Worst Of The Series

[Gosens6]

08 Was the absolute worst...

06 and 07 last gen were my favorites

[RamblinWreck21]

Quote: Originally Posted by Gosens6

08 Was the absolute worst... 06 and 07 last gen were my favorites

Yeah I originally said 08. Its is too date the least played NCAA game in my household. That said, I rented 07 on 360 when I first got my 360 and it was terrible. 09 was the first decent next-gen title. Thinking back, the last-gen games were so much better. It makes me sad.

[GaryT531]

07 probably had the best progressive lighting to date that I've seen in any football game, but that was about all it had.

08 was without a doubt the most disappointing let down. this game brought nothing. it was absolute crap. Year two on next gen should have been much better than this.

09 & 10 made me happy, they were fun, but not great. By 09 this series should have been great on next gen, and it wasn't.

I don't ever remember being unsatisfied with a PSone or PS2 version of the game other than 2005, and for all of the reasons mentioned throughout this thread.


I still can't believe that we are still waiting for NCAA and Madden to be great on next gen. Please NCAA 11, be everything we are hoping for.

[BLACKJ414]

1-09 for 360/PS3
2-08 for 360/PS3
3-07 for 360/PS3
4-10 for 360/PS3
5-05 for xbox/ps2

[Madwolf]

'05 was flipping terrible. The passing game was non-existent because no one could catch a pass. I mean guys would be wide open and the ball would just bounce off their chest. You were lucky to be 1-10 sometimes. It was atrocious.

[Dollar Theater]

To me it was NCAA 07 for the 360. What made it worse was that everywhere was advertising that it had all the features of the PS2 version (Amazon STILL says it does) when, in fact, it had very little of anything. Biggest ripoff of $60 I can remember.

[BamaBruce]

Quote: Originally Posted by AirLobo23

1 - '05 2 - '07 (current gen, due to lack of features) 3 - '09 4 - '10

really? I thought 05 was great. wish we had those moments back, if anyone knows what I'm talkin about

anyway as far as the worst, probably 07 or 06 from what I've played

[SECElit3]

2007 "Hands Down"