Re: What do you guys think of my new MWC?
Since BYU is now Independent and TCU will be joining the Big East starting in 2012, i felt the need to reorder the MWC myself...this is how i did it:
Blue Division
Boise State
Nevada
Wyoming
UNLV
Utah State
UTEP
White Division
Fresno State
Hawaii
Colorado State
San Diego State
Air Force
New Mexico
Protected Rivalries
Boise State VS Fresno State
Nevada VS Hawaii
Wyoming VS Colorado State
UNLV VS San Diego State
Utah State VS Air Force
UTEP VS New Mexico
Conference Title Game Site
Invesco Field, Denver, Colorado
I went with Blue and White for the divisions because those are the colors in the MWC logo, and because regional divisions dont work...either way u slice it, the "North" or "West" would be stacked with Boise, Nevada, and possibly Fresno, Hawaii and SD State...
As for the teams in each division, i tried to balance them out based on their overall rating and prestige level...in the Blue division you have Boise and Nevada, the two best teams in the league, but in the White Division you have Hawaii, Fresno, SD State, Colorado State and Air Force, which are all above a 78 overall, and 3 of them over an 81...i could have switched Nevada with Fresno though, and put the two best teams in different divisions, like the Big Ten did with Ohio State and Michigan...but i figured that while Boise and Nevada will battle it out for their division every year, the White Division will be up for grabs year-in and year-out...
and the Protected Rivalries were hard to figure, since there arent many rivalries among the teams...most of them would be within their own respective divisions...it might be best to not have Protected Rivalries, since the only team of any prestige is Boise State, and any team matched up with them would be at a major disadvantage within their own division...but, for the sake of argument i tried to come up with the best matchups to be protected...as shown in the Big Ten, the biggest rivalry takes precedence over all others, being, of course, Ohio State VS Michigan...in this case, that rivalry would be Boise State VS Fresno State (which is called "The Battle for the Milk Can")...the only other real rivalry is Wyoming with either Hawaii (The Battle for the Paniolo Trophy) or Colorado State (the Border War)...and since the "Border War" is more prestigious, i went with that one...also, i could put Hawaii VS Nevada, since they were former WAC opponents...the other three are technically border battles, (UNLV VS SD State, Utah St VS Air Force, UTEP VS New Mexico) so at least they would have that to go on...
As for the Automatic Qualifier i thought of giving it to the "New Mountain West", but i didnt really feel they deserved it based on the strength of the league...yea, Boise State would, but what if they lost in the Title Game to a 7-5 Fresno State team that Boise had destroyed in the regular season matchup?...Any AQ given to the MWC would be almost solely for the benefits of Boise State...
Last edited by kruszer; 07-15-2011 at 01:53 AM.
|