Legends of the Show 15...

[jorge380]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

I hope I'm wrong, but I feel like there going to give us Legends from 90s till now.

[ericjwm]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

Also to the OP I would go with either Biggio, Bagwell or Oswalt as the guy for the Astros and put Ryan with the Rangers. Also Bonds WON'T be in the game. He wasn't for the latter part of his career. From 2004 until he retired he went by a different name because he did not allow video game companies to his name and likeness. I remember in MVP Baseball 2005 he wasn't even black. He was a white guy named John Dowd. And also Kevin Millar was a black guy named Anthony Friese.

But here are some others.

Mets: toss up between Piazza and Gordon

Yankees: Gehrig

O's: Ripken Jr.

Pirates: Clemente

Cubs: Ernie Banks

Angels: Carew

Twins: Puckett

Dbacks: Johnson, Schilling, Luis Gonzalez

Rays: Boggs

I highly agree with Bagwell for the Astros, Ripken for the O's and Piazza for the Mets.
Bonds was not part of the MLBPA for the latter part of his career which is why he was not in video games.

Barry Bonds IS the current HR king no matter what anyone believes at this point, so.. yeah he is the legend of all legends right now & as great a Mays was he is not that.
Bonds signing for this game would be huge since the Michael Jordan of baseball has been absent from the virtual world for ages.

Plz do not let this start a debate about Bonds.. stay on topic with legends for The Show and express your candidates for 15 and beyond.

[ericjwm]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

I hope I'm wrong, but I feel like there going to give us Legends from 90s till now.

I hope you're right. The mid 80's and beyond is probably the generation they want to appeal to. Yet, they still need quite a few of the older classics such as Hank Aaron, Babe Ruth, Reggie Jackson, Mantle, etc....

[Jimmydm90]

Legends of the Show 15...

Mays and Bonds are irrefutably two of the greatest players in baseball history. And though it would be a cheat you could always go with Pittsburgh Pirates Bonds or worse Mays on the Mets.

Dodgers: Sandy Koufax
Astros: Nolan Ryan
A's: Ricky Henderson
Rockies: Larry Walker
Padres: Tony Gwynn (RIP)
Mariners: Ken Griffey Jr.
Brewers: Robin Yount

[JODYE]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

Cubs: Ernie Banks or Billy Williams

[redsox4evur]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

I highly agree with Bagwell for the Astros, Ripken for the O's and Piazza for the Mets.
Bonds was not part of the MLBPA for the latter part of his career which is why he was not in video games.

Barry Bonds IS the current HR king no matter what anyone believes at this point, so.. yeah he is the legend of all legends right now & as great a Mays was he is not that.
Bonds signing for this game would be huge since the Michael Jordan of baseball has been absent from the virtual world for ages.

Plz do not let this start a debate about Bonds.. stay on topic with legends for The Show and express your candidates for 15 and beyond.

Yea I understand about Bonds and that he wasn't in old games. So why would he allow SCEA to use his name and likeness again. I don't think it is going to happen. Also I would PISSED if I got Bonds over a Willy Mays. I don't give a damn if he is the homerun leader or not. Mays was easily one of the greatest players of all time and did not use any drugs to help him play that way.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

Plz do not let this start a debate about Bonds.. stay on topic with legends for The Show and express your candidates for 15 and beyond.

Debating the merits of the choice of one player over another for Giants MLB 15 Show Legend is on topic IMO

Reasons for Mays over Bonds for Giants Legend:

Career WAR for Giants Mays 154.6 - Bonds 112.3
Hits Mays 3187 - Bonds 1951
Homers Mays 646 - Bonds 586
Stolen Bases Mays 336 - Bonds 263
Cooperstown Inductee Mays yes - Bonds no

[Jimmydm90]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

Mays was easily one of the greatest players of all time and did not use any drugs to help him play that way.

To be fair Mays, Hank Aaron, Pete Rose and many others have admitted to using amphetamines (or greenies), a performance enhancing drug/stimulant. That was illegal without a prescription which players were able to get easily enough. Most of the league was using at that point.

“There were always two pots of coffee brewing in the clubhouse -- one conventional and the other laced with stimulants - former Royals outfielder Brian McRae (Crasnick, 2006).”

Amphetamines weren't banned until 1971, Mays retired in 73 so there was little overlap of it being "technically" cheating by the rules of the MLB. Still ethically it's a gray area. HGH was banned in 2005 and Bonds retired in 2007.

[redsox4evur]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

To be fair Mays, Hank Aaron, Pete Rose and many others have admitted to using amphetamines (or greenies), a performance enhancing drug/stimulant. That was illegal without a prescription which players were able to get easily enough. Most of the league was using at that point.

“There were always two pots of coffee brewing in the clubhouse -- one conventional and the other laced with stimulants - former Royals outfielder Brian McRae (Crasnick, 2006).”

Amphetamines weren't banned until 1971, Mays retired in 73 so there was little overlap of it being "technically" cheating by the rules of the MLB. Still ethically it's a gray area. HGH was banned in 2005 and Bonds retired in 2007.

OK, fine then the numbers provided by Ghost of the Year prove my point. You can't use Bonds' numbers from Pitt when debating best Giant.

[RedMeansGo2006]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

Mays and Bonds are irrefutably two of the greatest players in baseball history. And though it would be a cheat you could always go with Pittsburgh Pirates Bonds or worse Mays on the Mets.

Dodgers: Sandy Koufax
Astros: Nolan Ryan
A's: Ricky Henderson
Rockies: Larry Walker
Padres: Tony Gwynn (RIP)
Mariners: Ken Griffey Jr.
Brewers: Robin Yount

I think Jimmy Foxx or Reggie Jackson and Todd Helton should get it over Henderson and Walker.

[redsox4evur]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

Mays and Bonds are irrefutably two of the greatest players in baseball history. And though it would be a cheat you could always go with Pittsburgh Pirates Bonds or worse Mays on the Mets.

Dodgers: Sandy Koufax
Astros: Nolan Ryan
A's: Ricky Henderson
Rockies: Larry Walker
Padres: Tony Gwynn (RIP)
Mariners: Ken Griffey Jr.
Brewers: Robin Yount

How do you leave out a Mike Piazza or Dwight Gooden, arguably the faces of the Mets? And how do you not choose Roberto Clemente, who is the face of Pirates, for the Pirates?

[Jimmydm90]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

I think Jimmy Foxx or Reggie Jackson and Todd Helton should get it over Henderson and Walker.

Jackson was inducted into the HOF as a Yankee. Foxx was inducted as a Red Sox. Maybe it's petty but I think Henderson's decision to be inducted as an A plus all of his records give him the leg up.

I thought about picking Todd Helton but it felt weird picking someone who had retired so recently (2013). It would be like picking Jeter for the Yankees. They're both great but I thought Walker was just a little better. Walker could hit and steal plus he's Colorado's only MVP. But Helton had the longer Colorado career. They're both worthy.

[ethnanm]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

I would like to see Tom "terrific" Seaver for the Mets. He was so far the best franchise player the Mets have had.

[jcmreds]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

One legend per team? Why even bother? It should be one legend team per franchise not one player.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: Legends of the Show 15...

One legend per team? Why even bother? It should be one legend team per franchise not one player.

That's what I said the last time my dad tried to give me a hundred dollars.
If it's not a thousand, why even bother.
Sheesh, inch, mile.