Player Ratings Predictions

[FordForHeisman]

Hey guys, I went ahead and predicted most of the main player ratings for my Crimson Tide. Let me know what you think, and post your own predictions if you want.

Bama

Offense: B+

QB John Parker Wilson - 82
RB Kenneth Darby - 92 (impact player)
RB Jimmy Johns - 85
RB Roy Upchurch - 85
FB Tim Castille - 94
WR Tyrone Prothro - 92
WR DJ Hall - 87
WR Keith Brown - 85
WR Matt Caddell - 80
OT Chris Capps - 79
OT Kyle Tatum - 90
OG Marlon Davis- 84
OG BJ Stabler - 82
C Antoine Caldwell - 88
*Andre Smith* - 85

Defense: B+

DE Wallace Gilberry - 90
DE Bobby Greenwood - 86
DT Jeremy Clark - 93
DT Dominic Lee - 86
OLB Terrence Jones - 86
MLB Matt Collins - 80
OLB Juwan Simpson - 91 (impact player)
CB Ramzee Robinson - 92 (impact player)
CB Simeon Castille - 87
CB Eric Gray - 86
FS Jeffrey Dukes - 84
SS Marcus Carter - 80

K Jamie Christensen - 88
P PJ Fitzgerald - 78

[Fanatical Fan]

Quote: Originally Posted by FordForHeisman

Hey guys, I went ahead and predicted most of the main player ratings for my Crimson Tide. Let me know what you think, and post your own predictions if you want. Bama Offense: B+ QB John Parker Wilson - 82 RB Kenneth Darby - 92 (impact player) RB Jimmy Johns - 85 RB Roy Upchurch - 85 FB Tim Castille - 94 WR Tyrone Prothro - 92 WR DJ Hall - 87 WR Keith Brown - 85 WR Matt Caddell - 80 OT Chris Capps - 79 OT Kyle Tatum - 90 OG Marlon Davis- 84 OG BJ Stabler - 82 C Antoine Caldwell - 88 *Andre Smith* - 85 Defense: B+ DE Wallace Gilberry - 90 DE Bobby Greenwood - 86 DT Jeremy Clark - 93 DT Dominic Lee - 86 OLB Terrence Jones - 86 MLB Matt Collins - 80 OLB Juwan Simpson - 91 (impact player) CB Ramzee Robinson - 92 (impact player) CB Simeon Castille - 87 CB Eric Gray - 86 FS Jeffrey Dukes - 84 SS Marcus Carter - 80 K Jamie Christensen - 88 P PJ Fitzgerald - 78

No offense but that's just too funny to even comment on. I'm only surprised you didn't go ahead and give them all 99s.

[FordForHeisman]

Hmm... I actually thought they were not very biased. Who do you think I overrated?

[mcculac]

Quote: Originally Posted by FordForHeisman

Hmm... I actually thought they were not very biased. Who do you think I overrated?

Tatum should be about an 85 at best. I doubt Prothro is even going to be in the game. Terrance Jones is way off along with Jeremy Clark. Caldwell is probably underrated at an 88 and Andre Smith will be about an 80. Then knock Johns and Upchurch down a few points. I have never even heard of Eric Gray (an 86) and I am an Auburn alumni and keep up with the SEC in depth. John Parker Wilson will probably be an 80 (Brandon Cox was an 80 last year and went on to be arguably one of the top 2 QBs in the SEC).

[CptObvious]

If anything, you UNDERrated Prothro...barring the injury impacting his ratings too much

[FordForHeisman]

I agree that Tatum should be worse, but I saw a screenshot with the top OTs in the game, and it RT #58 on there as a 90. He was an 88 last year. Terrence Jones I guess should be a little lower, but I don't think it's way off. 84 maybe. And Jeremy Clark was a 92 last year, so I just gave him one more point. Jimmy Johns should be at least a 84. I suppose Upchurch should be about a 82. Eric Gray is actually slated to be a starting CB over Castille. He should be pretty good.

Oh yeah, and Andre Smith was the #2 prospect in the country last year, regardless of position. I think he should be better than an 80.

[AuburnAlumni]

I stopped reading after I saw John Franklin Thompson Suzette Parker Wilson was an 82.

[AuburnAlumni]

Just curious...

Did you somehow miss that 80+ rated O line get bitchslapped by LSU and Auburn's D line the last two games of the year?