The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

[slayter]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

Anyone else feel like there are too many errors?

Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk

Me!

But I’m playing the Marlins, so maybe it’s fine. 😜

[SlimeySnake88]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

Anyone else feel like there are too many errors?

I've played 6 games so far and they all were 0-1 errors per game which is normal. Except for 1 game against the Reds where they had 6 errors. To make matters worse I still somehow lost that game while using the Dodgers.

[kamackeris76]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

Just beat the athletics 10 - 1 and they had 3 errors... I'm getting multiple every game

Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

Me!

But I’m playing the Marlins, so maybe it’s fine. 😜

Miami did have the most errors per game last season, but they're much better this year

Law of averages I suppose lol

[Wolves F C]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

You should be averaging about .5 errors per game per team. one every 2 games...

[DetroitStyle]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

Batting averages are a pesky one. There are typically more than the 10 players listed on the league leaderboards, but there's a PA threshold that players need to be placed on the leaderboard.

Lowering starter stamina has worked for me, but it's a tricky balance because if you decrease it too much, ERAs increase.

I also noticed that as the season goes on, batting averages go down. I wonder if durability/injuries slider affects it.

It's really friggin tricky. ERA/BA are tied directly to Stamina. So you have to pick your poison - realistic ERAs or realistic averages.

Hook is a little more forgiving as it controls the amount of Ks/IP/CG/SHOs. But again, pick your poison. You can get realistic amount of Ks and IPs or a realistic amount of CG/SHOs.

If you choose Averages, Ks, and IP go with 3 Stamina and 4 Hook. I've done dozens of sims and those numbers give the most realistic variety.

Also to your point I tested injury slider and it didn't appear to have any affect on the leader boards unless turned off completely. Reliever stamina also didn't have any affect on averages or ERA from my testing.

I initally zeroed out RP Stamina hoping it would improve averages without nerfing starters but that wasn't the case.

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

It's really friggin tricky. ERA/BA are tied directly to Stamina. So you have to pick your poison - realistic ERAs or realistic averages.

Hook is a little more forgiving as it controls the amount of Ks/IP/CG/SHOs. But again, pick your poison. You can get realistic amount of Ks and IPs or a realistic amount of CG/SHOs.

If you choose Averages, Ks, and IP go with 3 Stamina and 4 Hook. I've done dozens of sims and those numbers give the most realistic variety.

Also to your point I tested injury slider and it didn't appear to have any affect on the leader boards unless turned off completely. Reliever stamina also didn't have any affect on averages or ERA from my testing.

I initally zeroed out RP Stamina hoping it would improve averages without nerfing starters but that wasn't the case.

Is this what you're going with? Are you liking the results for batting averages, or are you saying they still aren't where they should be?

If they still aren't, it may be either the clucth attribute or durability attribute? I tested clutch and had inconsistent results from what I recall.

[The Kid 24]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

It's really friggin tricky. ERA/BA are tied directly to Stamina. So you have to pick your poison - realistic ERAs or realistic averages.



Hook is a little more forgiving as it controls the amount of Ks/IP/CG/SHOs. But again, pick your poison. You can get realistic amount of Ks and IPs or a realistic amount of CG/SHOs.



If you choose Averages, Ks, and IP go with 3 Stamina and 4 Hook. I've done dozens of sims and those numbers give the most realistic variety.



Also to your point I tested injury slider and it didn't appear to have any affect on the leader boards unless turned off completely. Reliever stamina also didn't have any affect on averages or ERA from my testing.



I initally zeroed out RP Stamina hoping it would improve averages without nerfing starters but that wasn't the case.

So 3/3/4, SP Sta/RP Sta/Hook is the way to go??


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[DetroitStyle]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

Is this what you're going with? Are you liking the results for batting averages, or are you saying they still aren't where they should be?

If they still aren't, it may be either the clucth attribute or durability attribute? I tested clutch and had inconsistent results from what I recall.

Correct, I'm liking the results of:

SP Stamina: 3
RP Stamina: 3
Hook: 4

It gives a good variety of averages but ERA is really high. Then again you can't get ERA down to real levels until you go Stamina 10. By that point, you'll only see 1 or 2 batters hit over .300.

Here's my data points for Stamina 3 Hook 4. I simmed the same 1st season several times and averaged the leaderboard numbers. The comparison is 2018, 2019, and 2021 real life season.

The averages were take from the top 16 players on the leaderboard. Not the best for determining global accuracy but the best we can do with what SCEA gives us in terms of stat sorting.

SIM/REAL LIFE
Batting Average: .310/.311
ERA: 3.45/2.83
SHO: 1.75/1.16
Ks: 223/236
CG: 1.88/1.625
IP: 195/200

Also note this was tested with Sim Injury at 8.

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

Correct, I'm liking the results of:

SP Stamina: 3
RP Stamina: 3
Hook: 4

It gives a good variety of averages but ERA is really high. Then again you can't get ERA down to real levels until you go Stamina 10. By that point, you'll only see 1 or 2 batters hit over .300.

Here's my data points for Stamina 3 Hook 4. I simmed the same 1st season several times and averaged the leaderboard numbers. The comparison is 2018, 2019, and 2021 real life season.

The averages were take from the top 16 players on the leaderboard. Not the best for determining global accuracy but the best we can do with what SCEA gives us in terms of stat sorting.

SIM/REAL LIFE
Batting Average: .310/.311
ERA: 3.45/2.83
SHO: 1.75/1.16
Ks: 223/236
CG: 1.88/1.625
IP: 195/200

Also note this was tested with Sim Injury at 8.

This is awesome stuff

How did you feel injuries were at 8? Too many or good?

[DetroitStyle]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

This is awesome stuff

How did you feel injuries were at 8? Too many or good?

It seems good. Hard to say, there's no way to track easily in game so it's all about feel. I also play a lot of OOTP and injuries are BRUTAL there lol.

[I_HATE_THAT_DUDE]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

Silly question but w/controlling all the teams is there a way to Sim the other games so you get score updates during the game of the team.you plan to use primarily?

Sent from my SM-N986W using Operation Sports mobile app

[knich1]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

Silly question but w/controlling all the teams is there a way to Sim the other games so you get score updates during the game of the team.you plan to use primarily?

Sent from my SM-N986W using Operation Sports mobile app

Yes go to calendar screen and select today’s games. Then sim all the cpu games except game you will play. Play your game.

[kamackeris76]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

You should be averaging about .5 errors per game per team. one every 2 games...

It's errors in played games that seem really high to me. Sim seems OK

Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 22

It's errors in played games that seem really high to me. Sim seems OK

Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk

Bump throwing errors and fielding erros down 1 notch