Greatest QB of All-Time??

[vgunn]

Well that depends on reality or fantasy. I have had some awesome qbs in the game that have put up similar numbers. I think a more accurate result would be coming from numbers put up by a qb that you did not control. For example, after injuries to Martin and Dickey, Chris Leak in one of my sims had huge numbers after he had finished his career at Florida.

Now if we are going with real players I'd have to say (mind you this is for what they did in college, not the NFL):

1. Danny Wuerffel
2. Ty Detmer
3. Doug Flutie

[bullcats]

Damn, nice QB you have there. I have a WR that is currently a Junior that didn't play much his freshman season. Edmund Kennedy, not sure of exact stats but somewhere around 8 pr tds, 2 kr tds, and 15 recieving tds last season alone, and 3,000 yards total offense.

[Meatloaf86]

closing in on the records. beat #11 ranked SDSU 24-10. I'm now ranked #24 in the nation. first time being ranked. kind of a good feeling after struggling to get there. My QB had a horrible game threw 2 TDs and 4 INTs. Valentine though caught 13 passes for 160+ yards and 1 TD. he now needs only 1 TD to break the school record and like 36 receptions in 4 games to break the school record. also needs like 450 yards to break the school record.

[Taur3asi3]

what about Andre Ware? He had like 741 yards in ONE game he has to atleast be top 5

[pennstlbu]

Here's my alltime greatest player: Phillip Merritt #19 Montana Grizzlies

Freshman: 347-482, 5003 yards, 37 TD, 178.7 rating
Sophomore: 369-511, 5619 yards, 64 TD, 202.4 rating
Junior: 225-357, 3302 yards, 24 TD, 156.7 rating
Senior: 182-268, 2734 yards, 22 TD, 174.7 rating

NCAA Single Season Records: 202.4 rating, 5619 yards, 64 TD

NCAA Career Records: 16658 yards, 147 TD

Awards: Freshman: Maxwell, Frosh AA, 1st Team AA, Best QB, Heisman
Sophomore: Maxwell, 1st Team AA, Best QB, Heisman
Junior: 2nd Team AA

Career Record: 43-2, 3-time National Champion, 1 National runner-up