S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

[Redwings19c]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

So I am still having a great time with using V2. CPU is hitting a bit much, however scoring is not that high. Get a lot of 6-4, 2-5, 5-4 games. I would enjoy a game with 5 hits or lower from time to time though.


Two things are not so good for my like. I see a great number of hits in the simulated games (not mine). I always switch to sim sliders (basic with 5-5-10 on pitchers), but there are too many HRs and hits. BTW, The Astros are hitting 32,4%, 4.0% more then the 2nd place. They also have 50 runs more than me (2nd) Any recommendations for the sim sliders? I am 32 games into the season FYI.



The other thing is, I am seeing the lowest BB in the league. Sure, I also get stupid SOs, but when the CPU pitchers pitch to Ohtani, Freeman, Betts, they throw the craziest strikes. Anyone seeing that as well? I manage 1-2 walks per game.

[bryanm1982]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

So I am still having a great time with using V2. CPU is hitting a bit much, however scoring is not that high. Get a lot of 6-4, 2-5, 5-4 games. I would enjoy a game with 5 hits or lower from time to time though.


Two things are not so good for my like. I see a great number of hits in the simulated games (not mine). I always switch to sim sliders (basic with 5-5-10 on pitchers), but there are too many HRs and hits. BTW, The Astros are hitting 32,4%, 4.0% more then the 2nd place. They also have 50 runs more than me (2nd) Any recommendations for the sim sliders? I am 32 games into the season FYI.



The other thing is, I am seeing the lowest BB in the league. Sure, I also get stupid SOs, but when the CPU pitchers pitch to Ohtani, Freeman, Betts, they throw the craziest strikes. Anyone seeing that as well? I manage 1-2 walks per game.

That is weird about the sim stats. We don't look at the sim numbers. We just worry about the pitcher usage and complete games. No sliders should be affecting those numbers. Everybody has said and the consensus is that only the stamina, hook, and injury sliders matter when you sim.

But, a couple of years ago I remember reading Warmwind's slider thread. I believe it was in there and he had a post about the higher the stamina, the higher the ERA's are across the league. And the hook slider affected strikeouts or something. His slider thread from 2020 I believe is huge so that will take some time finding the post if it is in there. I believe it is.

For the walks, you could lower CPU strike frequency if you aren't using quick counts. I would start going down to 4 and see if that is better. I lowered the pitch speeds so I could read the pitches better and I can lay off more close pitches. When I would hit without quick counts, I would always take until I get a strike. Especially the first time around.

[bwiggy33]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

I use these sliders but with some adjustments to CPU hitting to make it harder. It's kind of a hybrid between these and Armors 23 sliders that I think I have found the right mix.

I am in the boat where I am seeing too many strikes (frequency and consistency both set to 5). I've had so many three pitch at-bats with the computer throwing all strikes. I've had multiple games in a row where the pitcher goes into the 7th inning with 55 - 65 pitches. I'm not claiming to be the best hitter nor most patient, but I've never seen what I have been lately.

This has been a mix of pitchers too. Some have good control and others have bad control. It's annoying me because it's ruining my skill at working counts. I'm essentially just swinging at everything because I know there's a very high chance it's going to be a strike. If it's not, it may miss by an inch or two or it's a blown call by the ump. I don't even think I've had a 3 ball count in the past 4 games I've played. The crappy thing too is that I wasn't seeing this a couple weeks ago and I think I've finally got everything locked in where the computer is difficult to pitch to. So, it could be the perfect game but now I need to figure out this too many strikes issue.

I've lowered strike frequency to 4 so we will see if that helps. I adjusted it in the 3rd inning of a game yesterday and it didn't make a difference but I'm not going to use 7 innings as a basis of whether I need to go lower than that.

[bryanm1982]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

I use these sliders but with some adjustments to CPU hitting to make it harder. It's kind of a hybrid between these and Armors 23 sliders that I think I have found the right mix.

I am in the boat where I am seeing too many strikes (frequency and consistency both set to 5). I've had so many three pitch at-bats with the computer throwing all strikes. I've had multiple games in a row where the pitcher goes into the 7th inning with 55 - 65 pitches. I'm not claiming to be the best hitter nor most patient, but I've never seen what I have been lately.

This has been a mix of pitchers too. Some have good control and others have bad control. It's annoying me because it's ruining my skill at working counts. I'm essentially just swinging at everything because I know there's a very high chance it's going to be a strike. If it's not, it may miss by an inch or two or it's a blown call by the ump. I don't even think I've had a 3 ball count in the past 4 games I've played. The crappy thing too is that I wasn't seeing this a couple weeks ago and I think I've finally got everything locked in where the computer is difficult to pitch to. So, it could be the perfect game but now I need to figure out this too many strikes issue.

I've lowered strike frequency to 4 so we will see if that helps. I adjusted it in the 3rd inning of a game yesterday and it didn't make a difference but I'm not going to use 7 innings as a basis of whether I need to go lower than that.

A quick way to see how sensitive that strike frequency is to put it a test game to 0 and see how much difference you see. Then work your way up. Another option would be to start lowering control but you don't want that to mess up other unintended issues.

You could try to raise contact at 6 to see if maybe the CPU pitcher will start to pitch around you more and get you to chase.

Are you on HOF hitting?

[bwiggy33]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

A quick way to see how sensitive that strike frequency is to put it a test game to 0 and see how much difference you see. Then work your way up. Another option would be to start lowering control but you don't want that to mess up other unintended issues.

You could try to raise contact at 6 to see if maybe the CPU pitcher will start to pitch around you more and get you to chase.

Are you on HOF hitting?

Thanks for the tips on that. Yes I'm on HOF hitting and my User hitting sliders are the same as the OP. FWIW all of my sliders are the same as the OP other than my CPU hitting sliders.

[bryanm1982]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

Just wanted to give an update. Steve and I have been kind of been testing different stuff. But we are going to stick with Version 3.0 with the power at 5.


It is very hard to determine the user hitting since we all have different skill levels and TV's and reaction times. For those that are not seeing enough walks, you could lower CPU Strike Frequency or if you feel like you can read the pitch better by lowering pitch speeds you can. Sometimes, lowering the pitch speed is just as hard as raising it.

I play with QC on and one game I got 7 walks and the next game I got 1.

[PhlliesPhan6]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

How is everyone seeing league wide injuries with sim injuries at 5? I'm almost a month into my season and I've only seen 1 or 2 guys get put on the DL. (Besides players that I did manually)

[bryanm1982]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

How is everyone seeing league wide injuries with sim injuries at 5? I'm almost a month into my season and I've only seen 1 or 2 guys get put on the DL. (Besides players that I did manually)

I know JWDixon tested multiple sim seasons and he found that 7 (I believe) worked well. I am in the middle of April in my franchise and I get notified on MLB only injuries. I get an injury notification about once every other day from a team. But it is usually a day to day injury. I probably have seen about 3-4 2 week injuries and 1 3 month injury.

[The Kid 24]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

Just wanted to give an update. Steve and I have been kind of been testing different stuff. But we are going to stick with Version 3.0 with the power at 5.


It is very hard to determine the user hitting since we all have different skill levels and TV's and reaction times. For those that are not seeing enough walks, you could lower CPU Strike Frequency or if you feel like you can read the pitch better by lowering pitch speeds you can. Sometimes, lowering the pitch speed is just as hard as raising it.

I play with QC on and one game I got 7 walks and the next game I got 1.

If using Version 2, should CPU Foul Freq be 0?

And Version 2 is AS or HOF hitting/HOF pitching correct?

[bryanm1982]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

If using Version 2, should CPU Foul Freq be 0?

And Version 2 is AS or HOF hitting/HOF pitching correct?

We haven't done foul frequency at 0 on Version 2. But I'm sure it would work fine if you did. So it is your preference. You will see more balls land fair than foul.

And Version 2 is HOF hitting/pitching. But there are red numbers for User hitting for Allstar if you want.

[PhlliesPhan6]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

I know JWDixon tested multiple sim seasons and he found that 7 (I believe) worked well. I am in the middle of April in my franchise and I get notified on MLB only injuries. I get an injury notification about once every other day from a team. But it is usually a day to day injury. I probably have seen about 3-4 2 week injuries and 1 3 month injury.

Yeah, I'm seeing a lot of day to day injuries as well but nothing that results in being put on the IL. I will give 7 and try and see how it works.

[DarthRambo]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

Yeah, I'm seeing a lot of day to day injuries as well but nothing that results in being put on the IL. I will give 7 and try and see how it works.

I simulate MLB games separately so I see all MLB injuries and help cpu call up players that makes most sense. A lot of day to day or 1-2 weeks injuries. I am in early May and I will count later, but my guess is less than 10 guys on IL. This is sim injuries at 5. I always felt 6 was really goodso I'll probably put it there. I know every year a couple teams max out on players possible on IL the game allows.

Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk

[Redwings19c]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

That is weird about the sim stats. We don't look at the sim numbers. We just worry about the pitcher usage and complete games. No sliders should be affecting those numbers. Everybody has said and the consensus is that only the stamina, hook, and injury sliders matter when you sim.

But, a couple of years ago I remember reading Warmwind's slider thread. I believe it was in there and he had a post about the higher the stamina, the higher the ERA's are across the league. And the hook slider affected strikeouts or something. His slider thread from 2020 I believe is huge so that will take some time finding the post if it is in there. I believe it is.

For the walks, you could lower CPU strike frequency if you aren't using quick counts. I would start going down to 4 and see if that is better. I lowered the pitch speeds so I could read the pitches better and I can lay off more close pitches. When I would hit without quick counts, I would always take until I get a strike. Especially the first time around.

Oh, I see. I didn´t know that sliders had no impact on sim numbers. Good to know. Well, either some teams are just on a long hot streak or the 10 manager hook may have an effect. Do you still have it on 10? I actually am very satisfied, there were just 3 complete games, lots of pitchers leave in the 4th (lower rankings) or 5th (bad game).


Ok, thanks, I will go down with strike frequency, I will see, what it does. I don´t want to touch speed - it just doesn´t feel right, when it is too slow.

[bryanm1982]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

Oh, I see. I didn´t know that sliders had no impact on sim numbers. Good to know. Well, either some teams are just on a long hot streak or the 10 manager hook may have an effect. Do you still have it on 10? I actually am very satisfied, there were just 3 complete games, lots of pitchers leave in the 4th (lower rankings) or 5th (bad game).


Ok, thanks, I will go down with strike frequency, I will see, what it does. I don´t want to touch speed - it just doesn´t feel right, when it is too slow.

If you are seeing starters not getting the wine or going 5-7 IP when it looks like they should then let us know. Then10 would be too much and they are getting pulled too early.

[HeadCoach2.0]

Re: S & B’s MLB 2024 Simulation Sliders

I was running multiple franchises with different teams and I accidentally deleted my Mets by mistake.

I didn't make a back up save !!! That was so stupid of me !!!

I have to start all over again.

I am totally bummed out.

I LEARNED MY LESSON FROM THIS.
I will always have multiple copies