FSU Fans: Freshman Ratings

[ufox1810]

Yeah I heard Price is going to give him a shot at playing QB. Or at least he promised him that much.

[99Potential]

I don't think that the ratings listed are necessarily in the form of a depth chart.

Knowing EA, Rouse, Garvin, Smith, and Jamie Robinson will not be on the depth charts. They rarely put true freshmen on the depth chart. I do agree with the person who said Bryant should be at least as good if not better than Garvin, though, but Bryant will in all likelihood be 3rd on the CB depth chart. Maybe even second as Flawless said, but probably 3rd on the game.

And Year 2 of my dynasty should be interesting as Antone Smith will basically be Reggie Bush without the high catching rating....... but unless Washington or Booker get hurt for a significant period, I can resist the temptation in Year 1.

[iag04ho]

Quote: Originally Posted by 99Potential

I don't think that the ratings listed are necessarily in the form of a depth chart. Knowing EA, Rouse, Garvin, Smith, and Jamie Robinson will not be on the depth charts. They rarely put true freshmen on the depth chart. I do agree with the person who said Bryant should be at least as good if not better than Garvin, though, but Bryant will in all likelihood be 3rd on the CB depth chart. Maybe even second as Flawless said, but probably 3rd on the game. And Year 2 of my dynasty should be interesting as Antone Smith will basically be Reggie Bush without the high catching rating....... but unless Washington or Booker get hurt for a significant period, I can resist the temptation in Year 1.

i think i'll probably redshirt Antone in the 1st year of my dynasty...gotta think about the long run...in the 2nd season he'll be my #2 guy behind Booker...then after Booker leaves...in my 3rd season it'll be all Antone...with 3 more years of eligibility left...monster haha

[FSU4LIFE]

Kyler Hall an 88?

[Saber]

Quote: Originally Posted by FreightTrain32

i am pretty sure i saw in another thread that gwaltney is either an 80 or 82 overall. Most of what I read said Smith was rated higher in real life. I've never seen him play. I saw one of gwaltney's games and he was an absolute truck. However, I am going to use FSU for my dynasty so Im glad Smith is rated nice and high.

maybe it was a typo I read then, either way there's a bit too much of a premium on speed in both Madden and NCAA, which will hold his overall down since he isn't all that fast, and his speed may only go up a point or two his entire career.

[NoleFan]

Thanks for those ratings. Also, Nivek, I'm jacking your FSU avatar.

[kbigsexy9]

ok so i say we make a list of all the freshmen who did nto make the team and there numbers and what ratings they should be in case they BL or FK dont do it right

[TwelveozPlaya21]

X-Lee is going to be starting for me at QB. Rouse is getting some PT game 1, not sold on Reid and Davis starting.