Composure...If this means new ratings...HOORAY!
However...
This just killed me:
"Former University of Pittsburgh star Larry Fitzgerald told us that normally he would use hand signals to communicate audibles while playing in hostile environments but crowd noise would force them to keep it pretty simple. However, he's a first round pick for good reason."
...and the good reason has nothing to do with the hand signals he uses. If Larry is using hand signals for Pitt, then almost every player on his team is using hand signals. Those guys aren't future All Pros (though they may be selling Alpo at WalMart someday, does that count?).
While Pitt runs a fairly sophisticated offense for a college team, any major conference team will use some sort of signalling to account for a loud environment. These teams play in big stadiums every Saturday, so it will be interesting to see how that's reflected.
Also I'm sure IGN meant this example as a generalization:
"If a true freshman is starting at quarterback for Florida at Neyland Stadium, he's going to be especially easy to rattle even before the defense starts riling up the Volunteer crowd."
At least, I sure hope so. Because Florida had a Freshman QB last season (Chris Leak), and he just so happened to be one of the most polished Freshman QBs in the history of the game. You don't go in to Death Valley and beat the 2003 LSU squad if you're easily rattled.
Bottom line -- there better be a player specific "Composure" attribute of some sort. And I'm sure there is, Jeff Luhr and the guys at Tiburon are some smart game designers. Overall, it seems like a feature which will really add to the game. Also, it would be nice if the stadium "Intesity" rankings are user-modifiable.
Composure is similar to what NFL 2k4 (nay ESPN Football) did with their consistency rating, but seemingly implemented to a much greater degree -- the Matchup stick is brilliant. Heck, it's also been hyped much better, and NCAA 2005 won't come out for another few months. Maybe ESPN will start hyping what they're doing with consistency for ESPN NFL 2005 a bit better this time
On that note...