2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Come on..

9% BB%

12% K%

Solid line drive hitter, 23%

The eyes of one NY-athlete-hating person isn't the only way to evaluate a player

there was no bias with my critique whatsoever

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

there was no bias with my critique whatsoever

No one can have a 100% bias free opinion. No one.

I'm providing facts and you're saying he looks like he has no upside... ugh, whatever you say.

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

No one can have a 100% bias free opinion. No one.

I'm providing facts and you're saying he looks like he has no upside... ugh, whatever you say.

he doesnt belong in any Ells trade.....point blank period

[merchie89]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

All I know is, I was able to trade Farnsworth for Lance Lynn straight up....fair or not, I made that trade

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

he doesnt belong in any Ells trade.....point blank period

And I'm saying that I strongly disagree with this statement because it's rather shortsighted

[Bronx Bomber03]

All I know is, I was able to trade Farnsworth for Lance Lynn straight up....fair or not, I made that trade

Its not fair at all, but the purpose of this thread is to help people find fair and/or realistic deals. If you need help finding these type of deals, then this is the place to go. This isn't much a rip-off the CPU thread.

Sent via Tapatalk

[Pesan915]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Hey guys, what would it take to trade for Billy Hamilton? I notice he plays CF, however, Shin-Soo Choo is there and Billy's secondary positions are 2B and SS and Reds are pretty good there. Thanks

[Bronx Bomber03]

Hey guys, what would it take to trade for Billy Hamilton? I notice he plays CF, however, Shin-Soo Choo is there and Billy's secondary positions are 2B and SS and Reds are pretty good there. Thanks

Check out the spreadsheet in the original post for values. What team are you?

Sent via Tapatalk

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Check out the spreadsheet in the original post for values. What team are you?

Sent via Tapatalk

Is Hamilton even on the spreadsheet?

He'd have to be on the 40 man roster to be on the spreadsheet, and for him to be on the spreadsheet would be a stupid move by CIN.

[Bronx Bomber03]

Is Hamilton even on the spreadsheet?

He'd have to be on the 40 man roster to be on the spreadsheet, and for him to be on the spreadsheet would be a stupid move by CIN.

Oh yeah! What was I thinking!?

Sent via Tapatalk

[Pesan915]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Check out the spreadsheet in the original post for values. What team are you?

Sent via Tapatalk

Well I'm waiting for V2 rosters to drop in. So in the mean time I'm deciding between Angels and I would put him at (SS).. Red Sox put him at CF and move Ellsbury to RF...Seattle, put him at CF... Braves, put him at 2B and trade Uggla or If I go with Marlins ill most likely put him at CF... Eventually once the V2 rosters get released ill be doing my franchise with one of them

[merchie89]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I know, I just stated that just to put it out there...dumb trade.

I try to make good ones. It took a good haul to get trumbo from Angels.

[BlueJays09]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Hey guys, currently just finished season 1 of my Jays franchise and going into playoffs. I started alot of my young guys last 4-5 games to see them and noticing that Sierra and Dominic Smith (my 1st pick this season) are great young players and will improve big time over the offseason.

I want to trade Lawrie (love in real life), cause i cant quite get use to his batting and stuff so I feel I want to move him to move Bautista to 3B and Sierra to RF. Now for Lawire I dont want older guys but young prospects (preferably guys who are actually playing with the big clubs atm in real life). I would like preferably a INF (2B, 3B, SS) + a OF.

This may be hard to find a MLB team with young players currently on their rosters in real life that match this criteria and are worth Lawrie but not looking for real as much I want a fair trade that they get a great young bat in Lawrie and I get some young not as good talent back.

I know you guys are up to the challenge so here we go...thanks to all in advance love this thread you guys are the best!

[Totte]

Hey guys, currently just finished season 1 of my Jays franchise and going into playoffs. I started alot of my young guys last 4-5 games to see them and noticing that Sierra and Dominic Smith (my 1st pick this season) are great young players and will improve big time over the offseason.

I want to trade Lawrie (love in real life), cause i cant quite get use to his batting and stuff so I feel I want to move him to move Bautista to 3B and Sierra to RF. Now for Lawire I dont want older guys but young prospects (preferably guys who are actually playing with the big clubs atm in real life). I would like preferably a INF (2B, 3B, SS) + a OF.

This may be hard to find a MLB team with young players currently on their rosters in real life that match this criteria and are worth Lawrie but not looking for real as much I want a fair trade that they get a great young bat in Lawrie and I get some young not as good talent back.

I know you guys are up to the challenge so here we go...thanks to all in advance love this thread you guys are the best!

Lawrie to the Mariners? You could get Nick Franklin for 2B/SS, Alex Liddi for 3B/1B, Michael Saunders for OF and maybe another lesser prospect

Send him back to the D'backs for Chris Owings and Corbin/Skaggs?

Lawrie to Oakland for Reddick and Weeks?

To Cleveland for A-Cab?

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Lawrie to the Mariners? You could get Nick Franklin for 2B/SS, Alex Liddi for 3B/1B, Michael Saunders for OF and maybe another lesser prospect

Send him back to the D'backs for Chris Owings and Corbin/Skaggs?

Lawrie to Oakland for Reddick and Weeks?

To Cleveland for A-Cab?

All of these trades would be painful to me lol

Anthopoulos HAS, in fact, attempted to trade Lawrie. Once for Michael Pineda, and once he came up in talks for one of Gio/Latos.

Lawrie + Smoral for Cespedes + their new Japanese IF?

Lawrie for Bauer/Chisenhall/Cabrera to Cleveland would work, I think. You may have to add in a prospect.

If you're up for inter-division trading, Lawrie for Zobrist is fair.

Lawrie to Washington for Rendon + Goodwin + another piece also sounds fine.

For a 4 win 23 year old with ridiculous defense and amazing hitting skills who's a top 5 young player in the league lol, these sound pretty fair.

*Disclaimer* None of these are remotely realistic