madden killing NCAA

[UNC_Pete]

Quote: Originally Posted by Africa Jr

ONLINE DYNASTY! > Madden 10

Agreed. Why doesn't Madden have online franchise?

[SageInfinite]

I used to think NCAA is was the superior game every year(except 05), but ever since this generation hit NCAA has been garbage. Madden hasn't been much better but NCAA has just been trash imo.

Football gaming died this generation, hopefully Madden can bring some life to it this year. Some people just enjoy college football more than the NFL, I think that and the online dynasty are the reasons NCAA still gets love. Also the commentary has consistantly ****ted on Madden's.

[Lava]

Quote: Originally Posted by SageInfinite

I used to think NCAA is was the superior game every year(except 05), but ever since this generation hit NCAA has been garbage. Madden hasn't been much better but NCAA has just been trash imo. Football gaming died this generation, hopefully Madden can bring some life to it this year. Some people just enjoy college football more than the NFL, I think that and the online dynasty are the reasons NCAA still gets love. Also the commentary has consistantly ****ted on Madden's.

I feel the exact opposite of your first paragraph, haha.

[nxt]

Quote: Originally Posted by SageInfinite

I used to think NCAA is was the superior game every year(except 05), but ever since this generation hit NCAA has been garbage. Madden hasn't been much better but NCAA has just been trash imo. Football gaming died this generation, hopefully Madden can bring some life to it this year. Some people just enjoy college football more than the NFL, I think that and the online dynasty are the reasons NCAA still gets love. Also the commentary has consistantly ****ted on Madden's.

I agree with Sage, with the exception that NCAA has always been better than Madden (even 05). However, Current Gen football gaming has been crap so far IMO. I can't put my finger on it, but it's just not as fun. If only the gameplay and presentation (immersion factor) could catch up to the graphics, these games would be the ***t!