Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SPTO
    binging
    • Feb 2003
    • 68046

    #31
    Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

    Originally posted by trobinson97
    If you're talking about LOTR being a "remake" in the sense of it being adapted from the books, then you should also know that Star Wars fiction predated the first movie.
    Huh?

    There were no Star Wars books and whatnot written before 1977. Star Wars was based on the old Serials in tone and had sci-fi roots but there was nothing on the market that you could call a space opera like SW was. I think you need to prove that there was SW fiction before '77 because I don't buy it.
    Member of the Official OS Bills Backers Club

    "Baseball is the most important thing that doesn't matter at all" - Robert B. Parker

    Comment

    • Sandman42
      Hall Of Fame
      • Aug 2004
      • 15186

      #32
      Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

      Originally posted by ExtremeGamer
      I feel like I'm standing in line at Mooby's.
      That's the first thing I thought of when I saw this thread.
      Member of The OS Baseball Rocket Scientists Association

      Comment

      • trobinson97
        Lie,cheat,steal,kill: Win
        • Oct 2004
        • 16366

        #33
        Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

        Originally posted by SPTO
        Huh?

        There were no Star Wars books and whatnot written before 1977. Star Wars was based on the old Serials in tone and had sci-fi roots but there was nothing on the market that you could call a space opera like SW was. I think you need to prove that there was SW fiction before '77 because I don't buy it.
        Alan Dean Foster bibliography
        PS: You guys are great.

        SteamID - Depotboy



        ...2009, 2011, 2012, 2015, 2017, 2020....
        What a run
        Roll Tide




        Comment

        • dieselboy
          --------------
          • Dec 2002
          • 18040

          #34
          Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

          Originally posted by ExtremeGamer
          I feel like I'm standing in line at Mooby's.
          Ditto.

          Better trilogy, Clerks.

          Comment

          • jfsolo
            Live Action, please?
            • May 2003
            • 12965

            #35
            Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

            Originally posted by Seymour Scagnetti
            I guess the old guys will say Star Wars and the young guys will say LOTR. LOTR was well done but it's missing that corny charm that Star Wars had and I guess most action\fantasy movies had in the 70's and 80's.
            I'm an old guy(saw Star Wars in the theater as a 8 year old) but I still pick LOTR. Corny charm is ok for romantic comedies, buy I don't want it in my sci-fi. This is not a slam on Star Wars, but I think the first three Alien films are much better then Star Wars as well.(yes including the underated(IMO) Alien 3)
            Jordan Mychal Lemos
            @crypticjordan

            Do this today: Instead of $%*#!@& on a game you're not going to play or movie you're not going to watch, say something good about a piece of media you're excited about.

            Do the same thing tomorrow. And the next. Now do it forever.

            Comment

            • Misfit
              All Star
              • Mar 2003
              • 5766

              #36
              Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

              Originally posted by trobinson97

              I don't know whats on Alan Dean's site, but Lucas wrote Star Wars as a spoof of old serial films. There are numerous interviews with him to prove this point (I viewed many of them in a philosophy class in college on the subject of religious themes in Star Wars). The original never had the words "Episode IV: A New Hope" in the title. It was supposed to mimic the old serials that tossed the viewer right into the action immediately. It wasn't until later that was added. Initially, there were no plans for sequels but the success of the first dictated that and he added the Episode titles. The first three episodes weren't written long ago and sealed away in some vault, they were written when the time came to cash in on the franchise once again.

              Comment

              • ObiWanJenkins

                #37
                Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

                Star Wars is a better trilogy. That's my opinion.

                Comment

                • SlimKibbles
                  Supporter
                  • Apr 2004
                  • 7276

                  #38
                  Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

                  Originally posted by trobinson97
                  What are we supposed to see? The 1976 collaboration with George Lucas on the "A New Hope" novel?

                  Anyway, I am a big fan of the LOTR movies, but Star Wars beats it in my book. Personal opinion, but the prequel movies only enhanced the story from the OT movies. Those of you who aren't old enough to have seen the OT movies in the theatre when they first came out won't quite understand the impact they had.
                  MLB: Cincinnati Reds
                  NFL: Cincinnati Bengals
                  NCAA Hoops: Xavier Musketeers
                  NCAA Football: Miami Hurricanes
                  NHL: Calgary Flames

                  "All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing." - Edmund Burke

                  "The wisest men follow their own direction." - Euripides

                  Comment

                  • RoyalBoyle78
                    Aka."Footballforever"
                    • May 2003
                    • 23918

                    #39
                    Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

                    I hate both series, I think Blade Trilogy is better, thats just me.
                    N.Y Mets
                    N.Y Giants
                    N.Y Knicks
                    N.Y Islanders
                    Miami Hurricanes


                    Twitter - @RoyalBoyle78
                    XBOX LIVE - Royalboyle78
                    PSN - RoyalBoyle78

                    Comment

                    • luv_mist
                      Older
                      • May 2004
                      • 9596

                      #40
                      Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

                      Originally posted by Blzer
                      The Matrix
                      That's what I'm talking about. No love for the great.

                      1.Matrix Trilogy
                      2.Original Star Wars
                      3.LOTR

























                      3,000,000,000,000,000,000. Star Wars Ep. 1-3 Lucas was smoking hard when he thought he could write the dialogue.

                      Comment

                      • Skerik
                        Living in this tube
                        • Mar 2004
                        • 5215

                        #41
                        Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

                        Yeah, LOTR and SW both suck. I would rank them:

                        1) Santa Clause trilogy
                        2) Crocodile Dundee trilogy
                        3) The Mighty Ducks trilogy

                        ......

                        Infinity) Star Wars triology
                        Infinity +1) LOTR
                        Helen: Everyone's special, Dash.
                        Dash: [muttering] Which is another way of saying no one is.

                        Comment

                        • Misfit
                          All Star
                          • Mar 2003
                          • 5766

                          #42
                          Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

                          Originally posted by Skerik
                          Yeah, LOTR and SW both suck. I would rank them:

                          1) Santa Clause trilogy
                          2) Crocodile Dundee trilogy
                          3) The Mighty Ducks trilogy

                          ......

                          Infinity) Star Wars triology
                          Infinity +1) LOTR
                          That list needs the 3 Ninjas Trilogy.

                          Comment

                          • Sandman42
                            Hall Of Fame
                            • Aug 2004
                            • 15186

                            #43
                            Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

                            Originally posted by FootballForever
                            I hate both series, I think Blade Trilogy is better, thats just me.
                            I liked Blade 1 and 2, but I wasn't a big fan of 3.

                            I'd have to say Star Wars is the better trilogy though.
                            Member of The OS Baseball Rocket Scientists Association

                            Comment

                            • daflyboys
                              Banned
                              • May 2003
                              • 18238

                              #44
                              Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

                              Man.....if there only would have been that 3rd Fletch movie!!! Gah-don-don-don.


                              LOTR...... better effects, acting, storyline, casting (well, except maybe for the Agent dude from Matrix coming in as an Elf leader ... what a stretch).

                              Comment

                              • Flyboy
                                Daydream Believer
                                • Jun 2003
                                • 11352

                                #45
                                Re: Better trilogy......Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?

                                I'm going to go with Star Wars even though ROTK is one of my favorite movies of all-time. The Two Towers just did nothing for me whatsoever.
                                Originally posted by EWRMETS
                                Maybe the best post in OS's history. If you don't think Tony Romo is a Hall of Famer, you support al Qaeda.

                                Comment

                                Working...