2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Capuano wouldnt last a day in the AL East and Olt's nothing close to A Rod, I think we over hype him a bit, ya he has crazy raw power, but he strikeouts alot as well. A better defending Mark Reynolds wouldnt be a bad comparison here. Olt's a good player, but him plus Capuano I dont think would be able to get Cano even if he is a rental

Capuano is better than Adam fuggin Warren lol.

Olt's a stellar defender with a good hit tool. Mentioning him next to Mark Reynold's name.. no. Just no lol. For a rental Cano he's completely fine. And it wasn't Olt + Capuano, it was Seager + Capuano. Which, too, is completely fine.

elite 3B are scarce

Said no one, ever.

Elite 3B are quite common today. Really common atm lol, nearly every team has an above average 3B.

bad experience with him in last year's Show

HUSH -_-

Hey guys,
Started a new Blue Jays franchise and making a few trades, are these fair?
Get: Kubel For:Jacob Anderson(B)

Get:Reddick For:Moises Sierra(B), Dawel Lugo(B) and Chad Beck(C) (looking to move Bautista to DH)

Get: R.Weeks For: Nessy(B) and Lopes(B)

And finally Get: A.Bailey For: Delebar(B)

Not looking to make all these trades but have them all in mind but want them fair

In order, fair (but I love Anderson), unfair (different B and C than Sierra/Beck, non prospects), you're getting ripped, and you're getting ripped.

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Seager+Capuano is NOT fine for even a rental Cano

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Seager+Capuano is NOT fine for even a rental Cano

Well, it depends. I'm pretty sure Seager is a high B, the highest possible B. If he gets bumped up to an A it's fine. If he's still a high B, it's unfair and a guy like Pederson should be included.

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Well, it depends. I'm pretty sure Seager is a high B, the highest possible B. If he gets bumped up to an A it's fine. If he's still a high B, it's unfair and a guy like Pederson should be included.

Capuano has to be taken outta that trade either way

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Capuano has to be taken outta that trade either way

My God, what's everyone's hate for Capuano? 3.72/3.95/3.97 slash line, *excellent* peripherals, durable enough, if you regress him by like half a run he's still a league average starter in the AL East, which the Yankees need. As someone who isn't the main part of the deal and is essentially a throw in he's a really solid piece.

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

My God, what's everyone's hate for Capuano? 3.72/3.95/3.97 slash line, *excellent* peripherals, durable enough, if you regress him by like half a run he's still a league average starter in the AL East, which the Yankees need. As someone who isn't the main part of the deal and is essentially a throw in he's a really solid piece.

u dont get rid of Cano and accept a 30 something pitcher in return...gimme a promising prospect instead

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

u dont get rid of Cano and accept a 30 something pitcher in return...gimme a promising prospect instead

You are completely ignoring the other half of the deal

You know, the whole 'stud 3B prospect who hit like .400 in his debut last year,' nbd

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

You are completely ignoring the other half of the deal

You know, the whole 'stud 3B prospect who hit like .400 in his debut last year,' nbd

my issue isnt with Seager.....just please take out Capuano and substitute with a promising prospect

[Blue Rangers]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I'm new to this whole site and only found it by accident. I did some reading and I'm trying to figure out how things go here. I'm playing as the Rangers and I have Andrus resigned in my franchise and I'm looking to move Profar. What type of deal would it take to get either Hernandez, Price, Strasburg ( I know none of these would be moved in a normal basis but I'm looking for fair not real) I'm also interested in Stantons Value too. I saw the spread sheet but I want to associate names with these values

[ubernoob]

my issue isnt with Seager.....just please take out Capuano and substitute with a promising prospect

That's not what would be considered fair though, is where they are going with this.

[RevisIsland2010]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Just started a new Yankees franchise and I was getting upset with Curtis Granderson's inability to get on base so I traded him to the Dodgers for Andre Ethier, Dee Gordon and Yasiel Puig. I thought I totally ripped them off; I got an immediate replacement in Ethier, as well as a top-flight prospect that will soon be MLB ready and a speedster who will come off the bench until Jeter retires, at which point I plan to make him the everyday SS. How'd I do?

[ubernoob]

Probably the wrong thread. This one is about making trades fair. The cheese trade that exploits bad trade AI is down the hall.

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

That's not what would be considered fair though, is where they are going with this.

so u think leaving Capuano in would make it fair?

[ubernoob]

so u think leaving Capuano in would make it fair?

Honestly I haven't looked up any of the values... But an elite prospect and someone to provide a solid starting pitcher is fair value for a half year rental to me for Cano.

Maybe another mid C to high C prospect added in.

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Honestly I haven't looked up any of the values... But an elite prospect and someone to provide a solid starting pitcher is fair value for a half year rental to me for Cano.

lol...just lol