I'm not cracking on his facial expression or making fun of him about that. I'm not saying, HAHA, his face is deformed like its funny to me. But he does overact all his dramatic scenes. He turns his body to face a different angle than the angle he's facing which is kind of effective for stage acting where you really want to convey the dramatic mood of the scene but Peter does it just about every scene and it comes off as overdone on the television. And look, an actor has to work with what he's been given. The lip thing is not his fault but it does take away from the viewing experience. It's like if someone cast a really, really ugly actress in a lead role that prevents the audience from believing that the male lead falls in love with her. I can say you shouldn't crack on her because she was born like that but if it detracts from the viewing experience, maybe she shouldn't be cast in that role. I'm a second year drama minor and all my classmates agree that he's a pretty bad actor. Probably not the worst ever, but he does overact most of his scenes. He'd be a lot better if he took some formal training.
EDIT:
Did like the last two episodes a lot more. Still some things I don't like but the last two have been a lot better and there may be hope for this show yet. Sylar makes the show very interesting.
Comment