Bill Abner's Review

[roadman]

I've been following Bill Abner's reviewing of sports games for years. He's knocked EA and also has praised it when appropriate.

He gave this one a B. Good solid review.

http://www.gameshark.com/reviews/358...-11-Review.htm

[HokieB]

I love The Abner.

Excellent review.

[Nextel Husker]

Great review. I really hope EA fixes the recruits issue because that's the biggest problem to me.

[superjew887]

This guy should seriously get a "Guest Reviewer" status on O.S. He really nails reviews right on the head. Great read.

I love how he hit dyansty hard, and even mentioned problems with simulated stats, although a smaller issue compared to the talent pool issue in recruiting.

I have faith though, that EA will fix the recruiting talent pool and dynasty mode will be back on its feet, because this game is just way to good to crumble because of a broken dynasty mode.

[Rashad19]

Great review! Bill Abner is always on point.

[vegaas]

Bill Abner is the Godfather of sports game reviews. I have been reading him since the mid 90's, he will throughly play and test a game before he submits his review, something sorely missing im most others. He is the only reviewer I trust.

[jbrew2411]

Yeah that was about right.

[CrossTown]

Agreed with everything, except for his final grade. I don't know his grading scale but the strides the NCAA team has made with this franchise's gameplay warrants at least a B+, regardless of the dynasty issues.

When we consider the tuning they intend to do, as well as the upcoming patch, I can say this game will be as good as it could ever really be. Not without it flaws, but close.