Well if my good buddy in my OD didn't totally stink at this as well I would simply not believe it since I almost NEVER miss any FGs at all. However, FGs and even a couple of EXTRA POINTS cost him a few games in year 1 of our dynasty. I know what he did was to use BOTH THUMBS to somehow kick the ball straighter so give that a try. He finally broke down and went to the practice field and kicked some and since then (and using both thumbs) he doesn't seem to have nearly as big of an issue. Hope this helps.