Larry Bird best SF of all time?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • arichzona
    Banned
    • Nov 2003
    • 1629

    #61
    Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

    Originally posted by tenoob
    Lets just agree to disagree.

    Jordan could of easily averaged 8-10+ assists (maybe even more?)
    and scoring 20+ or 30+ points per game at the PG position.
    Not to mention having the advantage of play calling, and
    should the play break down the ball is already in Jordan's
    hands so whats the worse that could of happened?

    I'm not a Jordan *****, my mouth just so happens to be
    far away from the guys ball-sack. Can't a guy be entitled
    to his own oppinion without being called a *****?

    Some people say Larry is overrated, some say Kobe is;
    I'm one of the few that isn't saying Jordan is overrated
    but "overglorified". Know what I'm saying? The guy was amazing;
    but he wasn't in any way the GOAT.

    Jordan to me is a GWOAT, Greatest winner of all time.

    BTW Jordan was NOT asked to play PG for the first
    time in Washington, when Doug Collins was coach
    he put MJ at the PG to get under Magic Johnson's
    skin and it worked. Actually alot better than anyone
    ever anticipated.



    The only reason other players call Jordan the GOAT
    is because Jordan put that in their minds everytime
    he played against them, Jordan's game was all
    psychological thats something people don't get.

    As for the guys who never played with him, when
    you hear Larry and Magic call him GOAT too you
    nod along and take their word for it.

    Jordan accomplished alot in his career, but to a
    guy like me who watched Mike play from start to
    finish you question alot of his judgement.

    What if no Phil Jackson and Tex Winter come along,
    that means no triangle offense. Would he of won 6
    rings being the same old Jordan without the triangle?

    I dunno man, but what I do know is had he never
    stepped down from PG rest assured this question
    wouldn't exist nor the doubt in my mind.
    Nice vid.....shows a good example of my prior post of where a guy plays out of position as part of a coaching decision from time to time to benefit the team. 6'6 vs 6'9" is not better than 6'1" vs 6'9"? His time with the Wiz, was the first time PG was mentioned as a permanent position for him.

    Everyone on here has to agree to disagree since personal opinions are just that. I too watched his entire career. (pro anyways) as I lived in Chicago from 89 on, Michigan before that. I tend not to question too much of his judgement...here and there, sure.....but a lot? nope. Hard to question the judgement of someone who won six titles and is viewed by his peers as the best.

    Seriously doubt thoug that the ONLY reason the opposition calls him the GOAT is mind games. However though, if you have your opponent beat prior to playing you have a huge advantage. It is all about confidence leading to ability which goes back to confidence.

    Who in your opinion is the GOAT then? I know it is going to be argued til the end of time as it is not really an official title.....just curious? But if you are indeed the GWOAT, as you put it........isn't the end all, be all - to win? To me - peer voting, peer opinion is what has the biggest impact. The guys who played with, against, or came before or after him. Honestly, to me there is a great handful of guys - I simply put MJ a bit above them as I watched him play day-in/day out.

    There are a LOT of "what if's" in the history of the league that could, or would have changed the outcome of a lot of stuff we saw, read about, and still watch. It is what it is, it happened, and it is history. What if Kareem wasnt traded? What if 'Nique knew how to pass? What if Bird's back never went bad? What if Magic and Bird went to the other's team in the draft? etc....it is endless.........Far too much to wonder stuff regarding coaches.

    As for the ball-sack comment? Not really justified and to me, but it says a lot as to why the arguements are there as it is typically where these things go when one person runs out of ammo (that, or f/u). Standing by your opinion does not suggest that is a persons stance. To each his own.

    as for your gambling claim.........find me the proof and I will listen.
    Last edited by arichzona; 01-05-2008, 03:05 PM.

    Comment

    • tenoob
      Banned
      • Dec 2007
      • 51

      #62
      Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

      Originally posted by arichzona
      Nice vid.....shows a good example of my prior post of where a guy plays out of position as part of a coaching decision from time to time to benefit the team. 6'6 vs 6'9" is not better than 6'1" vs 6'9"? His time with the Wiz, was the first time PG was mentioned as a permanent position for him.

      Everyone on here has to agree to disagree since personal opinions are just that. I too watched his entire career. (pro anyways) as I lived in Chicago from 89 on, Michigan before that. I tend not to question too much of his judgement...here and there, sure.....but a lot? nope. Hard to question the judgement of someone who won six titles and is viewed by his peers as the best.

      Seriously doubt thoug that the ONLY reason the opposition calls him the GOAT is mind games. However though, if you have your opponent beat prior to playing you have a huge advantage. It is all about confidence leading to ability which goes back to confidence.

      Who in your opinion is the GOAT then? I know it is going to be argued til the end of time as it is not really an official title.....just curious? But if you are indeed the GWOAT, as you put it........isn't the end all, be all - to win? To me - peer voting, peer opinion is what has the biggest impact. The guys who played with, against, or came before or after him. Honestly, to me there is a great handful of guys - I simply put MJ a bit above them as I watched him play day-in/day out.

      There are a LOT of "what if's" in the history of the league that could, or would have changed the outcome of a lot of stuff we saw, read about, and still watch. It is what it is, it happened, and it is history. What if Kareem wasnt traded? What if 'Nique knew how to pass? What if Bird's back never went bad? What if Magic and Bird went to the other's team in the draft? etc....it is endless.........Far too much to wonder stuff regarding coaches.

      As for the ball-sack comment? Not really justified and to me, but it says a lot as to why the arguements are there as it is typically where these things go when one person runs out of ammo (that, or f/u). Standing by your opinion does not suggest that is a persons stance. To each his own.

      as for your gambling claim.........find me the proof and I will listen.
      The ballsack comment wasn't to you I should of been more specific,
      it has to do with Jordan fanboys and their relentless effort to discredit
      all players as great except Michael you know?

      The gambling thing is kinda hard to find now (oddly..) but I read it
      a LONG LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG time ago, (4-3 years maybe)
      and it went to detail about the real reason Mike retired to go to
      baseball. Stern refused to comment on exactly what he gambled
      on I believe so the article for all I know could be fake but logic
      would explain he would of done something in those terms to
      all the sudden leave basketball for baseball you know?

      It wouldnt be surprising if true, Wilt Chamberlain did the same thing.

      Comment

      • tenoob
        Banned
        • Dec 2007
        • 51

        #63
        Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

        Who do I think is GOAT?

        Well, to be completely honest as of right now it has to be
        Sasha Vujacic (j/k even though SV is secretly overpowered in 2k8).

        I don't think of anyone as GOAT, because what is a goat anyways?

        The greatest of all time.

        To put all the hall of famers in the same timeframe and have them
        ball it out for the title is impossible, so the term GOAT to me don't
        exist.

        Comment

        • GP Mercy
          Pro
          • Jun 2006
          • 839

          #64
          Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

          Originally posted by tenoob
          To put all the hall of famers in the same timeframe and have them
          ball it out for the title is impossible, so the term GOAT to me don't
          exist.
          I would pay money to see this..put all the teams in a 64 team playoff system, but let them play 7 game series. It would take a while, but it would be worth it.

          Comment

          • arichzona
            Banned
            • Nov 2003
            • 1629

            #65
            Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

            Originally posted by tenoob
            Who do I think is GOAT?

            Well, to be completely honest as of right now it has to be
            Sasha Vujacic (j/k even though SV is secretly overpowered in 2k8).

            I don't think of anyone as GOAT, because what is a goat anyways?

            The greatest of all time.

            To put all the hall of famers in the same timeframe and have them
            ball it out for the title is impossible, so the term GOAT to me don't
            exist.
            right...........it is an opinion. We all have those - no harm in sharing. I know that for my time of reference, who I have seen.....it is MJ. Could be Oscar.... I never saw the guy play except for highlights.

            Comment

            • Gibbz
              All Star
              • Aug 2005
              • 8240

              #66
              Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

              At this point, Bird in a landslide. By the time LBJ's career is done he could make a strong case, though.

              Comment

              • tenoob
                Banned
                • Dec 2007
                • 51

                #67
                Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

                Originally posted by GP Mercy
                I would pay money to see this..put all the teams in a 64 team playoff system, but let them play 7 game series. It would take a while, but it would be worth it.
                Yeah, if only there was somehow to accurately simulate all this.

                Probably the best basketball video game ever created will be based
                off pitting hall of fame teams against each other. Not to mention
                teams with hall of famers on them including their roleplayers.

                That would be a sight to see, and a game to play 24 hours straight.

                Comment

                • KG
                  Welcome Back
                  • Sep 2005
                  • 17583

                  #68
                  Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

                  Originally posted by lbartlett_32
                  Larry played when the NBA was at its best. Defense was relied upon to win games. There was constant hand checking, no free lanes, and no uncontested shot. There was the team concept as well as team D. There are no equivalents in this league to Barkley, Magic, Thomas, Malone, Stockton, and Jordan. These are only a few names that played in the Laker-Celtic dynasty era and didn't win till Bird and Magic was gone.
                  Larry played at a time where the rules in the NBA allowed for teams to be stacked. It's nearly impossible that you get a team where you have as many HOF's that the Celts/Lakers did. The game now is so much different then back then. Guys used their skills instead of relying on athleticism but I think the players now are alot more skilled overall. When I watch those old games on ESPN Classic I see no defense. Instead I see hard fouls. I'm sure people are going to bring up the argument of how "people could hit the midrange" but there's more to Hoops than that. The League is far more advanced now then it ever was with advanced scouting reports and the such.

                  I do think Larry was the best SF of all time though. He could really do it all and if it weren't for a bad back he would have been even better.
                  Twitter Instagram - kgx2thez

                  Comment

                  • DC
                    Hall Of Fame
                    • Oct 2002
                    • 17996

                    #69
                    Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

                    How is Jordan a greater winner than Russell?
                    Concrete evidence/videos please

                    Comment

                    • ehh
                      Hall Of Fame
                      • Mar 2003
                      • 28962

                      #70
                      Re: Larry Bird best SF of all time?

                      Originally posted by DCAllAmerican
                      How is Jordan a greater winner than Russell?
                      Because Jordan's game was all psychological, duh!
                      "You make your name in the regular season, and your fame in the postseason." - Clyde Frazier

                      "Beware of geeks bearing formulas." - Warren Buffet

                      Comment

                      Working...