2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ksig24
    Resident Scout
    • Feb 2006
    • 1417

    #31
    Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

    Yes, we have a bunch of them already added. I will be editing bodies tonight and ARoid will be doing faces.

    Comment

    • CKW11
      MVP
      • Mar 2009
      • 1540

      #32
      Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

      Hey Ksig you released these into the vault? There's a roster named KSig24 Top prospects and the description is OSFM Top 100. All the players are on the Orioles. Just wondering if you did this or if it's an imposter.

      Comment

      • ksig24
        Resident Scout
        • Feb 2006
        • 1417

        #33
        Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

        Its mine, but I am going to add another one right now with some extras included. I had about 5 A rated position players left over so I added the guys whom I feel are the highest upside players with the best chance of becoming All-Stars.

        I really wanted to add Gyorko, Swihart, Marte, Gray, Odorizzi and a few others.

        Comment

        • BatsareBugs
          LVP
          • Feb 2003
          • 12553

          #34
          Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

          ksig, I haven't had a chance to look at the top 100 you posted on the roster vault, but the list you posted earlier here is missing Milwaukee and Minnesota. Did Miguel Sano and Jean Segura make the cut for A's?

          Comment

          • ksig24
            Resident Scout
            • Feb 2006
            • 1417

            #35
            Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

            Did I miss them????

            Never heard of the first guy and Segura didnt make it. I dont see him being an impact player at this point. I have seen him in person several times and though he does fly, unless the Halos stick him in CF then I dont see the value. As you know LAA has a CF logjam at this point.

            Comment

            • BDKiiing
              Best in the World
              • Jun 2008
              • 9334

              #36
              Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

              Originally posted by ksig24
              Did I miss them????

              Never heard of the first guy and Segura didnt make it. I dont see him being an impact player at this point. I have seen him in person several times and though he does fly, unless the Halos stick him in CF then I dont see the value. As you know LAA has a CF logjam at this point.

              If that's in reference to Miguel Sano, I hope you're joking.
              St. Louis Cardinals | Milwaukee Bucks | Los Angeles Rams
              UWW | UWGB | Duke
              AEW

              Comment

              • 55
                Banned
                • Mar 2006
                • 20857

                #37
                Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

                Originally posted by bdolski
                If that's in reference to Miguel Sano, I hope you're joking.
                He clearly is, as Sano is listed as an A prospect in this very thread.

                I take it Hak-Ju Lee is a high B then?

                Comment

                • BatsareBugs
                  LVP
                  • Feb 2003
                  • 12553

                  #38
                  Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

                  Originally posted by ksig24
                  Did I miss them????

                  Never heard of the first guy and Segura didnt make it. I dont see him being an impact player at this point. I have seen him in person several times and though he does fly, unless the Halos stick him in CF then I dont see the value. As you know LAA has a CF logjam at this point.

                  No problem at all ksig I gotta admit I chuckled a bit at this response.

                  Comment

                  • ksig24
                    Resident Scout
                    • Feb 2006
                    • 1417

                    #39
                    Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

                    Originally posted by 55
                    He clearly is, as Sano is listed as an A prospect in this very thread.

                    I take it Hak-Ju Lee is a high B then?
                    Yeah a high B, and I love his upside.

                    Comment

                    • ksig24
                      Resident Scout
                      • Feb 2006
                      • 1417

                      #40
                      Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

                      Originally posted by Rag3vsW0rld
                      No problem at all ksig I gotta admit I chuckled a bit at this response.
                      No worries at all brochacho! I figured the thread could use a bit of humor. Whats the good word on Cumberland?

                      Comment

                      • PadresFan
                        Underrated
                        • Feb 2003
                        • 1147

                        #41
                        Originally posted by ksig24
                        Been gone for a few days and would like to know what I have missed. Waiting on Knight to respond to one of my questions regarding the top prospect project. Being that I am extremely meticulous and picky when it comes to a true A rated prospect I wanted to ease up a bit for the experience. My motion is to add a selected few of A rated prospects per team and rate them accordingly. That way you Padres fans will get your Liriano, Kelly, Grandal, Hedges and Erlin's as well as the Brewers fans with Jungmann, Bradley, Thornberg etc.

                        What this will entail is a true A rated prospect with a high ceiling being rated as such from the graph and a B+(A) prospect being given an A, but projected ceiling stats lower in reference to the graph.

                        Make sense? I think it will offer the user a better experience.
                        I greatly respect your expertise and opinions about prospects. I agree you with about Padres prospects. Although they have a great farm system, I don't feel like they have a sure fire A prospect... yet.

                        Players like Liriano, Ross, Hedges and Sampson could become A prospects with more seasoning/experience in the higher levels.

                        Anyway, just wanted to give my two cents as a Padres faithful and avid minor league follower. I appreciate your insight and advanced knowledge of players.



                        Sent from my SCH-I510 using Tapatalk

                        Comment

                        • BatsareBugs
                          LVP
                          • Feb 2003
                          • 12553

                          #42
                          Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

                          Originally posted by ksig24
                          No worries at all brochacho! I figured the thread could use a bit of humor. Whats the good word on Cumberland?
                          Unfortunately it's not good. He was doing extremely well in Spring Training, but decided to hang the cleats up again when his symptoms started to appear again.

                          In my opinion I think his playing days are over, apparently he had a bunch of concussions when he was in high school that damaged his inner ears or something like that, causing all sorts of balance problems and such.

                          Originally posted by PadresFan
                          I greatly respect your expertise and opinions about prospects. I agree you with about Padres prospects. Although they have a great farm system, I don't feel like they have a sure fire A prospect... yet.

                          Players like Liriano, Ross, Hedges and Sampson could become A prospects with more seasoning/experience in the higher levels.

                          Anyway, just wanted to give my two cents as a Padres faithful and avid minor league follower. I appreciate your insight and advanced knowledge of players.



                          Sent from my SCH-I510 using Tapatalk
                          That's the thing with the Padres farm system, especially with younger, high ceiling players. The oldest player in that bunch is Rymer Liriano and even he is still probably three years away with so much time for him to either improve on last season (show a bit more power that he possesses) or could whittle away like many other Padre international signees. Who knows, next year three of the four could be five-stars on BP and be in the top 30, or they could all fall off (like what happened to Jaff Decker, Matt Antonelli, Donovan Tate).

                          A perfect example would be Latos. He arguably had the stuff for a frontline starter, but he was drafted in the teen rounds I believe and was never in the top 100, however if the Padres failed to sign him back in 2006, he easily could've been a first round pick the next time he was eligible.

                          I'll probably be a bit conservative with the Padres prospect potential ratings (and fortunately I had done the D'Backs first, as it would be discouraging to redo the top prospects ratings and such again), but I might end up .zip my original top prospects ratings in a separate file for people to download and import.

                          On a side note this is why I wish the dynamic potential feature in MLB The Show was more frequent in both ways. You have players whose stocks jump up greatly each year and others whose stocks fall off the table. Liriano already has made a big jump from a C to a B+ over the course of a year, likewise, Matt Antonelli went from a top second base prospect (A-) to a mediocre player rather quickly.
                          Last edited by BatsareBugs; 03-14-2012, 10:45 PM.

                          Comment

                          • ksig24
                            Resident Scout
                            • Feb 2006
                            • 1417

                            #43
                            Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

                            Seriously thinking about making Segura an A!

                            Comment

                            • bohica41
                              Rookie
                              • Oct 2010
                              • 22

                              #44
                              Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

                              Will Myers has not proven that he can hit in the minor leagues. I think he should be a B prospect...look at his track record. Still make for a descent Pro eventually.

                              Comment

                              • CKW11
                                MVP
                                • Mar 2009
                                • 1540

                                #45
                                Re: 2012 OSFM: Top Prospects

                                Originally posted by bohica41
                                Will Myers has not proven that he can hit in the minor leagues. I think he should be a B prospect...look at his track record. Still make for a descent Pro eventually.
                                His track record shows he CAN hit...He has a .296 average, he just had a bad year last year. If it wasn't for his .254 average last year he would probably be hitting over .300 for his minor league career. And he's hit double digit HR's every year except last year.

                                Comment

                                Working...