QB Ratings

[K_GUN]

Trent Edwards AWR rating is WAAY off....that's more like Losman....edwards is a stanford man

[blackngoldfan]

Carson Palmer, QB accuracy of 95? He's good, but he got Chad Johnson knocked out about 4 times last season. Lol

[JBucc]

Quote: Originally Posted by blackngoldfan

Carson Palmer, QB accuracy of 95? He's good, but he got Chad Johnson knocked out about 4 times last season. Lol

Not so sure those weren't on purpose

[blackngoldfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by JBucc

Not so sure those weren't on purpose

Ha Ha. You may be right. "YOU WANT THE F'ING BALL,THEN HERE IT COMES!!!!"

[a4reak]

Quote: Originally Posted by blackngoldfan

Ha Ha. You may be right. "YOU WANT THE F'ING BALL,THEN HERE IT COMES!!!!"

I would never take that clown Johnson on my team, you may remember this but two years ago when the Bengals played you guys at Pittsburgh on SNF. Near the end of the game its like 4th and 13 and Johnson runs a 9 yard out then hops out of bounds instead of diving for the first down. They then show Palmer staring at him like WTF are you doing and Johnosn just slaps his hands together as if he forgot the down and distance. He is so overrated also. He will have a 4 TD game vs the Browns to give his stats the illusion of a great yr. He will put up of 3 monster weeks, 7 good weeks and 6 meh games and everyone sees teh stats and sees a top 5 WR but I know the deal

[Scott]

Heres how I think the overalls should be.....

Brady & P. Manning - 99
Palmer - 97
Roethlisberger - 95
Romo - 94
Brees - 94
Garrard - 93
Hasselbeck - 93
McNabb - 91
Rivers - 90
E. Manning - 89
Anderson - 86
Cutler - 86
Campbell - 85
Garcia - 83
Delhomme - 82
Edwards - 81
Pennington - 80
Schaub - 80
Young - 80
Rodgers - 79
Grossman - 79
Kitna - 79
Russell - 78
Leinart - 77
Flacco - 77
Jackson - 76
Huard - 75
McCown - 74
Smith - 74
Redman - 72

and Rookies...
Ryan - 78
Flacco - 77
Brohm - 74
Henne - 72
Booty - 72
Ainge - 69
Dixon - 69
Woodson - 68
Brennan - 68
Johnson - 67
Flynn - 66

[a4reak]

Quote: Originally Posted by Scott

Heres how I think the overalls should be..... Brady & P. Manning - 99 Palmer - 97 Roethlisberger - 95 Romo - 94 Brees - 94 Garrard - 93 Hasselbeck - 93 McNabb - 91 Rivers - 90 E. Manning - 89 Anderson - 86 Cutler - 86 Campbell - 85 Garcia - 83 Delhomme - 82 Edwards - 81 Pennington - 80 Schaub - 80 Young - 80 Rodgers - 79 Grossman - 79 Kitna - 79 Russell - 78 Leinart - 77 Flacco - 77 Jackson - 76 Huard - 75 McCown - 74 Smith - 74 Redman - 72 and Rookies... Ryan - 78 Flacco - 77 Brohm - 74 Henne - 72 Booty - 72 Ainge - 69 Dixon - 69 Woodson - 68 Brennan - 68 Johnson - 67 Flynn - 66

Couple things, no way you can raise palmer to a 97 with the above average year he had last season, and Eli should get a little more love maybe 90 or 91. He did beat the 3 best teams in the NFL last year on the road and at a neutral site and no way you put Rivers over him. Garcia had a very effiecient year last year, 87 is fair, Andeson I would give an 88. The rookies and rest seem spot on

[Scott]

Quote: Originally Posted by a4reak

Couple things, no way you can raise palmer to a 97 with the above average year he had last season, and Eli should get a little more love maybe 90 or 91. He did beat the 3 best teams in the NFL last year on the road and at a neutral site and no way you put Rivers over him. Garcia had a very effiecient year last year, 87 is fair, Andeson I would give an 88. The rookies and rest seem spot on

Well this is just my opinion, and who knows if Anderson & Eli's years were just flukes...I do agree with you on Garcia, he could be upped a little bit.