Aaron Rodgers deserves a 100 overall rating!

[volsman]

We have seen a better 18 game stretch then this before. Farve 1996-97. Look up the stats if you don't believe it

[suthrnthug]

Quote: Originally Posted by volsman

We have seen a better 18 game stretch then this before. Farve 1996-97. Look up the stats if you don't believe it

He wasn't undefeated in that run or have a QB rating of 110+ 9 straight games. Look it up.

[suthrnthug]

Another win for the Packers and another 110+ QB rating for Aaron Rodgers!

[Iceman87GT]

Quote: Originally Posted by Obnoxious

Didn't Madden have a 100 rated player before? Or was that 2K Football? I swear I've seen it. And I don't think so. It's not all Aaron Rodgers y'know? The ENTIRE Offense is complete. Nobody gives them credit. Give him a Chicago Bears OL and see how he does.

He's played behind poor lines before (2008 and 2009).

Quote: Originally Posted by LivingLegend

He has thrown 3, and 2 of those were drops by his recievers that the defender caught.

He has 4, 2 of which were off tips from his receivers he threw his fourth this past weekend

Quote: Originally Posted by bmj2k7

HAHAHAHA now thats just stupid saying he deserves a 100, and no one has ever played at that level, so apparently someone only watches GB games. Brady in 07 and last season and the HOF QBs played better than rodgers this year. If Manning didn't get hurt it would still be Brady vs Manning who's better, he was put in by default and most people would still choose Brady over everyone else including rodgers. He's played NO ONE but the Bears 1 time, he has wide open receivers so lets not make him a great QB bc he's a product of his receivers, bc ive seen his games, he gets tds on screens or his WRs making a play he gets credit for. Everyone loves him since last year when he played OK at best, which is why Clay Mathews got more attention at the SB then rodgers bc hes there best player. During the post season Mathews/Woodson/Williams carried the team not rodgers. This year rodgers has played no real great D, his WRs make him look good bc he has the best WR core in the NFL. Dont get me wrong hes a top 3 QB but no where near Manning let alone Brady sorry.

Have you seen the passes he has made? You know the ones that get broken down on ESPN, FOX, CBS and NFL Network on a regular basis, in which the ball is perfectly placed where only his receiver can get it, going over the defenders' hands and falling right where it needs to be. He's not a product of his receivers, he is the one throwing spot-on passes to them and occasionally they are wide-open (maybe more so than some receiving corps but not enough to inflate his numbers as much as you claim they are).

As for Rodgers not being anywhere near Brady:
Brady didn't throw for more than 28 TDs (which he did twice) until his 7th season as a starter (when he got to 50), Rodgers has yet to have fewer than 28 TD passes. Rodgers reached the 100 TD mark during his 4th year as a starter, Brady did so in year 5.

Rodgers holds a passer rating higher than all QBs in nfl history with at least 1500 attempt. And while you may think the QB rating is some mystical formula that no one can figure out it actually is a good measure for long term success (game to game basis is where it gets fuzzy). Rodgers is well on his way to passing his mentor, and the elite QBs over the past few years. If he keeps this pace he will surpass them, you can't compare their entire accomplishments yet as both Brady and Manning have more time on Rodgers, but as how they are playing right now Rodgers is #1, Rodgers has done better in the playoffs than those 2, and has had a better season than the 2 (granted Manning is injured).

What I find the most interesting is that you think Brady is so much more elite than Manning. You are aware that Manning does everything, and has had virtually no defense, while Brady is the opposite, both are very accomplished and elite QBs when healthy but in terms of pure talent and ability Manning takes the cake (better stats, and if he had a defense he would have more rings).

[suthrnthug]

Another win and another 110+ QB rating! Still time to jump on the bandwagon!

[sportjames23]

Quote: Originally Posted by suthrnthug

You can call me a homer, I don't care. We as football fans have NEVER seen a QB play at this level with this kind of consistency. He is the best player in the NFL hands down. If anybody deserves the 100 rating it is Aaron Rodgers. Go Pack!

"We", kemosabe? Who is this "we"?

Rodgers is having a phenomenal year, but some Pack fans are starting to get carried away.

[suthrnthug]

Quote: Originally Posted by sportjames23

"We", kemosabe? Who is this "we"? Rodgers is having a phenomenal year, but some Pack fans are starting to get carried away.

"We" as in football fans. Name a QB who has had a better season thru the 1st 11 games of the season? Statistically speaking, Aaron Rodgers is playing better than Tom Brady's 07 season.

[havokeff]

No, he just has a very high QBR. His yards aren't that much better if at all, nor are his touchdown. He is completing a high percentage of his passes and is playing great, but lets let the season play out. There are 5 games to go and presumably two playoff games.

Rodgers could play like this the rest of the season and his defense could falter in the playoffs and they lose and then no one will care. Just like no one cares that the Patriots went 16-0, because they ultimately went 18-1.

I would still take '94 Steve Young over '11 Rogers any day of the week and twice on Sunday.