1up Review 9.0 Xbox 360 8.5 PS3

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by Behindshadows2

Review not surprising....Go EA...sell this baby up. EA Sports Madden 08 no referees, no chain gang, no commentary. and no John Madden, no online leagues.. but everything else. Its in the Game.

Of all those listed, only commentary irritates me.

[DLaren]

Quote: Originally Posted by Tully

Thats not true. Go back and look at their reviews. 1up.com gave Madden 06 a 7.4 Madden 07 a 7.0Madden 08 a 9.0 So how the heck do you get they're too generous with this game. Get real

Good post! Now I'm really feelin this review...

[sportdan30]

Quote: Originally Posted by QB16

I feel for PS3 players. They spent all of that money and all they get is inferior games, and develop a need to scramble and validate their purchase every time a new problem pops up. It's not fair. My Brother is a PS3 sufferer and he went into shock with how (bad) he thought APF played and felt... he nearly went into an unstoppable tirade when he found out Madden was only going to be 30 frames. Even with all of that, and after considering it to the point of almost doing it, he won't trade his PS3 for a 360. It makes me sad; it's like watching an addict knowing he needs help but just can't muster up the strength to overcome it. All I know is, NCAA stunk at 30 frames on 360 last year, and Madden '07 wasn't all it could've been in 30FPS. I admire the optimism of PS3 guys, but I'm sorry, these football games at 30FPS just don't get it done. Not anymore. Smooth gameplay is what it's all about.

I have a lot of faith that NCAA and Madden will run @ 60fps next season. If not, that's when I'll rethink my PS3 purchase. Until then, I'm enjoying the best baseball video game on any gaming console....ever. That's right. MLB The Show baby. And it's a Sony exclusive. Tell your bro to hang in there. Afterall, NCAA wasn't all that it was cracked up to be, and Madden is still missing key components to a great game.

[Bacardi151]

Since people cant seem to stick to the topic, locked.