Pink Floyd Fans................

[Heelfan71]

I hear some songs that I am not sure who is singing (Gilmour or Waters). Can anyone list the most popular/best songs sung by each person?

[Ger]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

list the songs and i will tell you

i guess i can start w/a few

Comfortably Numb-Waters then Gilmour then Waters then Gilmour
Money- Gilmour
Time- Gilmour and Rick Wright
Wish You Were Here- Gilmour
Another Brick in the Wall Pt 2 Waters and Gilmour

[Triggerfish]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

have a cigar/Pigs-waters
comfortably numb/Money-gilmour
they both shared alot of singing on the PF Albums...do you know which one you heard?

[Ger]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

actually Have A Cigar is sung by Roy Harper.

[ODogg]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

actually Have A Cigar is sung by Roy Harper.

yeah it's the only song I think aside from seamus that is sung by someone outside of the group. seamus is a song I used to annoy my co-workers with (it's funny because it's got a dog yodeling on it, many floyd musta been so high back in the day).

[Ger]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

You ever see them use the dog on the Live at Pompeii dvd? Its pretty cool.

[ODogg]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

You ever see them use the dog on the Live at Pompeii dvd? Its pretty cool.

yeah man, gilmour looks like he's smoked a nickel bag in that video. i love the part where they are sitting around talking about pie crust and stuff at the table, lol, classic!!

i used to watch that DVD all the time on fridays and hit the brewskis. come to think of it, i'll have to load that back up again when i get my new TV. I love that DVD, just wish they'd bring out DSOT and Pulse on DVD....Pulse keeps getting delayed and I don't even know if there are plans currently to bring DSOT to dvd.

[Ger]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

I think Pulse comes out next month, but dont quote me on that.

[ODogg]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

I think Pulse comes out next month, but dont quote me on that.

Here's what Amazon says: Availability: This title will be released on July 11, 2006.

Looks like July is going to be a good month for releases with NCAA and Pulse.

[Ger]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

lets hope they dont delay it any longer. argh!

[AugustWest71]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

lets hope they dont delay it any longer. argh!

Fo real. I have the CD and the performance is just amazing.

[FISH]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

I hear some songs that I am not sure who is singing (Gilmour or Waters). Can anyone list the most popular/best songs sung by each person?

Wow, you are usually a lot more precise, is that really you?

[Heelfan71]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

Thanks, I have every single album ever made and I was just listening to them all. There were a few songs that I wasn't sure and it turned out it was both of them. What about "Hey You" Is that both too ? I didn't know that about "Have A Cigar" either. Thanks.

Anyone have a prefernce when it comes to Gilmour or Waters ??? I like them both. Waters was the writing genious though. But they were the best when they were both in the group.

I read Dark Side Of The Moon sales 8,000 copier per week still !

[Heelfan71]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

One more. "Welcom To The Machine" who sings that one ?

[FISH]

Re: Pink Floyd Fans................

Anyone have a prefernce when it comes to Gilmour or Waters ??? I like them both. Waters was the writing genious though. But they were the best when they were both in the group.

Both are geniuses IMO, I heard Waters say when the did "The Wall" it was him and Gilmour and no one else in the band really gave a S$%t.