MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

[sink4ever]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

Knight you are a god amongst mere mortals in the editing business my friend!! Just got a couple questions that haven't been answered yet. Was wondering if you were going to address those 2 reds players I suggested? If not no biggie but was just wondering. Also, are you replacing the guys that are like lifetime minor leaguers that are A potentials that shouldn't be. There was about 3 per team I'd say. Again, reason I ask is because I'm going to do it myself on my own if it doesn't get addressed. Thanks and keep up the awesome work man!!

Pretty sure this has been answered, but just in case let's do it again.

The 'A' potential lifetime minor leaguers are NOT an error. When creating a player this year, if you put in the name and audio of a player who has been in the game before, the editor will automatically give that player their correct face. Since the player is being created from scratch, they are given an 'A' potential. Because these guys are older, the 'A' potential won't impact their progression.

I could be wrong, but I think you may have brought up that this causes the CPU team to value the player too highly. I don't believe at this time that it's much of a concern for most people (at least I haven't read of any other complaints).

[callmetaternuts]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

I am just releasing/creating players no longer with the organizations since they edited them.

Do you guys want a list of players that are going to be overwritten to double check?...

Bryce Cox-Bos
T.J. Large-Bos
R. De los Santos-TB
Russ Canzler-TB
Ricky Orta-TB
Dirk Hayhurst-TB
Chris Bootcheck-TB
Jeff Sues-ChiA
Jared Price-ChiA
Jeff Bailey-Minn
Whitney Robbins-Minn
Nick Livingston-Minn
Matt Watson-Oak
Cedric Bowers-Oak
Derrick Gordon-Oak
Andy Jenkins-Tex

Let me know if any of those guys should remain or just be moved somewhere.

Thanks!

M.K.
Knight165

Hey Knight, Orta can go (probably replace with Robinson Chirinos, AAA catcher (secondary should be IF), but the others are all in AAA and probably should stick.

[El_MaYiMbE]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

Knight I had asked to Bartolo Colon to be exported from the 4/4/11 update, but I don't think that is a good idea.


Disadvantage:

They didn't use his hidden face! It looks NOTHING like Colon, AND they still didn't include his name in the audio (Bart instead of Bartolo).

Advantage:

His MLB service is accurate 10+ years.
His face is editable, but someone would have to be able to make him look exactly like Colon for it to be worth it.

[gman2774]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

Yes. The CPU will fill the 40 man per whatever algorithm it uses, and also arrange the CPU batting orders as it sees fit.

This is all on page 1 in Knight's conveniently written first post.

Will messed up CPU batting orders have a stat affect on simulated games?

I love the rosters but don't want the hassle of managing CPU line-ups/rotations and don't care if I have 100% accurate 40 man rosters. But I do care that the team I'm playing have a realistic batting order. So, I use the 2nd controller before starting each game and edit the cpu's line-up myself.

[cjandebe]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

Knight- I've seen this discussed, but have not seen a direct answer so I thought I would follow up. Are you exporting players from the 4/4 update to your opening day set? For example, Brandon Belt, Bartolo Colon, and Nikiosha (Min). Or are you going to keep the players that were created, in the opening day set? 'appreciate all your work and everyone else who had a hand in these rosters.

[El_MaYiMbE]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

Knight- I've seen this discussed, but have not seen a direct answer so I thought I would follow up. Are you exporting players from the 4/4 update to your opening day set? For example, Brandon Belt, Bartolo Colon, and Nikiosha (Min). Or are you going to keep the players that were created, in the opening day set? 'appreciate all your work and everyone else who had a hand in these rosters.

He is exporting the ones that is worth the export. ALOT of the players I seen from Knights original set are good. Colon is an example (see a few post above). He looks 100x better on Knights set then the SCEA version. So I have asked Knight to consider NOT using SCEA's version of Colon.

He will import the ones that SCEA created if there is an advantage over his set.

[cjandebe]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

He is exporting the ones that is worth the export. ALOT of the players I seen from Knights original set are good. Colon is an example (see a few post above). He looks 100x better on Knights set then the SCEA version. So I have asked Knight to consider NOT using SCEA's version of Colon.

He will import the ones that SCEA created if there is an advantage over his set.

One of the reasons I ask is because of the contract situation with such players. I notice a lot of the CAPs in OSFM don't have contracts. How does this affect in franchise?

Also, I'm a Twins fan, and Nikiosha is rated a lot better in the 4/4 roster than in the OSFM roster. And Belt is rated a lot lower in the 4/4 roster than in the OSFM roster.

Will there be a list provided of who is exported from the 4/4 roster into the OSFM Opening Day roster? IMHO that would be helpful in case people want to import players from the 4/4 roster that Knight does not import.

Hope this wasn't too confusing. And as always, 'appreciate all the hardwork by everyone. Thanks.

[19]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

One of the reasons I ask is because of the contract situation with such players. I notice a lot of the CAPs in OSFM don't have contracts. How does this affect in franchise?

Also, I'm a Twins fan, and Nikiosha is rated a lot better in the 4/4 roster than in the OSFM roster. And Belt is rated a lot lower in the 4/4 roster than in the OSFM roster.

Will there be a list provided of who is exported from the 4/4 roster into the OSFM Opening Day roster? IMHO that would be helpful in case people want to import players from the 4/4 roster that Knight does not import.

Hope this wasn't too confusing. And as always, 'appreciate all the hardwork by everyone. Thanks.

I have actually already done this on the roster I am planning on using for my Franchise. I've exported most, but not all the SCEA players, and un-injured all the big name players (Wainwright/Strasburg/Santana/Utley) and placed them back on the MLB roster, along with players I created that you can find in this thread.

I could post it in the Vault if you want, although I'm a little wary to do so without permission from the people who worked so hard on the meat of the roster set.

But if Knight says it's OK, I'll put it up there for you if you're interested.

[Knight165]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

I have actually already done this on the roster I am planning on using for my Franchise. I've exported most, but not all the SCEA players, and un-injured all the big name players (Wainwright/Strasburg/Santana/Utley) and placed them back on the MLB roster, along with players I created that you can find in this thread.

I could post it in the Vault if you want, although I'm a little wary to do so without permission from the people who worked so hard on the meat of the roster set.

But if Knight says it's OK, I'll put it up there for you if you're interested.

No problem.
Once they are out there....I think we all know(and appreciate!) guys working off them to make different iterations of it....improving....changing...whatever.
Be our guest!

M.K.
Knight165

[19]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

No problem.
Once they are out there....I think we all know(and appreciate!) guys working off them to make different iterations of it....improving....changing...whatever.
Be our guest!

M.K.
Knight165

Will do Knight.

File Name : OSFMv4+SCEA CAPs

Username : HabloCon19

This roster includes... SCEA players imported into OSFM STV4, Opening Day 40 Man Rosters for MLB (Lineups/Rotations), star players back on MLB Roster, HabloCon19 prospects.

[bravesfan1984]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

hey knight, the Braves released minor league 1B Barbaro Canizares

[cjandebe]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

No problem.
Once they are out there....I think we all know(and appreciate!) guys working off them to make different iterations of it....improving....changing...whatever.
Be our guest!

M.K.
Knight165

Knight, so are you not going to be exporting any SCEA 4/4 roster players into your opening day set?

[bravesfan1984]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

knight, Canizares can probably be replaced with Scott Proctor because the Braves re-signed him to a minor league deal

[tonybologna]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

knight, Canizares can probably be replaced with Scott Proctor because the Braves re-signed him to a minor league deal

I don't think Canizares should be removed. He probably will be called up at some point. We really don't have a true backup at 1B other than Hinske. He'll probably give Prado a break in LF more often than Freeman. Canizares can hit.

His numbers at AAA have been solid for the past few years. I think keeping him on the roster would be the right thing to do but it's Knight's choice. Proctor might get a call as well to the MLB club but I think Canizares would go up before him unless we take a hit with pitcher injuries first. :wink:

[bravesfan1984]

Re: MLB 11 The Show - Operation Sports Full Minors 2011 (Spring Training Version)

I don't think Canizares should be removed. He probably will be called up at some point. We really don't have a true backup at 1B other than Hinske. He'll probably give Prado a break in LF more often than Freeman. Canizares can hit.

His numbers at AAA have been solid for the past few years. I think keeping him on the roster would be the right thing to do but it's Knight's choice. Proctor might get a call as well to the MLB club but I think Canizares would go up before him unless we take a hit with pitcher injuries first. :wink:

Tony, the Braves released Canizares

http://www.gwinnettdailypost.com/sports/headlines/Braves_release_G-Braves_1B_Canizares_119152059.html