Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

[CoachLewis73]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

Is there any newer versions coming out soon?

[madden1717]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

any spreadsheets with each draft class and the names and overall ratings for each player?

[dakota7]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

any spreadsheets with each draft class and the names and overall ratings for each player?

The classes are randomly generated. No draft guides available, like the old days

Sent from my SM-N910R4 using Tapatalk

[fopayne]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

So I'm having an issue with this and maybe someone can help. I'm using Excel 2016 Pro Plus and on the Individual Scouting Reports page I'm getting a formula error that says #NAME? in the Strengths and Weaknesses section. Is anybody else getting this error? How do I fix it?

[Crzy25]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

Hoping we will be getting an updated version of this for Madden 20. This tool is a great help!

[grilled_rooster]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

Hoping we will be getting an updated version of this for Madden 20. This tool is a great help!

I heard that Old Man Nathy is taking some time off. He is not working on a M20 Version. There are more important things in life then Madden.

[extremeskins04]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

The M19 scouting tool should still work pretty well for M20.

[ktd1976]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

The M19 scouting tool should still work pretty well for M20.

IDK if it really would, or not, what with the ratings being completely reworked, and the new Super Star X factor dev added.....

[extremeskins04]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

IDK if it really would, or not, what with the ratings being completely reworked, and the new Super Star X factor dev added.....

It works pretty well still. Just did a few drafts with it. I just take Quick out and replace it with Star.

[Justb__]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

It works pretty well still. Just did a few drafts with it. I just take Quick out and replace it with Star.

That is good to hear, doubt it gets updated before my CFM does first draft

Sent from my LG-LS998 using Operation Sports mobile app

[servo75]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

IDK if it really would, or not, what with the ratings being completely reworked, and the new Super Star X factor dev added.....

Superstar and X Factor aren't tied to ratings, so as long as the scouting hasn't been overhauled (which it probably should), I don't see why it wouldn't work.

[storm021]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

Just did my first draft for Madden 20 using the scouting tool and it still works really well. The only issue I personally found was they adding a few more WR Arch types. Want to do a few more to see if the results are consistent but from what I saw it worked really well

[mvb34]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

For Archetype for physical would use Possession ?




Sent from my VS996 using Operation Sports mobile app

[Jose21crisis]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

I'm thinking you would use "Possession" WR in the tool for "Route Runner" WR, and use "Red Zone Threat" WR in the tool for "Physical" WR.

[pkloehn]

Re: Madden 19 CFM Scouting Tool

Updating just the core tool without touching the OVR and Skill Specific calcs doesn't appear to be too difficult. I've added the new Defensive Schemes to Nathan's spreadsheet tool for my own use.

The offensive schemes involve a bit more work, as the new Offensive Archetypes don't map 1:1 back to the Madden 19 Archetypes, or at least I haven't seen data that shows this.

Personally, I wouldn't touch any of the calcs. The scouting still holds up in M20 for me, and all I'm interested in is the Scheme Fits and a relative evaluation of the player against the mean talent pool, which the M19 version does.

If I had the information below, I would be willing to make an attempt at an update of the 7.1 Excel template.

The work that would need to be done to add the new offensive Archetypes is:
1. Modify the lookup values across the entire Lookups workbook consistently (number of archetypes has not changed, just the names). This step is simply updating A1:U5 of the Lookups and the other named ranges in the workbook.
2. Update the A8:A71 name of the archetype (must be consistent through the sheet.
3. For each new Archetype find % weighting of each attribute and update in A7:BE71.
4. Update the POS Tiers Lower (A7:A374), POS Tier Mid (A377:A677), POStier Upper (A680:A980), POS Tier Lowers (A983:A1283) with value from #2.
5. Update the O Sheme lookup with both new Schemes and Archetypes.
6. Update POSArch (A1531:A1594) with the consistent name.
7. Update Archetype Scheme Fits (A1818:V1881) with Archetype variables.