Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

[scoobyskyline3]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

In 2k Lebron IRL Kobe... But if i had a choice id take Kevin Durant in both! hes a 2k glitch

[Boling4Humor]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

Seriously, a lot of you guys have taken this thread to a whole different level. You've gone beyond a simple question of who you would take on your team and you've turned it into a debate on whose more greater IRL. Mods should consider closing this thread.

If you guys want to debate about real life basketball then please go to this link and create a thread about it (if there already isn't one):

http://www.operationsports.com/forums/pro-basketball/

[Shield]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

I'd say Lebron IRL, and Kobe in 2K11

[dramachild11]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

in 2k lebron no question reasons: even 97 ratings but bron is younger, stronger, faster, better dribbler/passer/rebounder, and the biggest positive of all is he can play the 1-4 on offense or defense (kobe could play the 1-3 but put him on a PF and watch him get abused)

[BATMON]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

"younger/youth" is not a Rating in the game.

If both players are 85 overall w/ the same ratings across the board but one is 7 years older, that doesnt make a difference.

[dramachild11]

i referenced brons age cause in the game kobe will retire before bron does and if ur tryna build a team u want ur star player to be around for a long time right...following ur logic about how age doesnt matter that would mean youd have a team full of aging stars and after two seasons i can guarantee youd probably be asking yourself why you didnt go younger, i know i would lol

[jeebs9]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

Younger means last long in a franchise mode

[13]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

At least some people are actually answering the question..

[dramachild11]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

one quick point about an argument i saw on another page in this thread... kobe without another all-star with him couldnt even win 45 games, but bron in his FIRST FOUR SEASONS (before he was 22 years old!!) was able to take a team of role players to the finals (a la allen iverson with the sixers) so dont ever say he wasnt or isnt good enough to be "the man"

[FragMaster]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

one quick point about an argument i saw on another page in this thread... kobe without another all-star with him couldnt even win 45 games, but bron in his FIRST FOUR SEASONS (before he was 22 years old!!) was able to take a team of role players to the finals (a la allen iverson with the sixers) so dont ever say he wasnt or isnt good enough to be "the man"

Lebron managed to get in the finals because of the weakass EC teams like the raptors, knicks, sixers, magic, atlanta and/or bobcats. whereas Kobe had to play the spurs, mavs, suns, sonics, nuggets and grizzlies. Come on man, there's a HUGE difference in ability. put Lebron in the WC he wouldn't make it past the first round.

on topic: Lebron gets 6+more seasons than Kobe in 2k11, that's why i would pick him.

[Freak123]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

Agree with the above posters, I digressed once just to answer people who quoted my post but let's try to keep on topic now. Read the thread title and respond.

[parker987]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

Lebron for sure, more explosive and all around player

[DakkoN]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

so if lebron was able to take that horrible team to the finals, why wasn't he able to take BETTER cavs teams to the finals in the years following?

Nice logic there. I guess the Celtics getting Allen, Garnett, Rondo turning into a top 5 PG, and them having a whole team full of smart veterans.. and the Magic going from a below .500 team to a finals team had NOTHING to do with it?

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

Nice logic there. I guess the Celtics getting Allen, Garnett, Rondo turning into a top 5 PG, and them having a whole team full of smart veterans.. and the Magic going from a below .500 team to a finals team had NOTHING to do with it?

I think that's his point. That we shouldn't give LeBron that much credit for taking his team to the Finals the year he got swept by the Spurs because there was pretty much nobody in the East.

[jeebs9]

Re: Who would you take LeBron or Kobe?

But to say there was no one in the East is kind of....( I don't want to say stupid.... Someone fill it in with another word lol). But you know what I mean. They beat the Pistons who had won the East 2 years in a row before (beat the LA in the Finals and lost to Spurs the year before in game 7). To call it a "cake walk" (as I've heard over the years). Would take away from every team that has won the finals or conference over the years. People can make the argument for the Lakers the last 3 years. "That because they play in the West. They don't play any strong team until they get to the finals."

I've heard this over and over again. Regardless of what is said. LeBron James went to the Finals.