Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

[MLB Bob]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

I want major league strike zone as an option..where the strike zone is a fair bit smaller, not just umps calling a different strike zone. and dont even have pitchers change how they pitch now, just make the zone smaller. just as an option

[CabreraMVP]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

I want them to add variety to the pitchers after motions after the pitch. Every pitcher throws the ball, then steps in the same spot on the mound, waiting for the catcher to throw it back. After seeing the same thing 100 times, it begins to look a little unrealistic.

If they could have guys maybe walk a few steps toward the plate then recieve the ball, or play with their hat, adjust their glove, there's a milion things pitchers do after the pitch. They don't stand in the same spot, in the same exact position every time.

Same with the first basemen after an out. In the game, they catch the ball, then go into the same animation of pausing awkwardly, then tossing it to the second basemen. Add some variety or some flow to their animations when throwing around the horn.

[g-burn]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

1) Detailed career statistics on player cards in Franchise Mode (obp, slug, ops, strike outs, walks, SB, 2b, 3b, runs, etc). Highlight the statistics leaders too just like on real baseball cards.
2) Player resumes on player cards. I'd like to see a record of previous years award winners, previous leaders in statistical categories, championships, or all star selections. They could take it one step further and attach experience point values to each item on the resume which would help improve overall team performance. This could give AI a reason to sign or start veterans over freshly drafted prospects.
3) Loosely designate the type a hitter a player is supposed to be. For instance, a player that shows the skill set of a lead off hitter should continue to develop as a lead off hitter. Same with a number 2 hitter or a clean up hitter. Then have AI build teams and lineups based on a hitters role. This would prevent Mark Texiera from ever batting in the 2 hole!
4) Player ranking system. For both the pro's and the prospects. Maybe include 2 lists. One ranking talent and another ranking actual performance.
5) Ability to tinker with and build line ups during the offseason in Franchise Mode. This one is slightly nitpicky since I can do with pen and paper, but why should I? I find it easier to make my signings when I can see the holes in my line ups rather than holes in my 40 man rosters.

[Careter 1970]

The biggest change that I'd like to see in MLB The Show 13 is a realistic physics engine that would play to a parks dimensions. Just one of many obvious examples would be that homeruns would be drastically easier to come by playing a season in Coors or Great American as opposed to Oakland or Miami. You could also play neutral for places like Kauffman or Nationals Park.

[MLB Bob]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

The biggest change that I'd like to see in MLB The Show 13 is a realistic physics engine that would play to a parks dimensions. Just one of many obvious examples would be that homeruns would be drastically easier to come by playing a season in Coors or Great American as opposed to Oakland or Miami. You could also play neutral for places like Kauffman or Nationals Park.

Pretty sure it already does

[tabarnes19_SDS]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

I asked about this. Yes there are park factors coded in.

[sydrogerdavid]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

The biggest change that I'd like to see in MLB The Show 13 is a realistic physics engine that would play to a parks dimensions. Just one of many obvious examples would be that homeruns would be drastically easier to come by playing a season in Coors or Great American as opposed to Oakland or Miami. You could also play neutral for places like Kauffman or Nationals Park.

First of all, there is already a realistic physics engine in the game. It will be even better in MLB 13 after all the feedback provided from 12.

Second, the game doesn't take into account the dimensions of the ballparks for a reason; and that's a good thing. I'm sure someone else can better describe it...

When you hit the ball, the only ballpark factors the game calculates are the wind speed, direction, and the altitude as to where the stadium is located. So like you wished, a ball hit at Coors already has an advantage over a ball hit at Petco. There is proof in the game that altitude is calculated. Play a round of HRD at Coors and compare it to another stadium. You'll notice the ball travels MUCH farther at Coors than anywhere else. A Coors HRD shot comes close to 500 feet regularly.

On the other hand, the game does not calculate fence dimensions when you hit the ball. In a way, the game is built to not recognize where the fences are. It allows for the dimensions of all the parks to affect the game in a natural way.

For example, let's say that after the hit type, how well you timed it, player ratings, wind, and altitude is calculated, the game decides the ball you hit will travel 320 feet down the LF line. Since the game doesn't take into account the distance of the fence, the ball will naturally travel over the Green Monster and leave Minute Maid Park, while at the same time, it would not make it out of Busch Stadium or Griffith Stadium.

Naturally, this allows parks like GABP and Citizen's Bank Park to be bandboxes, while Marlins Ballpark and Comerica Park are naturally pitchers parks.

[soxfan56]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

I'm sure many people would not care if this was added, or if it is possible, but the ability to play a career mode as an existing mlb player, just like in Madden and NHL, ect... The problem is whether or not EA owns the rights to recent additions to their sports games, also the fact that not many people had a positive response to the new game modes. I would also like to have the ability to have more control when fielding. The players feel locked and you are very limited in your abilities because your player is locked from attempting a diving play at 3rd or an aggressive route to a ball in the outfield to attempt a throw home. This is a must.

[lhslancers]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

I would like the commentary team from the other game. Since I play with a lot of historical rosters it would be nice if the play by play guy went back into the studio and recorded the names of a few hundred top legends so they would be announced at bat and in the field.

A more robust face and body editor would be great.

[dingleberryfinn]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

1) Custom Seasons, where I have the ability to run a 26 team dynasty,
or 16 team if I want to use a classic roster & don't want the Rays
playing in 1927 or 1981.

2) Expanded minor league rosters, from the current 60 players in a teams farm system, to maybe 75 or 85.

3) The ability to edit managers.

4) More batting stances!!

5) More classic stadiums, even if they are DLC & I have to pay $5 a stadium,
I'd buy 25 stadiums if they were available.

[Bluejaysfan65]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

1. More A.I. Realism when it comes to free agency.
2. The ability to have more than one option year. For example, I could offer Kyle Drabek a two year contract with two option years so that it could possible be a 4 year contract.
3. The ability to choose the type of contract. It would be more realistic and cool if we could choose if a contract was front end loaded or if it's worth more in the later years. Also, it would be nice to be able to choose between offering a player a minor league contract and a major league contract.
4. More Uniforms to choose from. I think that explains its self very clearly.
5. Something like what NBA 2K13 has done with their Mycareer mode where you can earn money and use your money to buy equipment or boost your ratings. It would also be nice to see endorsement offers since it seems like Nike is in the game this year. Seeingthe postgame press conference in RTTS would make that mode much more enjoyable and interesting.

[daenius]

Re: Top Five Wishes for MLB 13: The Show

1.) Improved RTTS - not interesting anymore.

2.) Improved ball physics and animations.

Here are some situations that I have experienced numerous times:

For ball physics the main problem that I have are realistic bounces in the outfield (too many ground rule doubles).

In terms of animations:
better and faster animations when fast-paced plays have to be made. I don't mind if mistakes happen (as they do in real life because of the stress and pressure when a play has to be made quickly) as long as I feel that my players seem to make an effort.
One instance where this could and should be implemented:
A tied game in the late innings with runners in scoring position and a playable drive to right field is picked up with that super-slow animation although at least one runner could be thrown out at home plate or even stopped at 3rd base. Due to that animation both runners (or the runner from 2nd base) score.

Another situation:

Pitchers or 3rd basemen picking up bunts, stopping for 1-2 seconds looking in the other direction, then turning around and throwing to 1st base when the runner has already reached 1st base; instead of one fluid animation the player has to stop and then shift into the "turn and throw" animation.