NCAA 08 Feed Back Poll #1 Whats the most important area for NCAA09

[DonkeyJote]

I voted gameplay. I agree the presentation needs to be improved, but gameplay needs work to, and that is more important than presentation to me. They need to control int's. I also think the game just needs to move a little faster and smoother. I would like to see smarter (but not cheaper) DB AI. I would like to see more swats, and I don't mean dropped ints'. That's the biggest problem with the engine to me is that db's go for ints too much, and not swats. That's why we get so many ints and why most the knockdowns are just db's dropping ints. I'd also like to see the interior running game to improve more still. I want them to force me to show patience and not just sprint through the hole for a big gain.

[Hurricain]

Quote: Originally Posted by rudyjuly2

Gameplay. The offline cpu INTs need fixing. The deep passing game needs to open up a little with the cpu actually attempting to complete a streak. I would love enhanced presentation but the cpu passing game is my #1 concern.

Honestly, How can anyone not put Gameplay? Just look at the slider forum, the passing game needs revamped big time. That and the CPU needs to play smarter. Gameplay!!!!!

[Village Idiot]

Quote: Originally Posted by Hurricain

Honestly, How can anyone not put Gameplay? Just look at the slider forum, the passing game needs revamped big time. That and the CPU needs to play smarter. Gameplay!!!!!

I can't argue against those voting gameplay, but like I said, my issues with it seem more or less self-evident. It's hard to imagine next year's game not addressing its flaws. Put another way, I guess I just take it as a forgone conclusion that the gameplay issues will be fixed - as they're so blatantly obvious - versus what I think should be the 'focus' of an entire year of development.

[J-Unit40]

Gameplay, Gameplay, Gameplay.

We need better CPU QB decision making, WRs that break for the ball, better CPU defense vs. the option, better ball physics, more realistic DB and WR animations and improved playbooks before we get better presentation. Oh, and tone down the CPU thrown INTs and pick 6's. Please.

I'll take better presentation is NCAA 2010.

[Sausage]

I know it may get old after a while, but I chose presentation.

I would love:
--More insightful commentary even with the play on field.
--Players warming up and more info of how they can impact the game.
--A variety of replay angles and styles.
--Commentary during replays
--Better entrances even generic ones are ok
--More ESPN, ABC, etc tv presentation

I believe gameplay is always a priority so I did not pick it.

[MrDontPlay]

Better ball trajectory (actually being able to get the ball over the heads of the LBs and DBs once the WR gets behind them), less INTs on both sides, WRs who fight for the ball, and eliminating the DB super jump would make this game money for me from a gameplay stadpoint. So, that's what I went with.

[trobinson97]

Gameplay and it's not even close.

[Cardot]

Quote: Originally Posted by Hurricain

Honestly, How can anyone not put Gameplay? Just look at the slider forum, the passing game needs revamped big time. That and the CPU needs to play smarter. Gameplay!!!!!

I wouldn't want them to revamp the passing game. There will even more problems if they do that. DB's and LB's need to be toned down a bit on pass defense, and the CPU has to make less passes right to defenders. While I dislike the number of Ints, I do like the fact that it is tough to complete a long pass.

I vote for Presentation. But honestly, if they want my money next year, EA is going to have to do both.

Unfortunately, I think EA would respond to this vote with: D: Add Some hokey new RPG mode that 17 people will like.