NCAA vs Madden post patch

[i3man]

I have a feeling after the Madden patch is released later this month that Madden will be the better game. The patch is supposed to include improvements to pass coverage.

NCAA has gone from a great game out of the box that stole all Madden's glory to a crippled defenseless game post patch.

You probably had 100,000 satisfied NCAA owners that had zero issues with pass coverage. But the 2,000 unhappy and unable to pass made so much noise EA felt it necessary to dumb down pass defense. One whiner makes 100X the noise of 100 happy customers.

[Sausage]

At the moment I am not sure. I need to play NCAA more with Patch and LTP 3. Though I must admit Madden has grown on me.

[Earl1963]

Madden 11 is a cartoon IMO.

[Sausage]

Quote: Originally Posted by Earl1963

Madden 11 is a cartoon IMO.

Do you mean the visuals? Or are you refering to the Wii version.

[i3man]

Madden 11 (Has anybody told the defense they aren't in the game?)

The same can now be said about NCAA 11.

[NDIrish98]

Quote: Originally Posted by i3man

I have a feeling after the Madden patch is released later this month that Madden will be the better game. The patch is supposed to include improvements to pass coverage. NCAA has gone from a great game out of the box that stole all Madden's glory to a crippled defenseless game post patch. You probably had 100,000 satisfied NCAA owners that had zero issues with pass coverage. But the 2,000 unhappy and unable to pass made so much noise EA felt it necessary to dumb down pass defense. One whiner makes 100X the noise of 100 happy customers.

is this a feeling too? I must not have the same copy of NCAA as you. there's no way in hell Madden will even come close to NCAA this year. patches will not, i repeat WILL NOT help Madden. it's the most broken, unrealistic football game i've ever played, and it was only after one game that helped me make that decision, one game. i have a feeling, that you'll be disappointed post madden patch. that's just me.

[i3man]

If you needed the dumbed down defense to make NCAA more playable then good for you. At least Madden has hope with a patch coming out later this month and perhaps even another patch after that. NCAA has no hope, this is the game we're stuck with after 3 patches... game that has gotten progressively worse after each patch.

[Segagendude]

Oh joy. Another one of these threads.