sorry i took a while to get back to you on this, but i was out all day yesterday and only had time to play a game and a half late last night.
anyways, i played against the jets for my first game. i scored a td on my first drive and i got a little worried that it would be easy all game, but as it progressed it was a back and forth struggle. to make a long story short, the jets tied the game in the fourth (7-7) and on another drive took the lead (14-7) with only a minute left. i managed to get down to their 30 and i was on my way to tie the game on a screen pass, but got tripped up right at the last minute. i was out of timeouts, so i lost. even though i lost the game, i felt that the ending was pretty incredible...like a true rivalry game would feel.
i tried playing a quick game against the colts and it felt like i was playing a different team (thankfully). manning was passing all over the field, but i managed to keep it close. i only wound up playing a half cause it was getting late, but i liked what i saw. the game was 17-10 (colts) before i quit.
my only issues were that there were too many penalties called against the cpu, but i'm using playmakers' penalty settings and maybe the patch skewed those settings. also, the cpu had clear breaks down the field, but always managed to step out of bounds...again, it has nothing to do with your sliders, it's just the faulty programming. at times, it felt like it was easy defending against the cpu, but i have been scored upon...i would've been a little more concerned if i dominated both games by keeping the jets and colts scoreless.
anyway, you really should consider opening up your own thread with these slider settings and ask for some feedback. i'd love to read other people's experiences using these.