Ratings For Rookies

[Bretsky523]

What do you guys think of these for the first rounders this year

Nathan Mackinnon- 78 (4.5 Green)
Sasha Barkov- 75 (4.5 Gold)
Jonathan Drouin- 75 (4.5 Gold)
Seth Jones- 76 (4.5 Green)
Elias Lindholm- 70 (4.5 Gold)
Sean Monahan- 70 (4.5 Gold)
Darnell Nurse 68 (4 Green)
Rasmus Ristolainen 65 (4 Gold)
Bo Horvat 70 (4 Green)
Valeri Nickushkin 72 (4.5 Red)
Samuel Morin 71 (3 Green)
Max Domi 68 (4 Red)
Josh Morrisey 65 (4 Red)
Alexander Wennberg 68 (3.5 Gold)
Ryan Pulock 68 (4 Gold)
Nikita Zadorov 70 (4 Gold)
Curtis Lazar 66 (3.5 Green)
Mirco Mueller 62 (3.5 Gold)
Kerby Rychel 65 (3.5 Gold)
Anthony Mantha 68 (4 Gold)
Frederick Gauthier 62 (4 Gold)
Emilie Porier 60 (3.5 Gold)
Andre Burakovsky 64 (3.5 Gold)
Hunter Shinkaruk 68 (4 Gold)
Michael Mccaron 65 (3.5 Gold)
Shea Theodore 60 (3.5 Gold)
Marko Dano 65 (3.5 Red)
Morgan Klimchuck 65 (3.5 Green)
Jason Dickinson 62 (3.5 Gold)
Ryan Hartman 69 (3.5 Gold)

[Weapon X]

Deduct 10 points from most of those and I think you'll be more on track. I don't think a rookie who hasn't proven himself at the NHL level will be getting a 78 as his initial rating. The best rookies tend to hover around 66-72 in their initial year, especially when they have high potential.

WX