression the way that it is is that there are going to be even more of these kinds of rookies. Before I go out and buy Madden I was wondering if anyone has gone through and checked this. Let me know if you can, thanks.

[thenextqb19]

I tried it and even with all of the 99 in later years of your dynasty when you upload them to madden that they come in a whole lot lower than last year... tebow came in as 74 in the first round.

[peteykirch]

What annoyed me is how neutered some of the ratings turned into...

Noel Devine came in with 84 speed and 78 acceleration. I hate WVU but that gives him no justice what so all.

[UnderRatedCoast]

Quote: Originally Posted by peteykirch

What annoyed me is how neutered some of the ratings turned into... Noel Devine came in with 84 speed and 78 acceleration. I hate WVU but that gives him no justice what so all.

Wow, that pretty much sucks, too. I remember they used to do that in the past with incredibly small players. Darren Sproles as a senior was always 99 OVR in one version and was like 98 SPD, AGI, and ACC, but no matter how many times you uploaded him into madden his speed was always in the 80s and he always was a 5th rounder or worse, and he always sucked. But I'll take that over having all of those 90 OVR first rounders any day of the week.

Running Backs
My hand made Draft Class Results with Speed/Agility/Accleration

1st season NFL

Javid Best- 93/88/87
Trindon Holliday-95/92/97
Craig Gooper- 84/81/86
Mikell Simpson- 81/78/82
Lonyae Miller- 85/81/79
Charles Scott-82/78/81
Jarviss James- 85/80/85
LeGarette Blount- 91/87/93
Keiland Williams- 84/85/88
Montario Hardesty- 90/96/92
Demarco Murray- 95/91/92
CJ Spiller- 88/81/80
Jonathan Dwyer- 91/87/89
James Starks- 83/83/86
Noel Devine- 96/97/86

2nd Season NFL

Javid Best- 93/91/89
Trindon Holliday-95/96/99
Craig Gooper- 84/84/88
Mikell Simpson- 81/78/82
Lonyae Miller- 85/85/82
Charles Scott-82/82/84
Jarviss James- 85/91/92
LeGarette Blount- 91/91/96
Keiland Williams- 84/89/91
Montario Hardesty- 90/99/95
Demarco Murray- 95/95/95
CJ Spiller- 88/82/80
Jonathan Dwyer- 91/91/92
James Starks- 83/86/88
Noel Devine- 96/99/87

3rd Season in NFL

Javid Best- 93/95/92
Trindon Holliday-95/99/99
Craig Gooper- 84/86/89
Mikell Simpson- 81/78/82
Lonyae Miller- 85/89/85
Charles Scott-82/86/87
Jarviss James- 85/95/95
LeGarette Blount- 91/95/99
Keiland Williams- 84/93/94
Montario Hardesty- 90/99/98
Demarco Murray- 95/97/96
CJ Spiller- 88/82/80
Jonathan Dwyer- 91/95/95
James Starks- 83/88/89
Noel Devine- 96/99/89

4th Season in NFL

Javid Best- 93/96/92
Trindon Holliday-93/98/99
Craig Gooper- 82/85/89
Mikell Simpson- 81/78/82
Lonyae Miller- 83/88/85
Charles Scott-80/85/87
Jarviss James- 85/96/95
LeGarette Blount- 88/96/99
Keiland Williams- 84/94/95
Montario Hardesty- 90/99/98
Demarco Murray- 95/98/97
CJ Spiller- 88/82/80
Jonathan Dwyer- 91/97/96
James Starks- 81/87/89
Noel Devine- 94/98/89

As you can see speed stays the same throughout. But as the seasons progress players Agility and Accleration go up alot and while their careers spand out longer their Speed, Agility, Accleration do decline at points


Quarterbacks
My hand made Draft Class Results with Throw Power/ Short/ Medium/ Deep Accuracy/ Run/ Play Action

1st season in NFL
OVR
83- Sam Bradford- 96/88/87/85/85/80
60- Jevan Snead- 84/62/66/58/73/73
55- Tim Tebow- 84/69/55/66/62/67
51- Colt McCoy- 78/74/71/49/59/59
51- Jarrett Brown- 83/59/66/66/79/48
50- Tony Pike- 77/67/71/68/56/50
56- Tim Hiller- 85/73/59/66/72/66
43- Juice Williams- 77/56/60/47/51/49
45- Zac Robinson- 79/62/64/44/66/47

2nd Season in NFL

Sam Bradford- 96/88/86/83/86/82
Jevan Snead- 84/67/70/61/74/75
Tim Tebow- 84/79/63/72/64/71
Jarrett Brown- 83/64/70/69/80/50
Tim Hiller- 85/77/63/69/73/67

3rd Season in NFL------------means Awareness

Sam Bradford- 96/93/90/86/87/84----------76
Jevan Snead- 84/72/74/64/75/77----------60
Tim Tebow- 84/74/59/69/63/69---------49
Jarrett Brown- 83/71/68/72/81/51--------37
Tim Hiller- 85/81/67/72/74/68-------61

4th Season in NFL
OVR
97- Sam Bradford- 96/97/94/89/88/85-------81
72- Jevan Snead- 84/74/76/65/75/78-------------62
66- Tim Tebow- 84/80/64/72/64/71---------53
64- Jarrett Brown- 83/72/78/75/82/52------------41
67- Tim Hiller- 85/83/69/73/74/69---------53



The reason I only highlighted 5 players after the 2nd season was well they were the only ones on NFL teams and still in the game…I didn’t control anything I just simulated so players got cut a lot and just ended up in free agency and disappeared


I have also come to the conclusions that the Throw Accuracy attribute absolutely means nothing in this game. The other entire accuracy attribute increases but just regular Throw Accuracy doesn’t move at all, so I don’t think you all need to worry about that.

[Titan2810]

That's gay man. Tebow at a 55?! That seems a bit extreme.

Quote: Originally Posted by Titan2810

That's gay man. Tebow at a 55?! That seems a bit extreme.

he starts off in NFL at 55 and increases to a 64 by the 4th season

[J.R. Locke]

What are the potential ratings for the players? Are they all high?