*** American Idol: Season 9 ***

[VanCitySportsGuy]

Re: *** American Idol: Season 9 ***

- Lauren:

This is a comment I shouldn't really make considering she's only 15 or 16 years old, but I'm surprised she didn't lose any weight from her initial audition to the live show. She has a really pretty face but she could lose 25 pounds. As for her signing, I wasn' a big fan. A very bland performance

- Casey

Don't like the guy at all. He's too "showy" for me

- Ashthon

A vanilla performance by a vanilla singer. She will be getting the boot within the next 3 weeks.

- Paul

Horrible, horrible, horrible. His movements on stage are distracting.

- Pia

Best performance of the night.

James

- Turned down his inner Lambert and showed a softer side but I still don't like the guy

- Haley

Next.......

- Jacob

Way too early to bring out the choir. Was very pitchy in certain parts of the song.

- Thia

Solid performance but she has no chance of winning the whole thing

- Stefano

My favorite male singer this season. A really solid performance

- Karen

She murdered the song (no pun intended). She's getting the boot or else it will be....

- Naima

I'll remember this performance weeks from now ....... because it was so horrible. At one point it looked like she almost forget the words. There's a reason most people don't dance and sign live.

- Scotty

Another typical Scotty performance. I think he's going to ride this all the way to the Top 5.

This post was presented by Beats Audio

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: *** American Idol: Season 9 ***

The right one went home last night. Ashton was horrible. Haley and Karen won't be far behind. Pia is head and shoulders above all of them imo.

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: *** American Idol: Season 9 ***

Naima should have got the boot. She'll likely be next along with Haley.

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: *** American Idol: Season 9 ***

I'm more convinced this show is fixed. Early on in the show Ryan said "Stay tuned until the very end!" They already knew the results and knew they were going to save Casey from the off.

[Pete1210]

Re: *** American Idol: Season 9 ***

What a shame and a bit of a shock seeing Pia go last night.
The judges need to step up and give some negative and positive feedback, instead of "they were all great tonight we really can't pick who could possibly get voted off" every week.

I think what hurt Pia this week was her potato sack looking outfit. Maybe showing some sex appeal would've grabbed some more votes. And being awkward moving around even a little on stage. Best voice but forgettable performance. Oh well.

I wish the judges hadn't used the save on Casey. They really thought he could win it all? He looks awful singing with those weird facial expressions. Maybe that could work as a front man for a metal band?