MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

[Stolm]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

Super disappointed if the solution to keeping stats realistic again is just to hoard your points and never spend em. All the talk last year of "making it a realistic as possible" for them just to do a complete 180 is embarrassing.

They could have just made archetype's semi-customizable, or have a seperate option or mode for those that want no caps.

[Peter_OS]

meh.. could care less. show me some franchise/presentation features. 

[dalger21]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

meh.. could care less. show me some franchise/presentation features.*

I mean, if you don't care about RttS, how productive is it to come into a thread specifically talking about RttS just to say that?

[dalger21]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

I've always said they needed to add challenges into the game to make it more interesting. The whole cap feature they implemented last year seemed to me to just be a way to slow progress to get to MLB from AA. I would much rather they add Rookie Ball, Single A, etc., instead of artificially holding players back in the minors.

[Mercury112491]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

Not to be the evil DD guy but does this mean we’re gonna see 5’4” 99 power 99 speed catchers again as teams created player?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Themayorofawsometown]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

Not to be the evil DD guy but does this mean we’re gonna see 5’4” 99 power 99 speed catchers again as teams created player?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

They haven't said anything about DD caps but I imagine if they cut down on that last year they probably are gonna do the same this year

Sent from my Z971 using Tapatalk

[Dolenz]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

Super disappointed if the solution to keeping stats realistic again is just to hoard your points and never spend em. All the talk last year of "making it a realistic as possible" for them just to do a complete 180 is embarrassing.

They could have just made archetype's semi-customizable, or have a seperate option or mode for those that want no caps.

We don't know yet how easy or hard it will be to hit those caps. The advancement last year seemed slowed down from the previous years. They could make it theoretically possible for players to hit all 99 but in practice make it nearly impossible to do so.


And I don't think it was foolish. There was a very vocal blowback to the Archetype system and new training. Many of us when back to RTTS in previous versions. I think they underestimated how many of us played RTTS and was fine with it being a more arcade version of the game, where we could create our players and become the GOAT in every category. It may be dumb to some but I don't want to be restricted in my single player modes.

[Dolenz]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

Not to be the evil DD guy but does this mean we’re gonna see 5’4” 99 power 99 speed catchers again as teams created player?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Well, personally, and it may not be a popular opinion, I am not sure CAP has any purpose being in DD. The only reason I can think of is that it creates a market for people to purchase equipment. I can't believe that there are not enough real players to fill out the roster.

[Mercury112491]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

Well, personally, and it may not be a popular opinion, I am not sure CAP has any purpose being in DD. The only reason I can think of is that it creates a market for people to purchase equipment. I can't believe that there are not enough real players to fill out the roster.

Yeah that’s a whole other can of worms. I’ve always said the CAP has no place in that mode because it’s so cheesy.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[LoadStar81]

What I noticed in the stills was stuff like, "These are the hardest to train."  Meaning, you may be able to get to 99 OVR, but you'll have to work hard at it.  And I think that is as it should be.
We'll see more in a couple of days, but this is getting pretty darn close to "shut up and take my money" territory.  More environments, more off-the-field activity, and a better supporting cast, all should REALLY amp up the world-building.

[jaiman]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

Super disappointed if the solution to keeping stats realistic again is just to hoard your points and never spend em. All the talk last year of "making it a realistic as possible" for them just to do a complete 180 is embarrassing.



They could have just made archetype's semi-customizable, or have a seperate option or mode for those that want no caps.

This dev team used to pride themselves on options for every play type. They seem to be getting away from that.

We used to have the option to turn off all indicators (red glow around the ball, base running graphic, etc), which would allow us to play with a clean screen. They just keep adding more interfaces now (ball off the wall indicator) which probably won’t be optional.

[King Gro23]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

I just hope that when I make a OF, and the manager suggest I try 1st base that I actually get to go back into the outfield. It's so sad and 1b is the least entertaining position in rtts..I started him in mlb 17 as a RF, which changed forever 3 months in to my career.
I carried him over to 18.. and ready to carry over to 19. I reached the majors in my first year in September call ups (2017)
And have a save set up for the start of the 2019 season.

91 ovr 1B
I did have 82 & 83 power but the cap system on 18' nerfed them down to 73-72.

Would like to get back in the outfield though I have a 94 arm strength and 85 react & fielding and living the dream as a gold glove 1B (facepalm)

Sent from my SM-G965U using Operation Sports mobile app

[Dolenz]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

I just hope that when I make a OF, and the manager suggest I try 1st base that I actually get to go back into the outfield. It's so sad and 1b is the least entertaining position in rtts..I started him in mlb 17 as a RF, which changed forever 3 months in to my career.
I carried him over to 18.. and ready to carry over to 19. I reached the majors in my first year in September call ups (2017)
And have a save set up for the start of the 2019 season.

91 ovr 1B
I did have 82 & 83 power but the cap system on 18' nerfed them down to 73-72.

Would like to get back in the outfield though I have a 94 arm strength and 85 react & fielding and living the dream as a gold glove 1B (facepalm)

Sent from my SM-G965U using Operation Sports mobile app

I HATE, HATE, HATE that crap. It would make me quit. When I choose a position in RTTS it is usually because it is a new position for me. If I have already spent large amounts of time playing other positions previously then I don't want to be forced to go back to them.


It is another case of realism getting in the way of fun.

[Stolm]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

We don't know yet how easy or hard it will be to hit those caps. The advancement last year seemed slowed down from the previous years. They could make it theoretically possible for players to hit all 99 but in practice make it nearly impossible to do so.


And I don't think it was foolish. There was a very vocal blowback to the Archetype system and new training. Many of us when back to RTTS in previous versions. I think they underestimated how many of us played RTTS and was fine with it being a more arcade version of the game, where we could create our players and become the GOAT in every category. It may be dumb to some but I don't want to be restricted in my single player modes.

Seems like an easy fix would to be just add a cap on/off toggle on the archetype screen when creating your player.

Doubt they do it.

[Dolenz]

Re: MLB The Show 19 Road to the Show Details, Video and Screenshots

Seems like an easy fix would to be just add a cap on/off toggle on the archetype screen when creating your player.

Doubt they do it.

Based on what we saw today in the IGN video it seems like those weak attributes will take significant effort to upgrade. How much harder it will be we don't know, but I am not expecting that you will do it without a significant amount of effort.