Game of The Year Discussion

[Tomba]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

these are why GOTY awards are fun discussions. I thought ocarina of time was just okay, and RE4 sucked. That's just me though.

WOW


What sports game do you like this year?

i NEED to be on some level of respect with you LOL

[Knight165]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

The best sports game this year?

MLB Power Pros, and it's not...even....close.

You're right about one thing and wrong about another....

You are correct....it's not even close, but it ain't Power Pros....c'mon...you know what the real deal is.....best baseball game to date......The Show..

M.K.
Knight165

[bizcanos]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

COD4. The stage with the AC-130 plane circling above the town was one the most memorable moments of gaming for me.

That was one of the most unique experiences in any game.

[Crucial Mike]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

Sports game- MLB Power Pros
Other- Super Mario Galaxy

[Tomba]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

You're right about one thing and wrong about another....

You are correct....it's not even close, but it ain't Power Pros....c'mon...you know what the real deal is.....best baseball game to date......The Show..

M.K.
Knight165

the show was and is a very great sport game

[Pared]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

You're right about one thing and wrong about another....

You are correct....it's not even close, but it ain't Power Pros....c'mon...you know what the real deal is.....best baseball game to date......The Show..

M.K.
Knight165

I would think this is pretty obvious.

[ExtremeGamer]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

You're right about one thing and wrong about another....

You are correct....it's not even close, but it ain't Power Pros....c'mon...you know what the real deal is.....best baseball game to date......The Show..

M.K.
Knight165

I liked Power Pros more than The Show. I said it in my review as well.

[Knight165]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

I liked Power Pros more than The Show. I said it in my review as well.

That's fine.....I was kind of throwing it back to the poster who made the statement that Power Pros was so far and above a better game than any other sports game that it was ridiculous for anyone to think anything different, when in fact his statement was a little ridiculous.

Some people like PP better than The Show...that's great...I and many others don't agree....but everyone is entitled to their own preference. Even if it's wrong

M.K.
Knight165

[seanmac]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

That's fine.....I was kind of throwing it back to the poster who made the statement that Power Pros was so far and above a better game than any other sports game that it was ridiculous for anyone to think anything different, when in fact his statement was a little ridiculous.

Some people like PP better than The Show...that's great...I and many others don't agree....but everyone is entitled to their own preference. Even if it's wrong

M.K.
Knight165

And I liked both NHL 08 and FIFA 08 better than either of them. Which goes to show that your mileage may vary depending on how much of a baseball fan you are (or aren't).

[JRod]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

Madden 08 pre-*vapor*-patch.

No?

[Pared]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

And I liked both NHL 08 and FIFA 08 better than either of them. Which goes to show that your mileage may vary depending on how much of a baseball fan you are (or aren't).

But whether or not you're a fan isn't really part of the discussion.

You can hate the Game of the Year.

In terms of recreating a sport, The Show is unmatched. Others are close but The Show comes out on top because of how deep the game is.

[TheMatrix31]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

The only reason you guys don't say the same about PP is because it was only out on the Wii and PS2. If it was out on the 360 and PS3, you guys would marvel at how deep it really is, despite it's light graphics.

But oh well, it's no big deal. Different strokes for different folks.

EDIT: Crucial Mike knows the deal

[Tomba]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

But whether or not you're a fan isn't really part of the discussion.

You can hate the Game of the Year.

In terms of recreating a sport, The Show is unmatched. Others are close but The Show comes out on top because of how deep the game is.

i can agree with that the game is reall good heck almost uncannily realistic BUT fifa 08 is the BEST EAsports game in along time since after the patch for it it plays a beautiful game of soccer

Back on topic.

mario galaxy's getting the nod for GoTY why?

gamerankings has it at NUMBER ONE ALL TIME. 97.8 % average! go ahead and argue...the facts are that it's the best game of all time

[jmood88]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

i can agree with that the game is reall good heck almost uncannily realistic BUT fifa 08 is the BEST EAsports game in along time since after the patch for it it plays a beautiful game of soccer

Back on topic.

mario galaxy's getting the nod for GoTY why?

gamerankings has it at NUMBER ONE ALL TIME. 97.8 % average! go ahead and argue...the facts are that it's the best game of all time

Mass Effect hasn't officially come out yet.

[Misfit]

Re: Game of The Year Discussion

I haven't finished Metroid or gotten my hands on the full version of some of the fall's big titles yet, but right now I think "How can it not be Mario?!" Galaxy is likely going to be one of those games we're discussing as one of the all-time greats 5-10 years from now. There are a lot of 5 star games out there right now, but I find it hard to believe any of them will carry such weight.