Armor & Swords Pro & All-Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

[C0883R]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

Trying to find a way to make the game slightly tougher as I'm loving how the game feels, but it's simply too easy. Have play limits and cooldowns been removed? Was planning to use these to force me to use my playbook more but can't find the options anywhere.

Play limits and cool downs are in CFM.
I use it myself. I also like using coach selection. In my opinion it helps to keep me from cheesing the cpu.


On a side note I am using a rookie FG l started slow simming my FG and I actually saw my kicker miss a FG.

[Billtomhere]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

Any reason to not try these on all pro?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[colepeyton]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

Any reason to not try these on all pro?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

All Pro game speed is just to fast, interceptions are far to many with sliders or not but most importantly you can’t play no switch on All pro… it’s all about user stick skills Ala Mut with real teams… at least from my perspective.

[thelegitgoat]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

I enjoy this game but the ints just kill it for me every game has 3-6 in it. I’m playing on all pro default. Will try these out


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[jsteele14]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

I feel like the kicking via random number generator should incorporate overall rating. Otherwise you could care less who the kicker is. Not sure anyone has ever analyzed a breakdown between FG success rates between Tier 1 to Tier 4 kickers.

If that data was understood then a algorithm could be created. The simplest would be if the current number is 70 or less than you multiply by 0.9 for a 90 rated kicker or .75 for a 75 rated kicker. That is likely far too wide a success rate difference but you get the idea.

Sent from my SM-G781V using Tapatalk

[Scott]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

I feel like the kicking via random number generator should incorporate overall rating. Otherwise you could care less who the kicker is. Not sure anyone has ever analyzed a breakdown between FG success rates between Tier 1 to Tier 4 kickers.

If that data was understood then a algorithm could be created. The simplest would be if the current number is 70 or less than you multiply by 0.9 for a 90 rated kicker or .75 for a 75 rated kicker. That is likely far too wide a success rate difference but you get the idea.

Sent from my SM-G781V using Tapatalk

I believe what he’s been doing lately is super-simming all kicks.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[jsteele14]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

I believe what he’s been doing lately is super-simming all kicks.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Oh ok. I did not realize that was working properly. That is certainly much easier.

Sent from my SM-G781V using Tapatalk

[Armor and Sword]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

I ran into an issue with super simming kicking. Sometimes the CPU decides not to kick a field goal in a situation that I want them to so what I’m doing is not using the left stick when I kick. I’m just gonna have the power bar either come in the middle of the accuracy bar or to the right of the left in combination with the random number generator.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[TopSide83]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

I ran into an issue with super simming kicking. Sometimes the CPU decides not to kick a field goal in a situation that I want them to so what I’m doing is not using the left stick when I kick. I’m just gonna have the power bar either come in the middle of the accuracy bar or to the right of the left in combination with the random number generator.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

This is the way to go. Pretty sure Schnaidt came up with this method and it works really well for me. I miss a lot of kicks from farther out and even some bunnies on occasion so having a better kicker actually matters.

[eggplantkitty80]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

I enjoy this game but the ints just kill it for me every game has 3-6 in it. I’m playing on all pro default. Will try these out


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Yeah the first game I used these sliders, 5 picks in 5 straight drives. 2 from me and 3 for the CPU.

[Armor and Sword]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

Yeah the first game I used these sliders, 5 picks in 5 straight drives. 2 from me and 3 for the CPU.

That’s awesome man.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[KSUowls]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

I feel like the kicking via random number generator should incorporate overall rating. Otherwise you could care less who the kicker is. Not sure anyone has ever analyzed a breakdown between FG success rates between Tier 1 to Tier 4 kickers.

If that data was understood then a algorithm could be created. The simplest would be if the current number is 70 or less than you multiply by 0.9 for a 90 rated kicker or .75 for a 75 rated kicker. That is likely far too wide a success rate difference but you get the idea.

Sent from my SM-G781V using Tapatalk

Definitely a good idea, and one I kind of thought about trying to recreate but I was lazy lol

One thing to remember though is that NFL kickers in general are very accurate, with no huge variation from guy to the next. There are certainly exceptions to the rule like Justin Tucker making 90% of his field goals over a 10 year period, but the median point for kickers over the same time period with at least 50 attempts was 86%. The lowest % for any kicker with at least 50 attempts was 78%. There is also likely some biases within the numbers. For instance, if you have Justin Tucker or play half your games in a dome , you might be more willing to kick a 50 yard field goal than if you has Mason Crosby or kicking in Chicago. So, it becomes a point of just how deep you want to go with the analytics.

There is definitely some room to play with the numbers based on personal preference. One idea might be to say to use the original Success % as the base and modify from there. I don't have the game up right now to say what everyone is rated, but let's say that Justin Tucker is rating of 95 (I think kickers are rated lower in general this year, but we'll go with this for now).

Well Justin Tucker as the "best" kicker is about 4% better than the median so we can apply a +4% boost on the success rates. So, taking an example from the original chart, it has a 41-45 yard field goal with an 80% rate. You could say that Justin Tucker is 4% better than the Median which would make your new Success rate 83 [80% * 1.04]. If you have a rookie or just so journeyman kicker then you'd go the other way, so the success rate in this scenario could be like 74% (ie: the worst kicker was 78% overall, or 7% lower than the median. So we would want to be 7% worse in any scenario)

There are a few different ways to handle it. I'm lazy so I probably won't go through all of that unless I draft a rookie kicker though. Then I might give him some kind of penalty like the above.

[eggplantkitty80]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

That’s awesome man.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

It's not a knock on the sliders, everything else plays great. The dev team needs to address the broken slider.

[Armor and Sword]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

It's not a knock on the sliders, everything else plays great. The dev team needs to address the broken slider.

On Pro….I honestly have not had a game like that yet….All-Pro absolutely.

And I agree the interception slider is severely nerfed.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[TheDycktator]

Re: Armor & Swords Pro Custom Madden 23 Simulation Sliders For PS5/X Franchise Mode

Sliders feel great to me overall. Only thing I'm noticing is that even with CPU run blocking at 100 the CPU seems to be lacking a bit on the run game. Seems like the CPU just gives up on the run game very quickly most games, and when they do run the ball it is usually pretty ineffective. Ultimately I'm pretty sure this isn't something that can be fixed with sliders.


Tweaked a few numbers here and there, but it's a great base.