The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Do they get added back to the 40 man and elevated to the MLB club at the start of year 2?

Sent from my SM-S918U using Operation Sports mobile app

Yes they do

[knich1]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I believe Kirby St. John is a 61, pretty sure he's a dev.

Amazing work on these rosters fellas!

Kirby was a real ball player. He still thinks he can play.

Which roster base did you guys use to create this? Original out of the box, opening day?
Super small but it irks me that in the another groups rosters it shows Sano and a few others as rookies. Also hoping to have as many of yhe international signings with names in commentary if I can help it.
I know its dumb buy immersion for me is huge?

How's everyone feel about ratings? The only one that I've noticed that I was skeptical about is Buxton who is lucky to break 100 games a season. Tremendous talent but hardly stays on the field. Not a complaint I can always go in an make changes, just curious what everyone else sees?
Thank you for your hard work on these rosters, can't wait to get started. If I could just decide on a damn team lol.....toughest year ever making a choice.

Is there another team aside from the Yankees?

[knich1]

The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

One thing I noticed on Nolan Schanuel, currently says his service time is 0.00 but he played in Majors last season.

Do you know what his service time is? Surprised you're not going with Os avatar...

Found it….45 days

[mooch49]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Question about pitch speed at 10. Not that it's extremely hard to hit, but the physics look very awkward. I put it down to 5, but then it comes off too slow. I'm thinking that these rosters, with the way the pitches were calculated, that it's meant for pitch speed to be at 10. Is this correct?

Sent from my CPH2583 using Tapatalk

[knich1]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Question about pitch speed at 10. Not that it's extremely hard to hit, but the physics look very awkward. I put it down to 5, but then it comes off too slow. I'm thinking that these rosters, with the way the pitches were calculated, that it's meant for pitch speed to be at 10. Is this correct?

Sent from my CPH2583 using Tapatalk

Hmm...been playing pitch speed 10 for years and Legend difficulty and it looks/feels great. I wish there was a 12 speed...lol.

It could have something to do with your monitor/tv and lag time.

[Fiddy]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Ok, dumb question incoming.

I'm at the point of getting slideritus. Trying to enjoy the game like I did majority of last year, then started reading up on the bullpen issues, simmed vs played etc.

If you don't use 30 team control then there is no way to control a simmed game and those sliders that help keep bullpen usage in check etc. Because after a user game, all cpu games have already been simulated.

So my question is this, if I used this roster but just went ahead and played on default hall of fame sliders would it be ok? Or have the player ratings and adjustments been made with the TrueSim Slider set in mind and work off each other?

[TripleCrown9]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I also have a stupid question.

I downloaded the rosters, went into roster control (in the main menu) and set every team's opening day rotation and lineup (using a combo of baseball reference and Fangraphs), and saved that as a separate roster.

However when I start a franchise with that roster, everything I did gets overwritten by starting on Opening Day and it's all wrong.

Is there a way to avoid this? Or is 30-team control required to have accurate OD lineups?

EDIT: To expand on this, if I start my franchise in Spring Training everything is correct. But even simming to Opening Day from there messes everything up.

[Fiddy]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I also have a stupid question.

I downloaded the rosters, went into roster control (in the main menu) and set every team's opening day rotation and lineup (using a combo of baseball reference and Fangraphs), and saved that as a separate roster.

However when I start a franchise with that roster, everything I did gets overwritten by starting on Opening Day and it's all wrong.

Is there a way to avoid this? Or is 30-team control required to have accurate OD lineups?

You would have to do 30 team control and start from Spring Training, then go through and send everyone down to Triple A/Double A.

Unless I'm doing it wrong myself, because I did the same as you in the past and it always auto generates even with all that stuff set to manual for multiple profiles if you don't do the above.

What I did last year was set up 30 team control using the method in the first post, started from regular season, then went through and adjusted all lineups to opening day ones etc. Then saved that as a base franchise so I could restart whenever I wanted and never had to adjust the opening day lineups again.

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I also have a stupid question.

I downloaded the rosters, went into roster control (in the main menu) and set every team's opening day rotation and lineup (using a combo of baseball reference and Fangraphs), and saved that as a separate roster.

However when I start a franchise with that roster, everything I did gets overwritten by starting on Opening Day and it's all wrong.

Is there a way to avoid this? Or is 30-team control required to have accurate OD lineups?

EDIT: To expand on this, if I start my franchise in Spring Training everything is correct. But even simming to Opening Day from there messes everything up.

The only surefire way to get them to stick is to advance to regular season, use 30 team control and set them then.

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Ok, dumb question incoming.

I'm at the point of getting slideritus. Trying to enjoy the game like I did majority of last year, then started reading up on the bullpen issues, simmed vs played etc.

If you don't use 30 team control then there is no way to control a simmed game and those sliders that help keep bullpen usage in check etc. Because after a user game, all cpu games have already been simulated.

So my question is this, if I used this roster but just went ahead and played on default hall of fame sliders would it be ok? Or have the player ratings and adjustments been made with the TrueSim Slider set in mind and work off each other?

If you don't use 30 team control, you'll load the Gameplay set, play your game. After your game, load simulation set then advance day.

You can play with whatever settings you want though. I think the other games get simulated when you advance day on the calendar.

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Question about pitch speed at 10. Not that it's extremely hard to hit, but the physics look very awkward. I put it down to 5, but then it comes off too slow. I'm thinking that these rosters, with the way the pitches were calculated, that it's meant for pitch speed to be at 10. Is this correct?

Sent from my CPH2583 using Tapatalk

You can put pitch speed to whatever you want

The roster doesn't have anything to do with it, it's just personal preference

[Firestorm]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Ok, dumb question incoming.

I'm at the point of getting slideritus. Trying to enjoy the game like I did majority of last year, then started reading up on the bullpen issues, simmed vs played etc.

If you don't use 30 team control then there is no way to control a simmed game and those sliders that help keep bullpen usage in check etc. Because after a user game, all cpu games have already been simulated.

So my question is this, if I used this roster but just went ahead and played on default hall of fame sliders would it be ok? Or have the player ratings and adjustments been made with the TrueSim Slider set in mind and work off each other?

Umm, can't you load the simulation slider set, go to the calendar and sim all the games of the day but yours, then load up the gameplay sliders and play your game? Doing so should have the stats at the bottom of the ticker update "in real time" as you play. That should be possible with or without 30 team control...

[COMMISSIONERHBK9]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Just curious is anyone going to do updates transactions for these rosters. Ans id I do it myself any tips on how to get it done especially for trades when it just cash involved

[Fiddy]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Just curious is anyone going to do updates transactions for these rosters. Ans id I do it myself any tips on how to get it done especially for trades when it just cash involved

Just use as is and let the franchise breathe my guy. If you want to make a move for a guy on the team you starting with do that and then let it live.




















Then restart two weeks later…. lol. Kidding.

[Fiddy]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Umm, can't you load the simulation slider set, go to the calendar and sim all the games of the day but yours, then load up the gameplay sliders and play your game? Doing so should have the stats at the bottom of the ticker update "in real time" as you play. That should be possible with or without 30 team control...

Hmmmm. Unless I’m missing something I don’t think you can without 30 team control.

If you don't use 30 team control, you'll load the Gameplay set, play your game. After your game, load simulation set then advance day.

You can play with whatever settings you want though. I think the other games get simulated when you advance day on the calendar.

Thanks for the response. I figured whatever settings would be fine, just wanted to make sure though.

As for simming after a played game without 30 team control, if you scroll to the other teams before advancing you can see that their game has already been played. If this was the case in years past I never noticed. So only way for CPU correct bullpen usage etc. would be to do 30 team control and sim all those games first. Then play the user game.