OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

[optimistic121]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Personally for the old old players I love the cartoonish look. If you pop in an old version of the game with the legends teams in the game many of the legends provided by SCEA actually have cartoonish looking cyberfaces.

Not like they weren't cartoonish to begin with or anything...



Big fan of your files, guys. Glad to finally be on OS. As I start my Washington Senators roster, I may take a stab at creating Frank Howard, assuming no one else has.

[optimistic121]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Not like they weren't cartoonish to begin with or anything...


Big fan of your files, guys. Glad to finally be on OS. As I start my Washington Senators roster, I may take a stab at creating Frank Howard, assuming no one else has.

Whoops, spoke too soon. Saw he'd already been created. Rookie mistake.

[Culture Rot]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Great work on these

[bedwardsroy19]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

I might be jumping the gun on this a little bit, but I have to believe that Matt Kemp should be on the Dodgers team. I think you could even make a case for him to be a starter on the team.

Yellow= All players info completed
Green= Info/Face completed (not rated)
Purple= Waiting to be exported

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/...hl=en_US#gid=3

[drsublime]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

I might be jumping the gun on this a little bit, but I have to believe that Matt Kemp should be on the Dodgers team. I think you could even make a case for him to be a starter on the team.

Yellow= All players info completed
Green= Info/Face completed (not rated)
Purple= Waiting to be exported

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/...hl=en_US#gid=3

considering that he had the greatest single offensive season in Dodgers history, i would have to agree with you.

also on the diamondbacks, Spivey, Daal and Counsell are up in the vault.


bump Furillo or Davis for Kemp, easily so what if you have to move him to a corner

one thing for the Dodgers.. are we going to add Rick Monday (1st #1 pick ever and the "flag hero")? if so i have a really solid version of him from last year that i can re-create.

[drsublime]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

I'd really like to see Randy Johnson moved to the Diamondbacks
yea he played less years there vs Seattle (8 vs 10)
but in seattle he had ONE Cy Young, and 5 all star appearances

in arizona he had 4 consecutive cy youngs, 4 all star games, and a world series mvp and for 5 years garnered mvp votes

kinda bugs me that the greatest pitcher in arizona sports history isnt on the team

http://www.baseball-reference.com/pl...ohnsra05.shtml


his career highs in wins, innings, strikeouts and compete games all were with arizona


he was a better player w/ arizona then he was w/ seattle, the numbers dont lie,


also, i'd think this is a superior version of randy for the file then the current one on the roster

(yea i made it)


and now i'll end my big unit rant . lol

[TruBluDodgerFan]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

"considering that he had the greatest single offensive season in Dodgers history, i would have to agree with you.

also on the diamondbacks, Spivey, Daal and Counsell are up in the vault.


bump Furillo or Davis for Kemp, easily so what if you have to move him to a corner

one thing for the Dodgers.. are we going to add Rick Monday (1st #1 pick ever and the "flag hero")? if so i have a really solid version of him from last year that i can re-create."

I AGREE TOO! Would love to have MONDAY and KEMP for Davis and Furillo

[Culture Rot]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

bedwardsroy can you please share with us what method you used for generating player ratings? I found them to be pretty accurate and want to use the same method for my mlb 12 rosters

[obscureguy]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

I'd really like to see Randy Johnson moved to the Diamondbacks
yea he played less years there vs Seattle (8 vs 10)
but in seattle he had ONE Cy Young, and 5 all star appearances

in arizona he had 4 consecutive cy youngs, 4 all star games, and a world series mvp and for 5 years garnered mvp votes

kinda bugs me that the greatest pitcher in arizona sports history isnt on the team

http://www.baseball-reference.com/pl...ohnsra05.shtml


his career highs in wins, innings, strikeouts and compete games all were with arizona


he was a better player w/ arizona then he was w/ seattle, the numbers dont lie,


also, i'd think this is a superior version of randy for the file then the current one on the roster

(yea i made it)


and now i'll end my big unit rant . lol

considering how many diamondbacks you release on a daily basis this is a pretty unbiased opinion....lol just kidding bro

You can def. make the case either way but I'd have to lean toward the Mariners just because it kinda feels like thats where he made a name for himself...but yea he won WS with Arizona so its def. a good argument. Ive got him on Seattle on my roster personally but you could go either way.

[drsublime]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

yea he made the name, but he was the most dominant pitcher in baseball in his time in arizona.. cant say the same for seattle.

seattle was young wild scary randy

arizona was wily precise scary randy lol

[WinMINTwins]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Just a few of small problems with the Twins:
-There is absolutely no way anybody plays 1st other than the Killer. I love Morneau and Hrbek, but Killebrew belongs at 1st base, and nowhere else. Subsequently, Gary Gaetti should be the 3rd baseman.
-I don't know if this is just the way it was typed in or whatever, but Rick Aguilera was, until last year, the only guy with more saves as a Twin than Joe Nathan. I don't see how he can be the 40th man.
-Juan Rincon? Really?

[OhioBobcats]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Just a few of small problems with the Twins:
-There is absolutely no way anybody plays 1st other than the Killer. I love Morneau and Hrbek, but Killebrew belongs at 1st base, and nowhere else.

Killebrew's best years were '62-'63, '66-'67, then '69-70

He played:

353 games at 3B
314 games at 1B
306 games in the OF

So, umm, stats don't lie. He was a jack of all trades, but a master at none when it came to fielding. It's not like he was a nasty defender at any position.

[mvattivo]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

First off, I want to say thank you so much to all of you working on this project. The faces posted are absolutely phenomenal !!!! I'm loving playing my season with Knights / Ridin's rosters, but, I'm looking forward to these ones even more. You guys are amazing, and your work is so greatly appreciated.

Now, I wanted to state some opinions on the Pirates roster:

Bill Madlock is the 2nd best Pirates 3rd baseman of all-time, in my opinion. (Other than Pie Traynor) I'd have the 3rd baseman as follows: 1. Traynor 2. Madlock 3. Richie Hebner 4. Dick Hoak 5. Tommy Leach

I'd have Lloyd Waner as the starter in CF.

For what it's worth, here would be my roster:

1 - C - Jason Kendall
2 - 1B - Willie Stargell
3 - 2B - Bill Mazeroski
4 - 3B - Pie Traynor
5 - SS - Honus Wagner
6 - LF - Ralph Kiner
7 - CF - Lloyd Waner
8 - RF - Roberto Clemente
9 - SP - Harvey Haddix
10 - SP - Vern Law
11 - SP - John Candelaria
12 - SP - Bob Friend
13 - SP - Doug Drabek
14 - CL - Kent Tekulve
15 - RP - Elroy Face
16 - RP - Dave Giusti
17 - RP - Stan Belinda
18 - RP - Grant Jackson
19 - RP - Al McBean
20 - C - Jason Kendall
21 - 1B - Dick Stuart
22 - 2B - Rennie Stennett
23 - 3B - Bill Madlock
24 - SS - Dick Groat
25 - LF - Max Carey
26 - CF - Andy Van Slyke
27 - RF - Paul Waner
28 - SP - Steve Blass
29 - SP - Wilbur Cooper
30 - SP - Steve Blass
31 - SP - Bob Veale
32 - SP - Deacon Phillippe
33 - CF - Bill Virdon
34 - RF - Dave Parker
35 - CF - Omar Moreno
36 - 3B - Richie Hebner
37 - C - Smokey Burgess
38 - C - Tony Pena
39 - 3B - Don Hoak
40 - RF - Bobby Bonilla

Just my opinion, and this is assuming that Bonds (SF) & Jay Bell (ARI) are on other teams. I'm, of course, happy with whatever you guys come up with, and your Pirates is pretty good, I just wanted to give my opinion. Thanks again.

Any other Pirate fans want to chime in ? I do think they have a few things wrong, in my opinion, on the Buccos roster. Any other opinions ?

[Curahee]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Just out of curiosity, why are you taking pics of your TV screen and not making screencaps thru your XMB?

[drsublime]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

its easier to post (google+)