Madden 08 Countdown: Player Ratings

[steph]

I like the Roy Williams coverage ratings

70 in zone coverage and 40 in man coverage
Worst coverage rating for a starting SS yet revealed, with Rodney Harrison
Seems about right!

[steph]

Ok now i have seen my colts ratings, i'm quite frustrated by some of them.
Spectacular catch for Marvin: 94, Reggie: 90, Dallas: 72 !!!
That's quite high rating for Marvin and Reggie, but when you see Randy Moss with a 98, it's not high enough!!
Marvin should be 100 in spectacular catch (Catch against the patriots this year...) and his catch in traffic rating should go down from 95 to 85 beacause it's not his main quality.
Reggie should be around 95 in spectacular catch.
And Dallas Clark should have at least 90 ! (Even Champ bailey has 80 or something in this rating!)

And the worst might be Bob Sanders 84 hit power rating !!!! WTF ??? You mean 94 !!

[RandyMoss84]

Quote: Originally Posted by steph

Ok now i have seen my colts ratings, i'm quite frustrated by some of them. Spectacular catch for Marvin: 94, Reggie: 90, Dallas: 72 !!! That's quite high rating for Marvin and Reggie, but when you see Randy Moss with a 98, it's not high enough!! Marvin should be 100 in spectacular catch (Catch against the patriots this year...) and his catch in traffic rating should go down from 95 to 85 beacause it's not his main quality. Reggie should be around 95 in spectacular catch. And Dallas Clark should have at least 90 ! (Even Champ bailey has 80 or something in this rating!) And the worst might be Bob Sanders 84 hit power rating !!!! WTF ??? You mean 94 !!

if reggie and marvin were 95+ in spectacular catch than randy would have to be 120+

[Matt Diesel]

Quote: Originally Posted by steph

Ok now i have seen my colts ratings, i'm quite frustrated by some of them. Spectacular catch for Marvin: 94, Reggie: 90, Dallas: 72 !!! That's quite high rating for Marvin and Reggie, but when you see Randy Moss with a 98, it's not high enough!! Marvin should be 100 in spectacular catch (Catch against the patriots this year...) and his catch in traffic rating should go down from 95 to 85 beacause it's not his main quality. Reggie should be around 95 in spectacular catch. And Dallas Clark should have at least 90 ! (Even Champ bailey has 80 or something in this rating!) And the worst might be Bob Sanders 84 hit power rating !!!! WTF ??? You mean 94 !!

Whats 4 points in either direction really gonna accomplish? I am not attacking you but using it as an example. Would we actually see the difference between a 96 and 100 spec catch?

[Kohlstar20]

How outdated are the rosters in this game? Frank Walker isn't even on the Packers according to the ratings and they signed him way back in March.

[cam780]

Quote: Originally Posted by Kohlstar20

How outdated are the rosters in this game? Frank Walker isn't even on the Packers according to the ratings and they signed him way back in March.

Whose Frank Walker?

PS That may be your answer ...

[JAKEHB20]

Quote: Originally Posted by cam780

Whose Frank Walker? PS That may be your answer ...

PS he is basically the packers only free agent move and possibly our nickelback this year.

[cam780]

Quote: Originally Posted by steph

Ok now i have seen my colts ratings, i'm quite frustrated by some of them. Spectacular catch for Marvin: 94, Reggie: 90, Dallas: 72 !!! That's quite high rating for Marvin and Reggie, but when you see Randy Moss with a 98, it's not high enough!! Marvin should be 100 in spectacular catch (Catch against the patriots this year...) and his catch in traffic rating should go down from 95 to 85 beacause it's not his main quality. Reggie should be around 95 in spectacular catch. And Dallas Clark should have at least 90 ! (Even Champ bailey has 80 or something in this rating!) And the worst might be Bob Sanders 84 hit power rating !!!! WTF ??? You mean 94 !!

Disclaimer: I am being a homer on this post

The way I look at it the Colts are more known for being consistent then having those Wow catches. Marvin Harrison's had a few but he's also had his share of ordinary catches followed by a quick slide. Moss' career is filled with those Al Micheal's "he did what?!?" moments. I honestly don't think that any TE deserves the spectacular catch weapon. And Sanders is scrappy he's great against the run I'd give him a boost just not up to 94.