madden 07 or ncaa 07 football?

[steven]

which game do u think is better in this era of next generation of football madden 07 or ncaa 07 football, feedback is helpful to me i dont have either game for my 360 so u make the decesion for me!!!
Thanks..........Nasa

[starscream]

Both games have their share of grief on the 360 this year.

Single Player NCAA...it has fatigue
Multiplayer Madden...why? Because my friends are all in love with him (got sick friends)

[sroz39]

Though neither is as refined as it could be, Madden is more polished...but also with more weird bugs/glitches/occurences.

Should be interesting to see what a FULL development cycle will do for Madden. Let's be honest, Madden 07 feels more like Madden 06 v.2. Meaning this is what we probably should've expected last November, and a game a little further along than 07 turned out to be.

[Fiddy]

both are solid titles with a lot of room for improvement.. i like them both the same!

[Macar91]

I like both games, but to me, NCAA is better even with all the collision detection problems. Specifically, I like the dynasty mode in NCAA better than the franchise mode in Madden. I find recruiting players more fun than drafting players and I like having turnover in the rosters every year. The franchise mode in Madden seems to get boring and repetitive if you play more than a couple of years.

Both games are similar gamplay wise, other than no fatigue in Madden and collision detection issues in NCAA. It really comes down to what you like better, NCAA or pro football.

[steven]

does madden 07 have fatigue, do players tire as the game goes on, or does a player fatigue faster when u use him to much, the reason i ask is because someone told me there no fatigue in madden 07, is that true??

does ncaa 07 football have the same problem? or is all this untrue?

Thanks......................Nasa

[bears5122]

NCAA because it has fatigue. My only issue with NCAA is the dirty disc error that seems to be killing 1 in every 4 games I play.

[Altimus]

Quote: Originally Posted by Macar91

Both games are similar gamplay wise, other than no fatigue in Madden and collision detection issues in NCAA. It really comes down to what you like better, NCAA or pro football.

I agree. I am sticking more with Madden just because I like pro football more. But, I will continue playing NCAA, something I haven't done the last couple years. As Macar said, both are great games. The biggest difference is pro or college.