Heisman voting messed up

[K0ZZ]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cynick

I've never seen anything but a RB win it, and the list is almost always 5 RB's. Every now and then a QB will get on the list for a bit, but never comes close to winning it.

Usually true, but I had a year where there were four QB's (one won), Walsh, Golson but I'm drawing a blank on the other two.

[Pezell04x]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cynick

I've never seen anything but a RB win it, and the list is almost always 5 RB's. Every now and then a QB will get on the list for a bit, but never comes close to winning it.

Taylor Martinez (QB Nebraska) just won the Heisman in 2013 of my dynasty.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

[Wilson16NCSU]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cynick

I've never seen anything but a RB win it, and the list is almost always 5 RB's. Every now and then a QB will get on the list for a bit, but never comes close to winning it.

In my first season Tyler Wilson, QB from Arkansas won it.

[Colt45]

If you are SO far above and beyond, you will never win it. It's been like that forever.

[scotty1011]

I think with QBs they consider all stats not just passing yards and passing TDs. My QB won the Heisman two years in a row not very realistic but it happened. Now this being said this is the only time I have ever had a QB win the Heisman in the NCAA Franchise.

2012 Stats (Won Heisman)
QB Rating – 221.8
PassingYards – 4357
PassingTDs – 52
Interceptions– 9
Completion% - 65.8
Rushing Stats
627, 11 TDs

2013 Stats (Won 2^ndHeisman)
QB Rating – 235.0
PassingYards – 5083
PassingTDs – 65
Interceptions– 12
Completion% - 68.1

Rushing stats were not very good this year.

[vD3ATHv]

Quote: Originally Posted by xtrezpasor

Broke passing yards and td records and went undefeated number ranked team and was later if the week 8 times and still finished 2nd to a hb that didn't set any tracks Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2

Depends on who you played with and quality of schedule.

[orangeafroman]

Right now in year 3 it's 4 QBs and 1 RB, in week 8. We'll see.

All of you saying it's not about stats, Keenum and Brennan were at mid-majors who couldn't beat a real team. I schedule tough, play as Florida, and it's still hard to win the Heisman.

At the beginning of the season (it'll change), I had 8 ranked teams on my schedule. I had a RB get hurt in week 10, ended up leading the nation in rushing and TDs by far (even with the missed time), and dropped totally out of the Heisman. Sure, that happened to Dixon from Oregon a few years back, but still.

The Heisman seems to me to be largely random.