2020 Free Agency
STATE OF THE ROSTER
This is a bit of a recap, but we have about $20M in unrestricted free agents coming off the books (plys $6-7M in RFAs), and most of them are fairly obvious choices. When the dust settles, we should have our top two lines (Gaudreau-Hayes-Wheeler and Sbruev-Kesler-Nyquist) and all six defensemen under contract. So that basically means we need to figure out our goaltending and rebuild the bottom six (except Andrew Cogliano) from scratch.
In-house promotions? Well, Linus Ullmark probably becomes our backup goaltender, replacing Ondrej Pavelec, and Dominik Simon (RFA, but has reasonable demands) will probably get called up to center the 4th line. So that gets us down to 4 forwards and some depth pieces.
RE-SIGN PERIOD
Priority #1 has to be Philipp Grubauer. He is asking about $5M. There are upgrades available in free agency, but they’re either guys who are going to command a lot of money (Andre Vasilevskiy and Connor Hellebuyck) or guys who are older (Pekka Rinne, Marc-Andre Fleury). (Vasilevskiy is actually an RFA, so there would also be picks involved on him). On balance, I’m feeling like it might be better to re-sign Grubauer. He actually balks at our first effort – in fact, says he wants out of Atlanta entirely – but that proves to be a negotiating tactic and he signs on the second pass at $5M a year. In fairness, I did lowball him pretty badly on the first offer at like $4.5M.
The rest of the unrestricted free agents -- David Backes, Matt Bartkowski, Beau Bennett, Mikkel Boedker, Mark Letestu, Ondrej Pavelec, Nail Yakupov – all get their walking papers. Some of them are decent players I might consider bringing back, but I figure you do the big pieces first and then see what you have left to fill in the gaps.
RFA-wise, I resign centers Dominik Simon, Mitchell Stephens, Michael Spacek, and goalie Nik Rubin. A few others (Gustav Olofsson, Oliver Kylington, Taylor Leier, Teemu Turunen, and goalie Nik Rubin) get RFA tags, and some of the no-man’s-land guys (too old to be a prospect; not good enough to make the big club) like Oskar Sundqvist and Dominic Turgeon get shown the door.
From our recent draftee pool, LW Jakub Lauko from our 2019 class looks like he’s ready to take the next step (66 OVR and Top 6 potential), so we also sign him to a full contract at about 850k.
FREE AGENCY
Our initial look focuses on assembling a third line of Chris Kreider, Erik Haula, and Michael Frolik. I thought about Evgenii Dadanov on the right, but if I went with that as a full wishlist line, I’d have almost nothing left for depth signings. So Frolik it is. I also target LW Yakov Trenin who’s 23 and has Top 6 potential and is asking less than a million. I start a little below their ask in all cases.
Early results are mixed. Kreider (4 years @ 4.8M) and Trenin (2 years @ 725k) sign after a few days. Haula rejects and doesn’t even give me a chance to counter; he re-ups with Vegas. Frolik rejects, but doesn’t have any other suitors, so I can still work on him. Plan B at center moves to Joe Thornton – he’s 41, so I’d rather give him one year than the two he’s asking for, but as a third-line center, he wouldn’t be terrible.
Thornton and Frolik go through a few rounds of rejecting and counter-offering. As this is happening I make a few minor trades.
First, Carolina offers to take Jake Dotchin off my hands for a 2nd-round pick swap. At this point, I’d rather be out from under his $1.75M, so whatever. Fair or not, he’s also become my symbolic goat for the playoff collapse. Deal.
TRADE: Firebirds trade D Jake Dotchin and their 2nd round pick in 2021 to Carolina for a 2nd-round pick in 2021 (orig: CGY).
In a move which might be an overpay (the opposing GM basically called me an idiot), I sent LW Artem Zubov (Top 6 guy, 20 years old) to Florida for C Jared McCann (also Top 6, but 24). I figure McCann can be my insurance policy if either Frolik or Thornton doesn’t work out. (Also, I’m feeling like I’m pretty deep in LW prospects, with Trenin, Lauko, and Kondratiev all in the system.) Maybe I should’ve tried to squeeze more out of the deal, but whatever.
TRADE: Firebirds trade LW Artem Zubov to Florida for C Jared McCann.
Returning to free agency, with Dotchin’s money in hand, we also decide to move in a new direction. While I’m looking around for depth parts, I notice TWD Ben Hutton is sitting out there with no offers at $3M. He’s an improvement in anyone except Karlsson, so I decide to at least get in on the action and see what happens.
A few days later, Thornton (1 year @ 3.8M) and Hutton (3 years @ 3.0M) both sign. Frolik, on the other hand, continues to be stubborn. I’m really torn here. He still feels like the perfect fit and a lot of my other options (including bringing back Jesper Fast or Mikkel Boedker) have signed somewhere else while he’s been screwing around. On the other hand, we’re now above his ask and he’s STILL whining about our locker room chemistry. I’m staying in, but I’ll admit I’m losing patience, and if he does sign, he’d better produce.
While Frolik is stringing us along, we start working on depth signings. Beau Bennett gets an offer to return as a possible depth forward, and then a bunch of quasi-prospecty guys: LW Rudolfs Balcers (another LW!), C Alexander Gonchar, G Emil Larmi, and D Pavel Prokhorkin. There’s no elite talent still on the board, but these guys are showing Top 6 forward/Top 4 defense potential levels. We also get an offer from San Jose of a 3rd-rounder for Mirco Mueller – we go ahead and take that to re-open a top-six spot for Tony DeAngelo.
FINALLY. Frolik signs (3 years @ 3.0M), and our third line of Kreider-Thornton-Frolik is ready for action. For the moment, that means Cogliano-Simon-McCann is the 4th line. Or maybe it’ll be McCann centering – Simon played some wing for the Pens in real life. TBD.
At this point, we're mostly working on extra bodies, all under a million. Beau Bennett rejects and signs with Winnipeg, but Balcers accepts (2 years @ 850k). A few days later, Larmi (1 year @ 700k), Gonchar (3 years @ 750k) and Prokhorkin (3 years @ 700k) all sign.
A few more depth offers go out. RW Ryan Reaves (1 year @ 1.5M) as a depth forward, G Jordan Binnington ( 2 years, 800k) as… well, he’ll be on a two-way deal, so he can either start in the minors or be the backup. Take your pick. Skipping ahead a few days, both accept.
I now have a dilemma. I have about $7M left, and Nicklas Backstrom (6.925M) and Max Pacioretty (4.925M) are both sitting out there with no offers. Part of me says “grab the talent, figure out where to play it” later. But that would turn somebody -- most likely Thornton or Kreider, though maybe I could juggle things so it was Frolik instead -- into a really expensive fourth-liner. I suppose in Backstrom’s case I could turn around and trade Thornton, though trading someone you just signed – even if it was a 1-year deal – is one of those things that borders on cheesy because if the other team really wanted that guy, they could’ve just signed him themselves.
I end up offering on Backstrom. We go back and forth a couple times, but he ends up signing with Vancouver (1 year @ $6.8M). Pacioretty also signed, with Toronto. No real harm done. A little cap space doesn’t bother me because it represents flexibility to take on a salary mid-season.
Taking one last look at the free agency lists, I think that’s going to do it. There’s no one left who can really make my team better, there’s no young, undervalued talent leaping out – it’s either low-ceiling guys or total shots in the dark. I might add a body or two once I get to camp and see where I need to push a Create-A-Scrub out of playing time, but other than that, I guess I’m done.
In summary, our signings end up being:
- LW Chris Kreider (4 yr/4.8M) – 3rd-line LW
- C Joe Thornton (1 yr/3.8M) – 3rd-line C
- RW Michael Frolik (3 yr/3.0M) – 3rd-line RW
- D Ben Hutton (3 yr/3.0M) – 1st/2nd-pair defenseman
- RW Ryan Reaves (1 yr/1.5M) – depth forward
- LW Taylor Leier (RFA tender/1.125M) – depth forward
- D Gustav Olofsson (RFA/870k) – depth defenseman
- LW Rudolfs Balcers (2 yr/850k) – prospect
- G Jordan Binnington (2yr/800k) – mostly a body, could compete as a backup
- D Niko Mikkola (RFA/770k) – spare body
- C Alexander Gonchar (3 yr/750k) – prospect
- LW Yakov Trenin (2 yr/725k) – prospect
- D Pavel Prokhorkin (3 yr/700k) – prospect
- G Emil Larmi (1yr/700k) – spare body
As I’m wrapping up, Washington comes calling, offering a 4th for Dylan DeMelo and a 7th. At age 27, DeMelo is done growing, and he’s also a free agent after this year, and I don’t think I’d be able to flip him for much better in-season, so what the heck. DEAL.
TRADE: Firebirds trade D Dylan DeMelo and a 7th round pick in 2020 to Washington for a 4th-round pick in 2021 (orig: WPG).
AROUND THE LEAGUE
I screwed up and forwarded to a point where most of the free agents dropped off the “signed recently” report. So I’ll just have to get this next year. The one thing I did notice is Tampa Bay is currently dealing with an Andre Vasilevskiy RFA holdout, so 23-year-old Connor Ingram and veteran Antti Niemi are holding down the fort there.
Comment