NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Basketball GURU
    MVP
    • Jul 2010
    • 1287

    #121
    Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

    I'll picked RG lll for this season and long term, I don't think you can go wrong with either him or Luck as long they both keep improving and both teams continue to build and put solid pieces around them.

    Comment

    • z Revis
      Hall Of Fame
      • Oct 2008
      • 13639

      #122
      Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

      Well, give Luck few more points on this debate after todays performance. Not incredible stats as far as completion percentage and INT's today, but that doesn't really matter when you score two TD's in the last 3 minutes including the game winning 75 yard drive with 1:07 remaining and no timeouts.

      Last week I would've given it to RG3, but now I don't know. RG3 still has the stats, but Luck is 8-4 with a few great comebacks/game winning drives.
      Indianapolis Colts
      Indiana Pacers
      Indiana Hoosiers
      Notre Dame Fighting Irish

      Comment

      • ImTellinTim
        YNWA
        • Sep 2006
        • 33028

        #123
        Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

        Wilson will again be overlooked today. He had 2 game-winning drives. In Chicago.

        Comment

        • iAM-IncReDiBLe-
          Next Miami Great
          • Dec 2008
          • 4285

          #124
          Wilson is playing just as good if not better then both of them. He has RG3 stats an Lucks wins. He's my ROTY so far.

          Comment

          • kingkilla56
            Hall Of Fame
            • Jun 2009
            • 19395

            #125
            Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

            Wilson is (if he is that is) overlooked because guys are doing it just as good if not better.
            Tweet Tweet

            Comment

            • BlastX21
              MVP
              • Jul 2010
              • 2118

              #126
              Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

              Originally posted by iAM-IncReDiBLe-
              (Wilson) has RG3 stats
              Justify this please.
              Originally posted by Kaiser Wilhelm
              there should not be ties occurring in the NFL except when neither team wins the game.

              Comment

              • iAM-IncReDiBLe-
                Next Miami Great
                • Dec 2008
                • 4285

                #127
                Originally posted by BlastX21
                Justify this please.
                Eh I was off on that statement.

                Wilson has less yards an four more int an one more td

                Comment

                • thaima1shu
                  Robot
                  • Feb 2004
                  • 5598

                  #128
                  Nobody has the stats/efficiency RGIII does. Wilson is doing just fine though. Better than anyone expected or gives him credit for

                  Comment

                  • kingkilla56
                    Hall Of Fame
                    • Jun 2009
                    • 19395

                    #129
                    Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                    Oh God this "Wilson gets no credit" is gonna be a thing now huh?
                    Tweet Tweet

                    Comment

                    • ProfessaPackMan
                      Bamma
                      • Mar 2008
                      • 63852

                      #130
                      Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                      Originally posted by kingkilla56
                      Wilson is (if he is that is) overlooked because guys are doing it just as good if not better.
                      Exactly.

                      It has nothing to do with him whatsoever. It's the fact that Luck and RG3 have had a bigger impact on their team's than he has. I mean when was the last time you seen the Redskins put up 30 points this many times in a season? They damn sure weren't doing it when they were trotting out McNabb and Grossman under Center.
                      #RespectTheCulture

                      Comment

                      • Seahawk76
                        MVP
                        • Oct 2005
                        • 1394

                        #131
                        Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                        I'd rank Wilson second to RG3 right now and way ahead of Luck. Wilson has better numbers than Luck in virtually every category except total passing yards and that's only because Luck has thrown a lot more passes. And Wilson's numbers have been close to spectacular over the past five games with 11 TDs and just one INT and a quarterback rating exceeding 100 in every game but one (96.8 vs Detroit).

                        Wilson is also on a pace to threaten the rookie TD passing record set by Peyton Manning with 26. Wilson has 19 and needs seven in the final four games to tie it and eight to break it. That's doable the way he has played in the second half of the season so far.

                        Comment

                        • wwharton
                          *ll St*r
                          • Aug 2002
                          • 26949

                          #132
                          Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                          Originally posted by Seahawk76
                          I'd rank Wilson second to RG3 right now and way ahead of Luck. Wilson has better numbers than Luck in virtually every category except total passing yards and that's only because Luck has thrown a lot more passes. And Wilson's numbers have been close to spectacular over the past five games with 11 TDs and just one INT and a quarterback rating exceeding 100 in every game but one (96.8 vs Detroit).

                          Wilson is also on a pace to threaten the rookie TD passing record set by Peyton Manning with 26. Wilson has 19 and needs seven in the final four games to tie it and eight to break it. That's doable the way he has played in the second half of the season so far.
                          All playing for a team that thrives on it's defense and amazing running back... a team that used this same philosophy to be in the playoff hunt with Taveris Jackson.

                          I just said this in another thread. People look at their favorite player/team without considering the competition they are up against. Luck is throwing more passes bc his defense is garbage that borders on average if the team can get a lead, and the running game is a joke. The fact that the two teams have the same record is a bonus for Luck, not something that cancels out so Wilson can get more props. The kid is having a good year... he's not doing what Luck or RG3 are doing. Luckily for him he doesn't have to.

                          Comment

                          • Redskinsfan26
                            Pro
                            • Jul 2009
                            • 624

                            #133
                            Originally posted by iAM-IncReDiBLe-
                            Wilson is playing just as good if not better then both of them. He has RG3 stats an Lucks wins. He's my ROTY so far.
                            Do you realize the team Wilson is on? The Seahawks have a good D, and a beast at running back. Their wide reciever core is also pretty solid. If RG had the Hawks D, his team would be undefeated.
                            REDSKINS & WIZARDS

                            Comment

                            • OSUFan_88
                              Outback Jesus
                              • Jul 2004
                              • 25642

                              #134
                              Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                              Brandon Weeden's day is being severely over looked today. Then again, it was against the Raiders, so I can understand why.
                              Too Old To Game Club

                              Urban Meyer is lol.

                              Comment

                              • Bmore Irish
                                The Future
                                • Jul 2011
                                • 3461

                                #135
                                Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                                needless to say, this is the year of the rookie QB. even nick foles is gettin in there and makin some plays now lol. But seriously. Tonight. RGIII. This is what it's all about. If the RGIIIs..i mean the Redskins make a run here in the following weeks, then it gets interesting. As a Ravens fan, I'm scared for next week, i can see Griffin tearin us apart. Luckily their defense is very suspect. Great comeback yesterday by Luck too. Wilson is doing a damn good job leading his team as well. Can't go wrong with these guys.

                                Comment

                                Working...