Madden vs NCAA

[jlower]

If I suck at NCAA will I probably find Madden equally frustrating?

[Ghost Of The Year]

You wont suck at either if you can get your sliders dialed into fit your particular skill set.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Edit - unless you mean online , in which case you may be SOL.

[jlower]

All offline. Dynasty/career.

Miss lotsa tackles
Throw lotsa ints

Hard to win even on 2nd lowest level. Win blowouts on easiest.

I've never changed sliders.

[jhoff7324]

No. I have found Madden plays more true to football than CFB. That's saying something cuz it doesn't play that true. But, it is cleaner, easier to tackle, smoother, more predictable.

CFB is extremely unpredictable which is infuriating but, fun at times. CFB has more of an arcade like feel in comparison to Madden.

Both have their pros/cons.

I would give it a shot!