Things missing from Scouting Update

[ForUntoOblivionSoar∞]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

1.) Sort column for completion of prospect % or any combine stats.
2.) Ability to change focus scouting at anytime during the season.
3.) Wonderlic Score.
4.) College season sim stats.
5.) Kicker and punter notes they all say the same thing.

100%......

[ForUntoOblivionSoar∞]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

Do NOT back out of setting up your focus players, or you'll lose it entirely. You must complete it or you don't get it. So examine the guys you want first, then select that task.

[sitandbehitski]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

It’s not bug riddled just missing a lot of quality of life things. I will say I appreciate the effort but the scouting is even more boring than it was before, sure it’s harder and more realistic but it’s still just boring. It makes zero sense to have guys scouted to 80% and not have position specific ratings unlocked.

Gonna have to disagree with you here. There are definitely some major bugs, not getting the scouting boosts on focused players frequently, and the player notes not being accurate much of the time (example, every single QB and OL I looked at in the draft had notes indicating that they threw tight spirals and played with a high motor respectively, and only like half the QB's had the throws tight spiral trait, and NONE of the OL had the high motor trait).

[ForUntoOblivionSoar∞]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

Gonna have to disagree with you here. There are definitely some major bugs, not getting the scouting boosts on focused players frequently, and the player notes not being accurate much of the time (example, every single QB and OL I looked at in the draft had notes indicating that they threw tight spirals and played with a high motor respectively, and only like half the QB's had the throws tight spiral trait, and NONE of the OL had the high motor trait).

What do you mean by this? You mean only at one appointed time, or do you mean you focus on them and then get nothing out of it? If it's the former that's by design. If the latter, then definitely a bug.


As for the notes, I wish they weren't traits in the first place. Or at least not only traits. Would be nice if they had ratings hints as well, e.g., "Hops like Moss but speed like a tight end."

[sitandbehitski]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

What do you mean by this? You mean only at one appointed time, or do you mean you focus on them and then get nothing out of it? If it's the former that's by design. If the latter, then definitely a bug.


As for the notes, I wish they weren't traits in the first place. Or at least not only traits. Would be nice if they had ratings hints as well, e.g., "Hops like Moss but speed like a tight end."

The later, from what I've read it looks like if you are very careful and don't try to switch any screens or go into any other menus and know exactly who you're focusing you can get the boosts, but it seems pretty easy to get nothing out of if you open the wrong screen or switch something.

As for the player notes I agree they should be a lot more varied, but even as they are intended they clearly are either bugged, or they are literally just useless window dressing.

[BoomFranchise]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

It’s not bug riddled just missing a lot of quality of life things. I will say I appreciate the effort but the scouting is even more boring than it was before, sure it’s harder and more realistic but it’s still just boring. It makes zero sense to have guys scouted to 80% and not have position specific ratings unlocked.

It's absolutely bug riddled just stop it man. A lot of us are getting 0 point the focused scouting portion of the game which is one of the only times we get any sort of boost. How iso hat not a bug?

[coachmac75]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

1) I think the positions need to be enhanced to a more modern view.
For instance LOLB/ROLb are totally meaningless we should have edge rushers vs off ball LB.

2) I think stats would be great to add on assessment. What NBA 2k has with shooting stats out of workouts are good too and could be revelaed for private workouts

3) Scouts should have a contract and subject to bids.

4) I think scout should have accuracy rating and efficiency ratings and the accuacy of their information / progression should be handled accordingly (the Show is a good benchmark for that).

5) I think we definitely needs enhanced interface to sort/filter data from the prospect list (2k is a good benchmark for this).

6) Real draft board should be back in game instead of that favourite list (this is the only downgrade from previous Draft preparation features)

[Faikanese]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

Do NOT back out of setting up your focus players, or you'll lose it entirely. You must complete it or you don't get it. So examine the guys you want first, then select that task.

With all the testing they supposedly did. I'm surprised they didn't catch that bug.

[Faikanese]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

1) I think the positions need to be enhanced to a more modern view.
For instance LOLB/ROLb are totally meaningless we should have edge rushers vs off ball LB.

2) I think stats would be great to add on assessment. What NBA 2k has with shooting stats out of workouts are good too and could be revelaed for private workouts

3) Scouts should have a contract and subject to bids.

4) I think scout should have accuracy rating and efficiency ratings and the accuacy of their information / progression should be handled accordingly (the Show is a good benchmark for that).

5) I think we definitely needs enhanced interface to sort/filter data from the prospect list (2k is a good benchmark for this).

6) Real draft board should be back in game instead of that favourite list (this is the only downgrade from previous Draft preparation features)

Scouts and Coaches should have contracts and each team should have a Coaching Budget like in 2k. The only thing I wish NBA2k would put in is Coaching records for every year coached for each coach.

[BoomFranchise]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

With all the testing they supposedly did. I'm surprised they didn't catch that bug.

The fact that Bengal spotted about 5 things in probably 2-3 hours of gameplay really says it all.

[Datninja619]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

Do NOT back out of setting up your focus players, or you'll lose it entirely. You must complete it or you don't get it. So examine the guys you want first, then select that task.

Seriously. Here I am in off season wondering why I only have one person with 75%

[Datninja619]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

How do you look at mock drafts during the draft?

[Datninja619]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

Maybe I'm spoiled by playing games on PC. But I'm already tired of going in and out of scouting menus and each menu re-sorting.

[Exile04]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

I'm glad I waited for the update to decide if I should buy. He'll no ill wait for it 50% off or something.ea play saved me money.

Sent from my SM-G996U using Operation Sports mobile app

[Datninja619]

Re: Things missing from Scouting Update

Another suggestion - If the whole premise of this update is to give us less skill information, because we didn't scout for that position.

Then we need to be able to sort and/or filter on the Rating categories (Poor, Good, etc) .

Maybe I didn't scout WR, but I know I need a returner. Let me sort on speed and see who fits my needs.