Top 3 positive & negative of NCAA '09

[Russell_SCEA]

Quote:

No progressive lighting! Why did they take this out? the graphics looked nicer than madden last year becasue of this.

They didn't take it out they are using a new lighting system thats probadly a baked system just like COD4 has when its baked you can't do progressive real time lighting it should return next year.

[boritter]

Here are a few that I believe no one has posted yet.

Pros:
1) Menu lag is gone
2) Return of slide protection audible
3) Left stick juking sounds amazing

Cons:
1) Spectacular catches. I've read that it is cheese and nearly unstoppable.
2) No all-time teams. Because I love being able to virtually settle the "Who would win if X played Y?" debates and because I hate that we still don't have 100% of the last gen features.
3) HB screen plays are way to easy.

[J-Unit40]

So far for me since I haven't played it yet:

Top 5 positives (I'm greedy) -
1) User Control
2) Improved playbooks
3) Improved player models
4) On-line dynasty
5) CPU INTs toned down!!

Top 4 Negatives -
1) No formation subs
2) QBs completed 80% + in every game
3) Lack of deep ball by CPU
4) Spectacular catch exploiting (possibly)

[ODogg]

Here are mine..

POSITIVES
Online dynasty
Wide open gameplay
Custom soundtracks

NEGATIVES
Pass rush negligible
No dreadlocks! No long hair!
No progressive lighting

[babyfat9]

Postitives:

1. Better graphics and lighting
2. Smoother running abilities
3. Better Player models

Negatives:

1. Same playbooks (I'd like to see more gimmick plays like Spurrier's pass to wide receiver then reciever pasess back to QB for a down field throw)

2. No Dreadlocks, Mullets, eyeblacks and mouthguards

3. No new team entrances or no new commentaries

[thmst30]

Quote: Originally Posted by jpringle

For Me: Positives: 1. Online Dynasty(As soon as this was annouced, this became a release day purchase) 2. Alt Unis 3. Everything in offline dynasty is in online dynasty(Sorry but I love the dynasty mode) Negatives 1. Still FCS teams(not a gamekiller, but would like them to go away) 2. No Bowl art in endzone(also not a gamekiller) 3. not enough of a deep ball from CPU(also not a game killer)

Ummmmmm, I think you messed up there. There are NO FCS teams and haven't been on next-gen yet. Which is bull****. However if you are talking about FCS teams on PS2/Wii, then why the hell would you want them gone? Hopefully you mis-typed.

[ka520]

Postives:

1. Finally some alternates
2. Roster sharing
3. 60 FPS on PS3

Negatives

1. Lack of alternates
2. No customizable hair
3. No FCS teams

[jpringle]

Quote: Originally Posted by thmst30

Ummmmmm, I think you messed up there. There are NO FCS teams and haven't been on next-gen yet. Which is bull****. However if you are talking about FCS teams on PS2/Wii, then why the hell would you want them gone? Hopefully you mis-typed.

I meant take away where the team says "FCS East" or something of that nature.