Shaq vs Tim Duncan

[23]

Re: Shaq vs Tim Duncan

With that cheap logic, I guess you can call Kobe, MJ since he imitates his tongue wag and finger wag.

Please give me some real reasoning. That does nothing for the discussion.

How many times was Brad Daughtery a champ, MVP, all NBA or anything of that sort? In what ways does his career piece together with the all time greats? How many seasons did he dominate his peers in top 3 birdies of efficiancy?

[teebone]

Re: Shaq vs Tim Duncan

With that cheap logic, I guess you can call Kobe, MJ since he imitates his tongue wag and finger wag.

Get that weak junk out of here. What does that have to do with anything. And you actually said, "cheap logic"...then proceeded to define it with your comment. LOL.

Please give me some real reasoning. That does nothing for the discussion.

How many times was Brad Daughtery a champ, MVP, all NBA or anything of that sort? In what ways does his career piece together with the all time greats? How many seasons did he dominate his peers in top 3 birdies of efficiancy?

Again, with YOUR cheap logic. A pound is a pound. Just because a pound is situated next to .5 lbs, doesnt make it more than a pound. And likewise, just because a pound, is situated next to 1.5 lbs, it doesnt make it less than a pound. This is your logic.

[X*Cell]

Re: Shaq vs Tim Duncan

You simply watch them and see what they do in given situations, see how they play. Again, being compared to Brad Dougherty is a compliment. Theyre similar in how they maneuver around...theyre both practitioners. Also, you have some players from different eras whose productive parts of their careers overlap.

I think comparing Daugherty to Duncan is a compliment for Daugherty... not so much for Duncan. I still don't see how Duncan wouldn't have been a force during the 80's. The guy has a silky smooth jumper off the glass, and he can handle his own in the post, offensively and defensively. It's not like he's undersized either. I am sure that 80's, 90's, 30's, whatever! If you have to matchup with a 7 footer who weighs 260 pounds and has the skillset Duncan has... YOU FEAR.

[23]

Re: Shaq vs Tim Duncan

Get that weak junk out of here. What does that have to do with anything. And you actually said, "cheap logic"...then proceeded to define it with your comment. LOL.

Touche'

Again, with YOUR cheap logic. A pound is a pound. Just because a pound is situated next to .5 lbs, doesnt make it more than a pound. And likewise, just because a pound, is situated next to 1.5 lbs, it doesnt make it less than a pound. This is your logic.

Again, Touche'

[slimm44]

Re: Shaq vs Tim Duncan

this thread has gotten ridiculous. can't we just get a lock? it makes my head hurt...

it started as a comparison between shaq and duncan's careers and has devolved into teebone analyzing what would happend if something that could never POSSIBLY HAPPEN, did happen.

it's gotten to the point of just saying things to say things. what if mike tyson boxed against john l sullivan? what if he boxed king kong? what if he boxed the queen of england?

let's pretend a hummingbird could play basketball - would the hummingbird be a better rebounder than detlef schrempf???

WHERE IS THIS GOING????

I think Detlef would win the rebounding battle, but I'm not so sure about free throws. Seriously though, a charge can only be called if the offensive player is out of control. Shaq is so big he can be completely under control and will still back anybody down in the paint. That being said, both Shaq and Timmy are great players and whoever started this thread wanted a flamefest to occur.