The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[jrose57]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Ok I made two trades here, I'm playing as the Raptors, these are mid season trades after a 15-26 start.

Raptors Receive
Sasha Vujacic
2012 1st Round Pick

Lakers Receive
Jarrett Jack
2011 1st Round Pick

2nd Trade *

Raptors Receive
Rudy Fernandez**
Joel Przybilla

Trail Blazers Receive
Leandro Barbosa
Ronald Dupree

*This trade was actually initiated by the cpu during the season.
**Fernandez was a player I wanted to pick up, actually edited him so his overall is a 72 now, couldn't resist

I want Fernandez in Toronto as well, backcourt with him and Calderon, you should get Marc Gasol as well, having Calderon, Fernandez, Derozan, Bargarni, and Gasol will be greatttttt!!!

[Vladrek]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

You gave LA your pick? why? lol

i guess i forgot to metion it and kinda feel dumb for not bringing it up but the 1st round pick i gave LA in my trade wasnt actually the Raptors, i tried giving the team their actual picks for this year so the pick I did trade away belonged to the Heat via the chris bosh trade. thats why it didnt bug me too terribly, though still vujacic seems to only turn it on in the 4th quarter.

[Vladrek]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I want Fernandez in Toronto as well, backcourt with him and Calderon, you should get Marc Gasol as well, having Calderon, Fernandez, Derozan, Bargarni, and Gasol will be greatttttt!!!

LMAO I actually played last year's game with that starting 5, I do want gasol but im gonna wait to trade for him in the off season, i dont think i could really offer anything fair for him right now, id hate to just be cheap on the trade. With that lineup I almost have team spain... well actually i kinda do cause im using a 2011 projected draft class and pablo aguilar will be one of my picks lol.

[AgaliareptX]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Trade:

Nuggets (me) trade:
Kenyon Martin
Ty Lawson
2011 1st Round Pick
2012 2nd Round Pick

Mavs (CPU) trade:
Dirk Nowitzki
J.J. Barea

I think if you take out the real-life loyalty factor that Mark Cuban/Mavs have with Dirk, this trade makes some sense. K-Mart has a giant expiring contract and still plays great defense and decent offense and Ty Lawson looks like a legit star in the making to replace Kidd when he's done.

From the Nuggets side, they finally get a perennial all-star to pair up with Melo, and they can sort-of form a "Big 3" with Melo/Chauncey/Dirk. And J.J.'s not to shabby.

Threw in a few picks to make it a little more fair as well.

[bailey4mvp]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Ok i decided to run with the Bulls for my Asscoiation, i was thinking about this trade down the track.


Bulls Send: Luol Deng, Taj Gibson/James Johnson, 2011, 2012 1st
Pacers Send: Danny Granger, A.J. Price/Filler, 2012 2nd

Reason behind it is that the Pacers have George at the 3 aswell and if Granger moves to SG then what becomes of Stephenson?

It gives me a scoring SF but i give up Gibson, i was thinking of making it Johnson cause im not to keen on him but i guess its not fair if i don't inclue Gibson.

[w1rri0r]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Trade:

Nuggets (me) trade:
Kenyon Martin
Ty Lawson
2011 1st Round Pick
2012 2nd Round Pick

Mavs (CPU) trade:
Dirk Nowitzki
J.J. Barea

I think if you take out the real-life loyalty factor that Mark Cuban/Mavs have with Dirk, this trade makes some sense. K-Mart has a giant expiring contract and still plays great defense and decent offense and Ty Lawson looks like a legit star in the making to replace Kidd when he's done.

From the Nuggets side, they finally get a perennial all-star to pair up with Melo, and they can sort-of form a "Big 3" with Melo/Chauncey/Dirk. And J.J.'s not to shabby.

Threw in a few picks to make it a little more fair as well.

No way is Mavs ever going into the rebuilding mode with Mark Cuban as the boss and they got Roddy Beaubois waiting in the wings as well, so this trade doesn't make much sense to me. I think K-Mart also had a fight with Mark Cuban a few years ago so...

[JBH3]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Trade:

Nuggets (me) trade:
Kenyon Martin
Ty Lawson
2011 1st Round Pick
2012 2nd Round Pick

Mavs (CPU) trade:
Dirk Nowitzki
J.J. Barea

I think if you take out the real-life loyalty factor that Mark Cuban/Mavs have with Dirk, this trade makes some sense. K-Mart has a giant expiring contract and still plays great defense and decent offense and Ty Lawson looks like a legit star in the making to replace Kidd when he's done.

From the Nuggets side, they finally get a perennial all-star to pair up with Melo, and they can sort-of form a "Big 3" with Melo/Chauncey/Dirk. And J.J.'s not to shabby.

Threw in a few picks to make it a little more fair as well.

Yea.....No.

First, Dallas has Roddy Beaubois who is such a better scoring option that Lawson, and can run the point. 2nd, the Mavs have Caron's deal expiring, and Jason Terry's a year after that, not to mention Kidd. So they have Dirk signed for the next 4 years, and have the ability to put younger pieces around him...OR...bring in another superstar.

Me thinks you just wanted Dirk on your team w/ the Nuggets, and are trying to justify it any way you can.

[Buckeye]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Looking to move some players from my Cavs team such as Mo Williams and Jamison ideas?

[JBH3]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Looking to move some players from my Cavs team such as Mo Williams and Jamison ideas?

Wait till you get to the deadline, look to see what teams have needs and are in playoff contention, and see who would be crazy enough to take on $33 million for the next two years....OR....realize that your fate is sealed till those two guys leave for free agency or until the following season when they have expiring deals.... and tough it out like the real Cavs.

[kenmasters06]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

The trade I just made (I'm the Knicks):

Warriors Trade:
Stephen Curry
Andris Biedrins

Knicks Trade:
Raymond Felton
Gallo
Anthony Randolph

[Freak123]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

The trade I just made (I'm the Knicks):

Warriors Trade:
Stephen Curry
Andris Biedrins

Knicks Trade:
Raymond Felton
Gallo
Anthony Randolph

If you're looking for realism that ain't it as Stephen Curry is untouchable except for a superstar like Carmelo, CP3, etc., but if you're not going for that great trade bud.

[JBH3]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

The trade I just made (I'm the Knicks):

Warriors Trade:
Stephen Curry
Andris Biedrins

Knicks Trade:
Raymond Felton
Gallo
Anthony Randolph

The Official "Get over on the CPU" Thread

-or-

The Official "Make a trade for the sake of making a trade when it makes no sense" Thread

?

Seriously? Curry....?

Rating = *

[vikingrk]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Thoughts on this trade? Came up on trade finder.

Suns (me) get:
Richard Jefferson
Tagio Splitter

Spurs get:
Hedo Turkoglu
Grant Hill

I'd get an actual PF with upside, and Jefferson is about as good as Hedo.

The Spurs (I assume) are looking for guys to help them win now.

[Freak123]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Thoughts on this trade? Came up on trade finder.

Suns (me) get:
Richard Jefferson
Tagio Splitter

Spurs get:
Hedo Turkoglu
Grant Hill

I'd get an actual PF with upside, and Jefferson is about as good as Hedo.

The Spurs (I assume) are looking for guys to help them win now.

That they are, but Tiago Splitter is untouchable, unless of course a ridiculous offer like Carmelo for him or something along those lines are offered. Tiago Splitter is supposed to fill Duncan's role when Duncan is finished, and for right now he takes a lot of the minute load away from Duncan so Duncan can rest and not play that much until the playoffs. Splitter could have a pretty good rookie season as I expect him to get 20+ minutes game in and game out.

[vikingrk]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

That they are, but Tiago Splitter is untouchable, unless of course a ridiculous offer like Carmelo for him or something along those lines are offered. Tiago Splitter is supposed to fill Duncan's role when Duncan is finished, and for right now he takes a lot of the minute load away from Duncan so Duncan can rest and not play that much until the playoffs. Splitter could have a pretty good rookie season as I expect him to get 20+ minutes game in and game out.

In real life, sure. But the in-game Spurs likely won't play him at all. They offered him to me, so I don't see why should pretend they won't give him up.

Aside from it being somewhat unrealistic (I knew that when I saw the trade), how do you think it works from the Suns point of view?