2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

[AndyTheGiant]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Appreciate the work, Calm. I think a lot of us are in this boat. As much as PS4 has gained a competitive advantage, Xbox still just feels "right" to me for sports gaming. It's hard to put it all into words, but there are small things even with the Xbox interface that make it feel better.

I'm in an online league for FIFA on my PS4 (have it for both consoles) but outside of that, I mainly stick to PS4 solely for single player. My second controller for PS4 is still in the box and my last real game played was The Last of Us. I did put quite some time into Battlefield 4 on PS4 over the summer (900p vs 720p made a difference here) but will probably go back to Xbox for COD if it shapes up to be a good game...

I also think the joysticks are so much tighter (in a good way) on Xbox. Makes a huge difference...

[aylmer1981]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

So far for me the Xbox one face scan has been horrifying. If we can figure out if the ps4 camera for 2k works better for facescan I think that will also be a deciding factor.

[Nomah5]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Sounds like you don't have the RGB Color Range set to "full" in your PS4 Display settings. Will result in things looking a bit too bright or "washed out". Try making the switch.

Jwill. I changed it from auto to full and yes I now see the graphics being on par. Less bright. Also yes there is a slight rumble in the ds4 but feel the one is certainly stronger.

Btw if any of you play forza madden or nhl on the one please add me. Sudbury1978

[Nomah5]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Andy... I have busted multiple left joy sticks already on the one playing nhl so I'm a bit afraid to use it. Haha.

[AndyTheGiant]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Andy... I have busted multiple left joy sticks already on the one playing nhl so I'm a bit afraid to use it. Haha.

haha, you can buy them in 10 packs I think though on Amazon. I had to put grips on my PS4 joysticks to keep them from wearing down...

[Rebel_INS]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Can you give details, is it player models? Shadows? Lighting. I am loading both the ps4 and xbox one versions right now and am trying to figure out how to post video.

Really...all of the above. From the time the game finished installing and put me into the main menu, I knew something was wrong. Even that screen was dark. I could barely see Shaq's face on the 2KTV preview. Shrugged it off and went into the Lakers vs Nuggest NBA Today game and immediately noticed it looked darker. The player models weren't as sharp. I even noticed pixelation in the smoke during player intros. After turning off my Box and booting up my PS4, I got into a party with one of my friends who got it for his son on the XB1. I asked him if he looked at it. He said "yeah...it looks like sh*t". I needed that confirmation because I thought it might just be my tv. Mind u, I have a 1080p lcd flat. I don't know man. I'm just disappointed. I was looking 4ward to playing MyCareer on XB1 due to easier vid capturing and editing but I'm sticking with PS4.

[aylmer1981]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Really...all of the above. From the time the game finished installing and put me into the main menu, I knew something was wrong. Even that screen was dark. I could barely see Shaq's face on the 2KTV preview. Shrugged it off and went into the Lakers vs Nuggest NBA Today game and immediately noticed it looked darker. The player models weren't as sharp. I even noticed pixelation in the smoke during player intros. After turning off my Box and booting up my PS4, I got into a party with one of my friends who got it for his son on the XB1. I asked him if he looked at it. He said "yeah...it looks like sh*t". I needed that confirmation because I thought it might just be my tv. Mind u, I have a 1080p lcd flat. I don't know man. I'm just disappointed. I was looking 4ward to playing MyCareer on XB1 due to easier vid capturing and editing but I'm sticking with PS4.

I have it on Xbox one and considering changing for ps4 but the graphics are not that bad. Pregame is just crap graphics overall. Its good graphics actually in game just how is it compared it to ps4.

[CalmLikeABomb]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Okay xbox one installed, I did a "xbox record that" to post here and uploaded to youtube. Can I do that with PS4. I can say from this first preload screen that the ps4 version appears to look better. It could be placebo. I will switch back and forth once PS4 is installed.

Here is link to video.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OoyNQsNxeKk

[Nomah5]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

I have it on Xbox one and considering changing for ps4 but the graphics are not that bad. Pregame is just crap graphics overall. Its good graphics actually in game just how is it compared it to ps4.

What is your reasoning to consider the switch?

[kluvindy]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Well I have both x1 and ps4. I purchased 2k14 on the ps4 last year, so I thought I would buy 15 on the x1 this year. I rented the ps4 version just to be sure and I really don't see much of a difference at all. I will say the ps4 version seems a bit more colorful and a bit brighter but that's where the differences end for me. I will mention I'm playing my games on a 65 inch curved 4k Samsung tv so I know it's not the television.

[aylmer1981]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

What is your reasoning to consider the switch?

Facescan problem turns horrible Tried the tricks . Terrible outcomestill.

[CalmLikeABomb]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Okay I did a video comparison through my phone. Probably not great quality but gives you a general idea. I am really torn right now, playing xbox it "feels" better. I don't know if it is the controller or the way the game plays. It feels like it is almost too fast on ps4. I would say it looks "richer" so to speak for ps4. Looks more vibrant, and slightly washed out IMO for xbox one. PS4 does have the vibration for the dribble. I would say if you are going for visuals only, I would go PS4. I am pretty sure I am keeping the XBOX one for the controller, rumble in triggers, xbox record that, and the way the game feels during gameplay.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ccvKmnSr07I&list=UUg_J6V1_sblEG8AaqvtXt9Q

[Dunk77]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Well I have both x1 and ps4. I purchased 2k14 on the ps4 last year, so I thought I would buy 15 on the x1 this year. I rented the ps4 version just to be sure and I really don't see much of a difference at all. I will say the ps4 version seems a bit more colorful and a bit brighter but that's where the differences end for me. I will mention I'm playing my games on a 65 inch curved 4k Samsung tv so I know it's not the television.

4k won't make a difference.

[sbauer318]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Okay I did a video comparison through my phone. Probably not great quality but gives you a general idea. I am really torn right now, playing xbox it "feels" better. I don't know if it is the controller or the way the game plays. It feels like it is almost too fast on ps4. I would say it looks "richer" so to speak for ps4. Looks more vibrant, and slightly washed out IMO for xbox one. PS4 does have the vibration for the dribble. I would say if you are going for visuals only, I would go PS4. I am pretty sure I am keeping the XBOX one for the controller, rumble in triggers, xbox record that, and the way the game feels during gameplay.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ccvKm...blEG8AaqvtXt9Q

You can record videos on the ps4 too. Do you just prefer the voice command?

[CalmLikeABomb]

Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

You can record videos on the ps4 too. Do you just prefer the voice command?

It's funny you say that, I was just doing the share button on the game. It is a shame you cannot upload to youtube and only facebook. It works well though. Something I just found out playing ps4 is it has in game voice commands just like kinect. I was going through settings and saw that.

The PS4 I would say definitely has the better graphics. I really think I just prefer X1 controller. Again, it seems like the gameplay on PS4 is slightly fast. I don't know if there is an option to change game speed? I am almost thinking of keeping the X1 version and getting ps4 as well. I have friends to play on both. I am curious to other opinions?